Travel Mapping

Highway Data Discussion => In-progress Highway Systems & Work => Completed Highway Systems Threads => Topic started by: theFXexpert on May 07, 2016, 11:38:08 am

Title: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: theFXexpert on May 07, 2016, 11:38:08 am
I am happy to say that the Georgia State Highways system is now in the works. 110 wpt files out of about 471 are drafted and merged into Github. They should be visible in the HB whenever the next site update is run.

Most of the drafted wpts are bannered routes and some important higher numbered routes like 300, 515, and 520.

-- Notes on development philosophy --

- GDOT signs multiplexes more often than not, roads that are multiplexed with US highways are included
- For bannered routes that I could not easily associate with a location, I left the city and abbreviation fields blank.
- Truck routes are omitted.
- Unsigned 400 series routes are omitted. (With exception to signed GA 410 and 404 Spur. GA 400 is not included since it's currently in usansf)

Currently working on bannered routes in descending order. Then I will draft main routes in descending order.

I am happy to take input on labeling errors and waypoint/shaping point placement and correct them.

-- Issues --

- GA 120 is signed as a loop on I-75 at Marietta but all other signage indicates the main 120 goes on the south loop while a 120 Alt takes the north loop. The source linked below says 120 still goes through Roswell St and doesn't show any bannered routes around the area. I am inclined to follow the surface street signage.

- Many times a bannered state route's parent is multiplexed with a US highway. Is it appropriate to label the endpoints of the bannered route (GAXXBus for example) as GAXX_N or USYY_N? I don't feel like I have been consistent in this situation.

-- Sources (Other than OSM) --

- GDOT GeoTRAQS (http://www.dot.ga.gov/DS/Maps/GeoTraqs) - data is five years old though
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: Jim on May 07, 2016, 03:49:19 pm
The first set should now be live in the HB.  As a devel system, users cannot yet map travels.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: rickmastfan67 on May 07, 2016, 07:43:53 pm
- Many times a bannered state route's parent is multiplexed with a US highway. Is it appropriate to label the endpoints of the bannered route (GAXXBus for example) as GAXX_N or USYY_N? I don't feel like I have been consistent in this situation.

Parent of the bannered route.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on May 13, 2016, 10:09:14 am
All of the remaining bannered routes are now on the site. I also fixed some labels in existing routes.

197 / 477 (41.3%) wpt files are now complete. (I found a few extra bannered routes)

The remaining 300 series routes are next to be done.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: yakra on May 13, 2016, 11:05:24 am
GA17Con:
Quote
- For bannered routes that I could not easily associate with a location, I left the city and abbreviation fields blank.
I don't think it's ever been done to have a bannered route without a City Or Abbrev. For my two cents I'm just more comfortable following precedent here, even if the results are imperfect names, somewhere the route doesn't pass through, etc.
Some possibilities include Autney or Warren County...

Interested to hear other CHM/TM veterans' take on this subject as well.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: rickmastfan67 on May 13, 2016, 09:46:44 pm
GA17Con:
Quote
- For bannered routes that I could not easily associate with a location, I left the city and abbreviation fields blank.
I don't think it's ever been done to have a bannered route without a City Or Abbrev. For my two cents I'm just more comfortable following precedent here, even if the results are imperfect names, somewhere the route doesn't pass through, etc.
Some possibilities include Autney or Warren County...

Interested to hear other CHM/TM veterans' take on this subject as well.

I-69 Future in KY at first had no 'City/Abbrev' till a segment in the middle became a full Interstate.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: yakra on May 14, 2016, 02:39:34 am
I-69 Future in KY at first had no 'City/Abbrev' till a segment in the middle became a full Interstate.
And now, it has a city, but still no abbrev.
Were there ever any US Highway examples? State highways?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: si404 on May 14, 2016, 05:41:43 am
When (10 years ago?!?) Tim made the gbnm and gbnam files, he put abbreviations on the M6 Toll and the Ax(M) routes (despite, other than the A1(M), they were unique). When we moved to TM, I stripped them off as it was unnecessary filler - because they aren't bannered routes and shouldn't have been treated as such.

KY I-69 always seemed to not have a city field mostly as it covered the whole state.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: yakra on May 14, 2016, 12:50:22 pm
When (10 years ago?!?) Tim made the gbnm and gbnam files, he put abbreviations on the M6 Toll and the Ax(M) routes (despite, other than the A1(M), they were unique). When we moved to TM, I stripped them off as it was unnecessary filler - because they aren't bannered routes and shouldn't have been treated as such.
Not very familiar with the UK, and have spent very little time looking at it, but I agree with what you did.

Quote
KY I-69 always seemed to not have a city field mostly as it covered the whole state.
I looked over the CHM hwyupdates page last night, and there used to be another KY I-69Fut once upon a time. So there was one with, and one without, an abbrev. Looking again, apparently there was just the original I-69Fut; I-69FutMad was added later. So it doesn't appear to have been purposefully following the state hwy "One vanilla, rest with Abbrevs" convention (E.G. ME113, ME113Fry, etc.). Maybe when USAIF was first created, it wasn't foreseen that there'd be more than one Future Interstate segment with a given number within a state. I dunno man, I didn't do it.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on May 16, 2016, 11:07:34 am
The update last night now includes All of the 300 series routes plus two GA6 business routes that I missed.
240 / 479 (50.1%) wpts are now plotted.
200 series routes are next.

GA17Con:
I don't think it's ever been done to have a bannered route without a City Or Abbrev. For my two cents I'm just more comfortable following precedent here, even if the results are imperfect names, somewhere the route doesn't pass through, etc.
Some possibilities include Autney or Warren County...

Interested to hear other CHM/TM veterans' take on this subject as well.
Looking at Google satellite imagery, It doesn't look like there is anything where the Autney lable is. I am open to using county names though.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on May 25, 2016, 02:26:52 pm
Reminder for myself: Things to include on next pull request:

- Fix GA6BusDal label self-reference.
- Extend GA25SprBru to GA99
- Add shaping point on GA40 at St. Marys
- Fix labels on GA187
- Fix duplicate labels MainSt/CenAve on GA520
- Fix labels on GA204
- Add GA242SprSan
- Add GA230ConByr
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: Presidentman on June 13, 2016, 05:02:46 pm
In re: GA7AltVal & GA7BusVal

Having lived in Valdosta for twelve years, here are a couple of changes I would make:


Hope this helps. I am also willing to help out on this project as well as in FL as those are the two states where I've spent most of my time. In GA, I am best in Valdosta vicinity & south GA in general and NE part of Metro Atlanta (specifically Gwinnett County).
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on June 13, 2016, 08:30:29 pm
In re: GA7AltVal & GA7BusVal

Having lived in Valdosta for twelve years, here are a couple of changes I would make:

  • Add a waypoint at Brookwood Dr. on GA7Alt as this is the main thoroughfare for Valdosta State Univ. as well as the main connector between downtown and I-75 aside from US 84.
  • The waypoint marked "OldGA125" on GA7Bus is actually still GA 125.
- Sure. I can add Brookwood Dr.
- Google Streetview images from June 2015 show GA125 ending at US41 (Perimeter Rd). Has it been extended?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on June 15, 2016, 10:39:26 pm
200 series routes and the above mentioned fixes are up.

- Noticed a label self-reference on GA236 from the datacheck page. Will be fixed with the next batch which will be the 100 series.
- GA236 also has a partial interchange with I-85 HOV lanes (no ramps to general lanes). There's no corresponding point on I-85, so I left it out.
- GA246 crosses the NC border several times before turning becoming NC106. For simplicity, I kept it within the GA side of the border.

EDIT:
- US341 was mislabeled twice as US319 on GA230.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: Markkos1992 on June 16, 2016, 05:17:59 pm
- GA236 also has a partial interchange with I-85 HOV lanes (no ramps to general lanes). There's no corresponding point on I-85, so I left it out.

Is there a good reason to not have a point at I-85?  (Looking at I-66, I-95, and I-495 in NoVA we have points at interchanges that only connect to HOV/HOT lanes, though on I-495 we seem to leave out a couple at Tysons due to the proximity of VA 7, VA 123, and VA 267).

Looking at the .lists files for I-85 and GA 236, maybe have one on GA 236 and not on I-85 (as two points suffice nearby)??
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: rickmastfan67 on June 16, 2016, 05:48:15 pm
- GA236 also has a partial interchange with I-85 HOV lanes (no ramps to general lanes). There's no corresponding point on I-85, so I left it out.

It must be a reality new 'interchange' for it not to be in I-85's file.  Just so you know theFXexpert, we do normally include these.  Most of the time, we just estimate an exit number (if none are posted) for these types of interchanges.

GA-236 should most defiantly have a point there for I-85.

So, I'm thinking of making a point for GA-236 in I-85's file tentatively as '87A' since GA-400's exit is 87 (well, at least going NB on I-85 it is).  Plus I'm thinking that GA-400's point should be recentered some, especially since it was acquired from before the 'missing' ramps were added there.  I'll get the changes done to this later tonight, and then you can copy the coordinates into the GA-236 file.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: rickmastfan67 on June 16, 2016, 11:35:31 pm
Alright, I-85 fixes here are done.
https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/618

Also quickly added in a new interchange I spotted on GA-400/US-19, 4C.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on June 19, 2016, 05:23:38 pm
Submitted my fixes: https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/627
I also took a crack at adding names to the remaining bannered routes.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: Presidentman on June 22, 2016, 03:21:47 pm
- Google Streetview images from June 2015 show GA125 ending at US41 (Perimeter Rd). Has it been extended?

It appears to have been truncated there per GDOT (http://www.dot.ga.gov/DriveSmart/MapsData/Documents/CountyMaps/Lowndes.pdf (http://www.dot.ga.gov/DriveSmart/MapsData/Documents/CountyMaps/Lowndes.pdf)). This is a recent change I guess because it was GA 125 for as long as I can remember.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: Presidentman on June 22, 2016, 03:58:34 pm
In GA52 Alt (Chatsworth), "GA 255" should be "GA 225".
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on June 24, 2016, 01:49:10 pm
In GA52 Alt (Chatsworth), "GA 255" should be "GA 225".
Thanks - https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/639
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: kjslaughter on July 15, 2016, 03:32:30 pm
Just found this successor site to the old CHM site today.  I always wanted my home state routes included, but there are so many I guess it just was delayed.  For reference, I live in Atlanta GA area and have loved maps and roads for all 39 years of my life.  I've travelled all over the state in an effort to visit all 159 counties.  As part of that love, I found an e-mail address for the GA DOT and got a file listing GA state highway mileages by county back in 2013.  It didn't show all of the overlay mileages, but I was able to compare to both the official state map and online detailed county maps to build an Excel file of mileages for all Georgia routes.  I'm happy to use that file and my own personal knowledge to validate the Georgia state highway development.  I know all of the overlays will make this a challenge.

Are you planning to map all of the routes and just accept the high number of overlays with both US highways and other GA routes?  I'd suggest doing all the routes and letting the overlaps fall where they may for ease of documenting and maintaining updates in the future.

In addition, you initial question about 120 is valid.  The DOT rerouted a bunch of routes around Marietta a couple of years ago.  GA 120 now follows the old south loop and a new designation, GA 120 ALT, follows the north loop.  They have never updated the interstate signs, most likely because the state is trying to slowly update all the interstate signs to the new font.  To add to the confusion, a new designation of GA 3 Conn was given to Roswell Rd. from US 41 east to the point where the loops join.  Roswell St. through downtown Marietta is no longer a state highway.  In addition, Google doesn't show this, but they moved GA 5 off of Cherokee and Church St. and instead routed with US 41 and GA 120 Alt around the downtown square.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on July 15, 2016, 09:30:17 pm
I appreciate the feedback. Google's street view confirms the routing of those routes is just like what you described and I will stick with that.
Are you planning to map all of the routes and just accept the high number of overlays with both US highways and other GA routes?  I'd suggest doing all the routes and letting the overlaps fall where they may for ease of documenting and maintaining updates in the future.
Yes. This is exactly what I plan to do.

Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on December 04, 2016, 01:10:25 am
Routes 150 -199 have been posted incrementally the past couple weeks.

343/482 (71.2%) wpt files are complete.

- Reroutes of GA 195 and GA 196 required new points on US19 and US84 respectively. See -> https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/935
- I also found GA 162 Conn and added that.

GDOT removed the GeoTRAQS page from their site and I had to dig to find the same data here -> http://www.arcgis.com/home/webmap/viewer.html?url=https%3A%2F%2Fegis.dot.ga.gov%2Farcgis%2Frest%2Fservices%2FSTATE_ROUTES%2FMapServer&source=sd
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on December 13, 2016, 12:11:36 pm
All of the 3-digit routes are drafted with the completion of 100 -149. Only 2-digit routes remain.

388/482 (80.5%) wpt files are complete.

Some notes on this set:

- GA119 and 144 are mostly inaccessible with streetview within Fort Stewart. There is one section of GA119 that appears inaccessible to the public. GA144 is signed and publicly accessible within the base (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.9045377,-81.5966682,3a,28.5y,36.44h,87.67t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sDPMYnwlmXgFNabP18xxe-g!2e0!7i13312!8i6656?hl=en) and GIS says both routes are continuous through the base. I didn't put many visible waypoints inside since the tank trails are off-limits.
- GA136 has large switchbacks around Trenton. The shaping is within tolerance, but I'm not sure if it would be a good idea to shape them for better distance approximation.
- GA138 may have been extended past US78 to GA11 in Monroe, but I can't definitively tell with streetview.
- GA142 is signed east-west for its entire length but mile marker 0 is located at the southeast end of the route. I have ordered the points as if it was east-west for now.

Other notes for other things/outlook:
- I think I got the idea of how the SVG shields work, so I tried to make the GA shields with some code from Wikimedia Commons. -> https://github.com/TravelMapping/Web/pull/118
- Sugarloaf Pkwy in Lawrenceville looks like a good candidate for select named freeways. US29/GA316 could use a waypoint at it regardless. I didn't put a point there when I did GA316 since I didn't want to break the concurrency.
- GA56 Spur in Augusta appears to have been deleted. US1, 25, 78, and 278 will need that point changed to DouBarPkwy
- Cleveland Bypass: Phase I recently completed -> http://www.nowhabersham.com/first-phase-of-cleveland-bypass-opens/ US129 will need a point at the south end.
- Avalon Bypass (GA17): was supposed to be complete last spring, but streetview still shows it incomplete as of July.
- Rome's west bypass is signed as GA1 Loop but there doesn't seem to be enough recent streetview to tell if it's contiguous or not with the rest of GA1 Loop anywhere.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: Jim on December 13, 2016, 02:16:33 pm
- I think I got the idea of how the SVG shields work, so I tried to make the GA shields with some code from Wikimedia Commons. -> https://github.com/TravelMapping/Web/pull/118

Live on the site and working, as far as I can tell.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: rickmastfan67 on December 19, 2016, 01:52:32 am
- Sugarloaf Pkwy in Lawrenceville looks like a good candidate for select named freeways. US29/GA316 could use a waypoint at it regardless. I didn't put a point there when I did GA316 since I didn't want to break the concurrency.
- GA56 Spur in Augusta appears to have been deleted. US1, 25, 78, and 278 will need that point changed to DouBarPkwy

If you want to make small changes like this, go for it man!  I have no problems with that. ;)
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on January 06, 2017, 10:20:34 am
Routes 75-99 are all up now.

412/483 (85.3%) wpts complete.

System mileage is at 8968.67 miles with many lengthy routes still left to plot.

Routes 50-74 will be in the next set.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on January 13, 2017, 09:34:51 am
Routes 50-74 are now up.

System length now exceeds 10,000 miles.

436/484 (90.1%) wpts complete.

Next set is 26-49.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on January 17, 2017, 11:33:30 pm
Routes 25-49 are up.

461/485 (95.1%) wpts complete.
System length over 13,000 miles now.

The last set will have 1-24 and will also address some datacheck errors/false positives. After that, I would like to have it promoted to preview.

Note on GA28 (the Augusta segment): It is signed east/west but the mile markers start at the southern end. The Pine Mountain segment is signed north/south with mile marker agreement. So, to also keep consistent with the Pine Mountain segment and the SC28 files, the Augusta segment is arranged as if it were north/south.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on January 19, 2017, 02:27:41 pm
Things I need to remind myself to add/fix before sending to preview:

- US411 needs waypoint for GA20 realignment at Cartersville.
- GA21Bus seems to have newly appeared (about a year ago) in Newington. (Streetview only shows north end)
- Points for GA47Con on US78 and US378 at Washington.
- GA49 was put on US129 instead of US41Bus in Macon; Also has label selfref error.
- Extend GA306 to GA20 in Cumming.
- Make sure US19/400 intersection labels are consistent.
- GA81: GA20 labels could be improved.
- GA59: Add point for GA17.
- Attempt to resolve various visible distance errors.
- GA78: Change point GA15/57 to US319_S
- I-985/US23 Add Exit 17.
- Add GA6 Spur at Austell.

*Will edit if more things are found.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - In Development
Post by: theFXexpert on January 21, 2017, 08:35:57 pm
The above issues have been addressed and usaga is now in preview.
Title: Add waypoint on GA 74
Post by: kjslaughter on January 23, 2017, 03:02:55 pm
I'm going through all of the GA Highways previews (which look great and I can't believe the work this must have taken!).  Suggestion to add a waypoint on GA 18/74/109 east of Woodbury, GA just west of the Flint River crossing.  A Georgia scenic route goes through the area and intersects GA 74 as part of River Cove Rd.  I've driven this route before and the scenic routes are shown on state highway maps.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Jim on January 23, 2017, 09:47:10 pm
GA 42 and GA 236: NDruHillRd -> DruHillRd by the "leave off directions" rule.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: theFXexpert on February 03, 2017, 12:40:08 pm
The above posts have been addressed https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/1100
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 15, 2017, 02:16:20 pm
The start of suggested feedback for you to consider with the Georgia State Route set...

GA 1: DCIAirPk point necessary?; ChrMisCRd -> ArlRd?; GA 37 point needs to be moved west to new alignment of US 27/GA 1?; PhiRd -> CouLinRd?; +X012 move to Riverbend Rd?; add pt (or move +X015) at Hancock Rd in northern Columbus (connection to US 80 exit)?; +020(US27) -> Callaway Gardens?; EDepSt in LaGrange necessary?; add pt (or move +X024) at DavisRd Bypass n of LaGrange?; move +X025 to BobPurRd?; move +X026 to GumTreeAirRd?; move +X027 to WadSt?; mpve +X029 to MonMilRd?; move +X030 to MorChuRd?; move +X032 to HunRd?; move +X034 to HutRd?; WestRomeByp is signed as GA 1 Loop from US 27 SB; RivPkwyNE -> RivPkwy?; move X+039 to SilHilRd?; GA100_End -> GA100/114?; move +X042 to MouVieRd?; WarSt off-center?; LeeAMillRd -> LeeGorMillRd?; DodAve->McFarAve_N?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 16, 2017, 11:18:27 pm
GA 1 Bus (Blakely): +X02 moved to 1st Kolomoki Rd?
GA 1 Bus (Cedartown): Move Piedmont Ave to John Hand Rd?

The West Rome Bypass/Horseleg Creek Rd is signed as GA 1 Loop from limited GMSV at US 27 SB and also at Black Creek Rd

GA 2: move +X002 to Cherokee Valley Rd?; +X003 -> WooRd?; OldUS441 -> OldUS411 or OldFedRd; OrvLaneDr -> OrvLanDr?; US19/129 -> US19/129_N; US129Trk->PatHarMemDr; new point needed for US19/129_S at Glenn Gooch Bypass east of Blairsville (US 19/129 rerouted in Blairsville); CroCreCon is pretty off center; HopDr->HooDr; AppTr is pretty far off;

GA 3: point needed between GA202 and GA188 (out of shape), suggest McMillan Rd; +X002 needs to be moved south to fix out of shape, suggest MicrowaveRd; move +X008 to HarrisFarmRd?; +X009 is pretty far off and could be moved to Wainwright Rd; need a point btw +X009 and GA208 (out of shape), suggest wilsonRd; GA208 off center; move +X010 to WesleyChurch Rd?; consider +X012 -> OldGA22Spr  which was GA22Spr until 2005 and connected to US 80?; move +X013 to AllenRd?; move +X016 to Vega Rd or Sandefur Rd?; point needed between GA18 and US 41 (out of shape), suggest the northern Patton Rd; most metro Atlanta/Marietta points have cardinal direction suffixes; GA176 seems to be decommissioned?  not on 2017 Official GA map or in GMSV; need point at Union Grove Rd to connect to I-75 exit 310?; move +X021 to NanceSpringRd?; HosCon->ChaRd?; TN/GA appears to be off but does match the TN US 41 point
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 17, 2017, 07:02:07 pm
GA3ConAtl is a waypoint on US19-41/GA 3 files but does not have its own .wpt file.  It is Tara Blvd between I-75(235) and US 19/41.  Note as far as I can tell there are no GA 3 CONN postings but it is on an inset of the 2013 Clayton County Map.

GA 4: add a point between US1/23Bus and +X004 (out of shape), suggest Dixie Union Rd?; JamRd point should be moved to Corinth Church Rd (out of shape segment)?; GA15_S point is off?; need a point between MainSt and LenRd (out of shape), suggest DunnsLake or Wayne Jones Rd?; GA130 is very far off; move +X006 to 5PointsRd?; US 1/GA 4 has a new bypass of Oak Park and therefore the GA86_E and GA46/86 points need to be moved to HarringtonRd and the new GA 46/86 jct respectively; move +X011 to either Greens Old Mill Rd or Wadley Coleman Lake Rd?; US1BusWad_S is very far off (same with the US1Bus/GA4Bus files); LFBriAPRd->CamRd?; SteMatRd->WooAcaRd?; 

GA 5: StaRd->StaPoiRd?; move +X002 to Old5NotchRd?; Move +X004 to GilesRd?; Move +X005 to BrightStarRd?; AusPSRd->LoveRd?; move +X007 to WestsideDr?; Delete or move +X008 to GarrisonRd?

GA 6: move +X013 to enonRd?

GA6BusRoc: EuhSt->MLKAve?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 18, 2017, 10:33:11 am
GA 7: KinBrgRd->CenAve?; GA32_E point is off (could also be merged with the 32Con point which is not signed as such); 11thSt_S ->JoeWriDr?; 6thSt is not at 6th St...a few choices of what to call it; I-75BusCor_N->FarMarRd?  I-75Bus not posted from anywhere that I could find...?; move +006 to LibChuRd?; move +X010 to CloLakeRd?; SugHillRd is not a road...change to +X point?; move +X011 to OldUS41?;

GA 8: move +X002 to PollardRd?; AusPSRd->LoveSt?; CopLakeRd->CooLakeRd; Move +X007 to PebRd?; PeaSt->WestPeaSt? (PeaSt is nearby); Move +X008 to JohnsonRd?; Move +X010 to DaculaRd?; Move +X011 to WallRd?; need point btw US78/78Bus_W and GA10Lp at OconeeConnector (connects to 10loop)?; PetSt->Ga10Lp(9)?; Move +X019 to Hartwell Speedway Rd?

GA 9: GA236->LinDr (GA 236 ends at GA 237 east of here); WinPkwy point needs to be moved to what appears to be a new alignment; +X002->HambyRd?; Move +X003 to SilverCityRd?; Move +X006 to YahoolaRd?;

GA 10: move +X000 to HowardAve Connector?; move +X004 to Pete Dickens Rd?; GA22 N-S should be E-W; GA77 E-W should be N-S; WillWinRd->WillWynRd?; GA44_S -> GA44_W?; US1Con point should be deleted (the only ramp to Bay St starts at the previous US25Bus point) as the ramp is signed as US 25BUs/GA 28?  Bay St itself is not in the primary system.

GA 10BusWas: LinCir moved to 3rd St? (connects to US 78);
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 18, 2017, 09:23:03 pm
GA 11:  move +X006 to PineLevelChurchRd?; move +X008 to JackAllenRd?; GA49_S and Houston Rd points are now pretty far off due to intersection relocations; move +X013 to nearby roads?; move +X015 to MeadRd?; +GrayByp can be turned into a waypoint as the bypass opened in late 2016..however I cannot find any evidence it has been assigned a primary route number; move +020 to Liberty Church Rd?; move +X021 to County Line Rd?; CR213 ->2ndAve? (CR 213 not signed as such); move +X022 to Thurman Baccus Rd?; move +X025 to Hancock Br Rd?; move +X026 to Ebenezer Church Rd?; need a point between GA323 and I-985 (out of shape), suggest Gaines Mill Rd; Blairsville points need relocating as route now uses bypass around the east to US 76 then back west

GA 11BusPer: move +X001 to MorningsideDr?

GA 11BypLak: GA135_N point is off

GA 12: GA260 ->GleRd (GA260 ends at I-20); HigTrl point is off; Move +X007 to SwordsRd?; Move +X008 to Carey Station Rd?; GA44_S -> GA44_W;

GA 13: need point for GA 332 (just east of GA 53);

GA 14: move +X001 to Old WestPointRd?; need point between GA100_N and CowHeaRd (out of shape), suggest RallRd; move +X004 to Cedar Creek Rd?; MainSt_Uni->WatSt; move +X007 to Stonewall Tell Rd?; NavAve->NabAve;

GA 15: need a point between MainSt and LenRd (out of shape), suggest DunnsLake or Wayne Jones Rd?; move +X007 to BraddyRd?; move +X015 to EleyRd?; GA44_S -> GA44_W; PetSt->Ga10Lp(9)?; move +X026 to CooperFarmRd or delete?; move +X027 to BereaRd?; move +X028 to WhiteHillSchRd?; move +X031 to ApplePieRidgeRd?; LevGroRd ->GA15Con; need point btw US441BusCla_N and GA15Lp_S (out of shape?), suggest Travis Smith Rd in Turnerville; OldUS441Lak_S point is pretty off; move +X037 to campcreekRd?;
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 19, 2017, 03:16:50 pm
GA 16: +X005 ->PopSt?; move +X006 to HighFallsRd?; delete +X007 and move JacRd to Bailey Jester Rd?;

GA 17: LFBriAPRd->CamRd?; +X015->FaiRd?; +X018->Hills Crossing?;

GA 17AltToc: +X000 ->BlaMouRd_E?; +X002 -> BlaMouRd_W?

GA17BusWas: GA44_N -> GA44_E

GA 18: +X001 -> ParRd?; EastMilRd->MilRd?; Add a point at Jenkins Rd btw I-75 and US 23 (connection to I-75)?; need a pont at Gray Byp right before US129_S; GA18Spr (Gordon) appears to have been decommissioned btw 2008-12...rename as MaconRd?;

GA 18SprGor: delete route? - see last note under GA 18

GA 19: +X004 ->StPauChuRd?; +X006->OchRd?; OldMacRd point is off; GA96_W -> GA96_E; The ColSt point in Macon is in an odd location, as both directions of 41Bus/19 pass through the Georgia Ave/College St intersection.  If the thought was to reflect the subsequent split routing west of here, suggest adding a point located at Monroe and Tinsley Ln; move KloRd point to PateRd which has ramps from I-75?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 19, 2017, 09:10:26 pm
GA 20: +Xwest rome bypass ->Ga1LpSW; shaping point needed between ReyBriRd and US41_N; GA369 point is off; SwuDamRd->SuwDamRd; +X010 -> BriscoeRd?; +X013 ->KelleytownRd?;

GA 21: GA21Bus_SylS -> GA21BusSyl_S;

GA 22: move CouRd point to TealRd?; move +X007 to the old GA22Spr near US 19 (existed until 2005)?; need a point at Gray Bypass east of town?; GA77_E -> GA77_N; GA77_W -> GA77_S;

GA 22SprCol: +X001 ->UniAve?

GA 23: DonRd->GeoSwiRd?; move +X007 to CanoocheeRd?;

GA 24: move +X009 to StembridgeRd?;

US 278 TrkMad/GA12TrkMad:  There is a fully signed US 278 Truck and GA 12 Truck for Madison that uses GA 24 Spur, US 441 south, then US 441 Bypass north back around to US 278/GA 12

GA 25: GA25SprDar -> Old GA25Spr or ForKGeoDr? (route decommissioned); move +X007 to ChurchillRd?; GA57/99 -> GA99 (GA 57 END shield is at I-95); add point at Harris Neck Rd (was GA 131 until 1990)?; move +X010 to Lewis Frasier Rd?; move +X014 to Canebrake Rd?;

GA 26: GA90_N -> GA90_W; GA90_S -> GA90_E;  OldMacRd point is off; move +X012 to OldReiRd?; move +X013 to WillHillRd?; move +X015 to ZetRd?

GA 27: CR76 ->SemRd? (CR 76 not marked as such); GA90_N -> GA90_W; LivFarmRd->OweRd;

GA 29: move +X001 to BraddyRd?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: oscar on February 19, 2017, 10:11:02 pm
Similar running log like I'm doing for Tennessee. This is just for things I spot while reconstructing my state route travels. I'll let you know when I'm finished.

GA 122: US19 => US19/84

GA 133: Request point between GA133 and CanRd, for CR44 (better) or Hempstead Church Rd. Either would approximate my turnaround point, which is somewhere (not necessarily an intersection) north of the county line. We haven't done non-intersection county line points,and I don't suggest changing that; thus my search for nearby intersections.

US 1 and GA 86:  i agree with Mapmikey that both routes need to be adjusted, to reflect the new US 1 bypass of Oak Park. Alas, GMSV hasn't run a camera car through Oak Park since the US 1 reroute, and the online mapping is confused about the numbers other than GA 86 for the old route. ince theFXexpert seems to live not too far from Oak Park, maybe some early spring field-checking is in order?

GA 18 and GA 109:  In GA18 file, waypoint GA109_E is west of waypoint GA109 -- shouldn't they be GA109_W and GA109_E respectively? Similar issue in GA109 file for GA18 points.

GA 299: Waypoints are in east to west order, rather than usual west to east.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 20, 2017, 04:43:43 pm
30-39:

GA 30: move +X003 to Pleasant View Rd?; GA215_W -> GA215_N; GA215_E -> GA215_S; US319/441_N point needs to be moved east to new configuration; move +X007 to ChurchSt?;

GA 31: GA31Con point is at wrong road.  It is on Murray Blvd near +X003 (GA31Conlak.wpt is on the correct routing, however); US280_E point needs to be moved east to new configuration

GA 32: GA520 -> GA45/520?; need a point added after US19_N for nearby GA 195;

GA 33: move +X000 to OzellRd?; move +X001 to Salem Rd or Airline Rd?; GA82->US82;

GA 35: move +X004 to KellRd?; need a point at RidgeAve (direct connection to I-75) in Tifton?;

GA 35ConTho: No .wpt file for this route

GA 36: SunnRd->SunRd; GA74_S -> GA74_E; GA168->GA162;

GA 37: US27 point needs to be moved west to new alignment of US 27/GA 1?; move +X005 to BayRd;

GA 37TrkCam:  There is a fully signed GA 37 TRUCK in both directions using Oakland Ave and a bit of US 19 in Camelia
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 20, 2017, 08:26:23 pm


GA 40SprStM:  Camden County map shows GA 40 SPUR ending at the north Mush Bluff Rd jct (appears to be no signage in the field anywhere)

GA 41: need a shaping point between DrBrownRd and US80_W
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 23, 2017, 09:21:13 pm
GA 42 to GA 52

GA 42: OldBetRd point is pretty far off; move +X007 to DeanPatrickRd?; move +X008 to MLKBlvd?; EllRd->ForPkwy;

GA 44: need a point at the Gray Bypass; MatRd (unpaved) needs to change to a shape point and moved southwest a little to eliminate an out-of-shape section; move +X002 to ScottRd?;

GA 45: need a point (out-of-shape) between GA 200 and GA 216, suggest Billy Newberry Rd;

GA 62 TrkArl: There is a fully signed GA 62 Truck in Arlington (could be argued there is also a fully signed GA 216 TRUCK too...45 TRUCK is 100% current with GA 45 ALT though)

GA 46: US1_S point needs to be moved south to new location;

GA 47: move +X007 to NealMillRd?

GA 49: US19_S and Houston Rd points are now pretty far off due to intersection relocations; move +X009 to nearby roads?; move +X011 to MeadRd?

GA 51: move +X004 to NewProspectRd?

GA 52: OldUS441->OldUS411
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 24, 2017, 08:57:49 pm
GA 53-74

GA 53: GA82_W -> GA82?

GA 54: move +X003 to Ebenezer Rd?

GA 60: LowStarCRd->OldDialRd? (no GMSV in area)

GA 60BusDah: move AndRd point to CampWahsegaRd?

GA 62: Both GA45Alt points are missing in Arlington

GA 67: Need shaping point north of GA 46; GA121_S point needs to be moved south to new intersection location; GA23_S point needs to be moved south to new intersection location (I missed this on my GA 23 review)

GA 70: +X000 -> Jim Starr Rd?; need a point at Cochran Mill Rd (just south of GA 92)?  This was where GA 70 left GA 154 until about 2007;

GA 72: +X000 ->Middleton Church Rd?

GA 73: LakRd -> ParSt_W?; GA21Bus_W -> GA21Bus_N; GA21Bus_E -> GA21Bus_S; move +X004 to Harmony Rd?

GA 73BypSta: no .wpt file, however despite it being on the official map it does not seem to be posted anywhere I could find along US 301 BYpass

GA 74: I-575 -> I-475;
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 25, 2017, 02:21:21 pm
GA 75-82

GA75altcle: +X000 -> GloverRd?

GA 77: move +X014 to RockyFordRd?

GA 77conlav: combine +X001 and +X002 into one waypoint at RidgeviewRd?

GA 78: Ruby Rd is not named that in GMSV

GA 80: move +X005 to RicketsonRd?

GA 81: need point at Turner Lake Rd (direct connection to I-20) in Covington?

GA 82: move +X001 to PicklesimonRd?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 25, 2017, 05:48:36 pm
GA 83-105

GA 84: US29->US78

GA 85: Has the GA92_N point moved to new alignment with traffic circle via Hood Ave?

GA 86: US1_N -> US1 and also moved south to relocated intersection; US1_S ->OldUS1

GA 87: US341Bus -> US341Bus_N?; move +X001 to Antioch Church Rd?; WillHenRd->AlbJenRd?; I-75(167A) and I-75(167) points need to be reclassified as CLOSED points (ramps are gone);

GA 88: US25 point has been moved southward

GA 89: move ChaRd (unpaved) point to CR204 (paved)?

GA 90: move +X007 to PineLevelChurchRd?; 6thSt is not at 6th St...a few choices of what to call it; I-75BusCor_N->FarMarRd?  I-75Bus not posted from anywhere that I could find...?

GA 45TrkCol and GA91TrkCol There are fully signed truck routes for GA 45 and GA 91 in Colquitt that follow US 27 and GA 91spr, with GA 45 truck then using GA 91 back into downtown Colquitt
 
GA 92: move +X002 to GozaRd?; need point at Oakley Ind Blvd in Fairburn?  signed as TO I-85; GA154 points add GA 70 label as well?;

GA 93: +X001->RidgeRd?

GA 97: US84Bus_E->US84Bus_W;

GA 100: move +X008 to Monroe MillRd?; LineBraRd->LimeBraRd?

GA 101: OakSt point is pretty far off

GA 102: GA296->GA296_S; need new point for GA296_N 1 block east of 296_S

GA 105: GA184 point is off;
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 25, 2017, 09:35:58 pm
GA 106-126

GA 112:  The 2017 Georgia Official map shows GA 112 ending at the Fall Line Freeway, which is marked as GA 243 east to GA 24 (this also affects the GA 24 and GA 29 files)...?

GA 117: move +X002 to KinnettRd?; FirRd point is very far off; GA257 point if off-center; +X000(GA117) is off

GA 119:  The visible distance error will have to be accepted IMO.  Even if you add a point at Old GA 129 there is still >10 miles to US 280 and there do not seem to be any roads or base entrances along GA 119.

GA 120: EstLp point is pretty far off;

GA 121: move +X011 to CanoocheeRd?; US25_S point needs to be moved south to new intersection location; GA23_S point needs to be moved south to new intersection location;GA88 point has been moved southward; US1Con point should be deleted (the only ramp to Bay St starts at the previous US25Bus point) as the ramp is signed as US 25BUs/GA 28?  Bay St itself is not in the primary system.

GA 122: move +X000 to GatCreRd?; remove +X002 and +X003 and instead put a point at SalemRd?

GA 124: move +X000 to OldFouRd?; GumSprCRd is pretty far off

GA 125: ErnSumRd->EarSumRd

GA 126: EastChiRd->ChiRd?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 26, 2017, 07:43:58 pm
GA 127-137

GA 127: move +X007 to JuicePLantRd?;

GA 129: move +X002 to CannochieRd?

GA 130: move +X001 to Cedar Crossing Vidalia Rd?; US1 point needs to be moved south to new intersection

GA 133: OldAdelRd point needs to be moved to new intersection to the SE

GA 135: CR185->TowBluRd? (CR185 not signed here);

GA 136: +X014->HillCityRd?

GA 137: HenCurRd point needs to be moved SW to new intersection location
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on February 27, 2017, 08:06:21 pm
GA 138-153

GA 138: CamSt -> GA92_N?; +X004 ->HemphillRd?; +X005 ->OldConyersRd?; GA10us->GA10Bus

GA 142: move +X001 to FlatRockRd?

GA 144: a point east of RogRd could be added at Anderson Way which looks like a fully open road but doesn't get rid of the visual distance error over to GA 119;

GA 146: US41->US41/76?

GA151sprrin: US41->US41/76?

US41trkrin: There is a signed US 41 TRUCK that uses GA 151 and GA 151 Spur...very well posted as US 41 TRUCK, only 1 US 76 TRUCK posting at all that I saw in GMSV

GA 153: +X001->Willard Rees Rd?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on March 03, 2017, 10:43:42 pm
GA 154-177

GA 154: need a point at Cochran Mill Rd (just south of GA 92)?  This was where GA 70 left GA 154 until about 2007; move +X003 to Stonewall Tell Rd?; move +X004 to EnonRd?; Has GA154ConAtl been decommissioned?  signs removed at GA154 and not on the official map.  There is one shield leaving I-20

GA 155: move +X004 to TeamonRd?; the GA136Con E-W labels are reversed

GA 158: move +X000 to County LineRd?; HebChuRd point is pretty far off; US441Trk should either be labeled GA158Trk or GA206.  US441Truck is not signed from US441 (e.g. not a true US 441 truck route)

GA 159: move +X001 to Amboy-RebeccaRd?

GA 166: move +X010 to Stonewall Tell Rd?; move +X011 to EnonRd?

GA 177: neither +X001 nor +X002 are needed

GA 177far: all evidence points to GA 177 ending at the dead end (coincides with end of GMSV coverage) - official maps and Charlton County maps show this.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on March 04, 2017, 11:16:51 am
GA 178-204

GA 184: DamRd_S -> DamRd?

GA 190: move +X001 to HinesGapRd?

GA 196: move +X000 to RogersRd?; move +X001 to SmileyRd?

GA 198: move +X001 to damascus Rd (old GA 184); +X003->PlainViewRd?

GA 200: move +X000 to South Blvd?; +X004->PullenRd?; JoSuLiRd point seems superfluous with the adjacent MilfordRd point
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on March 04, 2017, 03:14:05 pm
GA 206-240

GA 32Trk and GA 158Trk:  These appear to be legitimate truck routes in Douglas following GA 206 and US 221

GA 208: US19 off center;

GA 215: move +X000 to Noble Gin Rd?; move +X001 to Williford Crossing?

GA 216: +X002 -> nickelsvilleRd?; missing GA45Alt point in Arlington (Cedar St); there is definitely a GA216Trkarl (follows 45 ALT and 62 west back to 216); move +X003 to Lovic Davis Rd?; move +X004 to BevisRd?

GA 228: move +X000 to LaCrosseRd?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on March 10, 2017, 02:00:13 pm
GA 241-274

GA 243: correct unless it follows Fall Line over to GA 24 as shown on 2017 Official

GA 246: should really be in 3 pieces (as should NC 106)...this is no different than VA/WV 102.  All 5 of the GA/NC crossings are marked in the field though there are no state route shields that I saw in GMSV between westernmost and easternmost crossings...I am open to discussion on this (since I would be responsible for NC 106 changes)...

GA 252: GA 252 appears to have been truncated to GA 40 CONN; 2017 official and 2015 Charlton County map show this.  Not posted at US 1-23-301; contradictory posting on latest GMSV at GA 40 CONN.  I did not notice this when reviewing GA 4-15 files so point name change with alt name needed for those...

GA 253: +X005 -> CooktownRd?

GA 253sprbai: reverse points for conventional direction?

GA 254: +X000 -> WebsterLakeRd?

GA 256: +X002 ->DouthitRd?

GA 257: move +X004 to LimestoneRd?; +X005 and +X006 could be consolidated as a point at Roddy Hwy

GA 262: move +X003 to Carl CloudRd?

GA 268: CypAve->CypSt
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on March 10, 2017, 08:44:15 pm
GA 275-308

GA 282: OldUS411->OldUS411_N?

GA 283: +X000 -> JimHooodRd?

GA 284: move +X001 to Nopone or Glade Farm Rd?

GA 293concas: reverse points for standard direction?

GA 296: GA102->GA102_W; need point 1 block east for GA102_E

GA 298: move +X001 to Secret ForestRd?

GA 300: point needed between GA202 and GA188 (out of shape), suggest McMillan Rd; +X002 needs to be moved south to fix out of shape, suggest MicrowaveRd; US82_W->US82_E

GA 301: +X000->MichaelsRd?

GA 302: GA302Con->GA302Spr

GA 303: US17_S -> US17/82?; US17_N -> US17?

GA 305: move +X003 to FarmersBridgeRd?

GA 307: need a point at DeLoach Pkwy?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on March 11, 2017, 11:27:21 am
GA 309-324

GA 309: US84Bus_E->US84Bus_W

GA 311: GA97_N -> GA97?

GA 313: +X000 -> MeddersRd?

GA 316: WalBlvd and UniCenLn should be closed waypoints?; need a point at Wimberly Ln ramp east of GA 20/124?; move +X011 to Drowning Creek Rd?; need point at Oconee connector (direct connection to GA 10 Loop?)

GA 320: move +X001 to New BethelRd?

GA 324: reverse points for standard direction (GA 324 is signed E-W)?; move +X000 to FenceRd and +X001 to DaculaRd?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on March 11, 2017, 03:15:00 pm
GA 325-358

GA 330: +X000 -> SavageRd?

GA 332: new point at either Main/Talmo Tr or Main/Old Gainesville Hwy?; move +X003 to Talmo Rd?

GA 334: +X001 -> Seagraves MillRd?; +X002 ->Harris Lord Cemetery Rd?; +X003 -> Allen Rd (was US 441)?

GA 335: move +X000 to Jefferson River Rd?; move AppVal Rd to ThyBro Rd and delete +X001?

GA 337: AL/GA point is off by a fair bit;

GA 341: move +X001 to KensingtonRd?; move +X004 to Mission Ridge Rd?

GA 354: neither +X002 nor +X003 are necessary

GA 355: +X001 ->OldGA137?; +X002 -> OldGA103?;
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on March 14, 2017, 09:05:06 pm
GA 360-378

GA 360: GA120_W -> GA120?; +X001 -> SandtownRd?

GA 362: +X005 -> MorelandRd?

GA 365: move +X021 to MudCatRd?; move +X022 to Demorest-Mt Airy Hwy? (this one affects GA 15 which I did not notice before)

GA 369: GA20 point is off; move +X005 to Memorial ParkRd?

GA 372: ProRd point is off
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on March 16, 2017, 08:21:21 pm
GA 380-520
This completes my detailed suggested feedback on the Georgia State Highways

GA 382: GA515 -> GA5/515?

GA 385: US441_S -> US23/441_S; US441_N -> US23/441_N?

GA 400: need shaping point north of GA136 (out of tolerance)

GA 515: OrvLaneDr -> OrvLanDr?; US19/129 -> US19/129_N; US129Trk->PatHarMemDr; new point needed for US19/129_S at Glenn Gooch Bypass east of Blairsville (US 19/129 rerouted in Blairsville); CroCreCon is pretty off center;

GA 520: InnSt->InmSt
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on March 16, 2017, 10:55:15 pm
The Glenn Gooch Bypass (not sure of exact spelling) is not US 19 or US 129.  It is US 129 Truck and SR 11 Truck.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: dfilpus on March 17, 2017, 10:03:04 am
The Glenn Gooch Bypass (not sure of exact spelling) is not US 19 or US 129.  It is US 129 Truck and SR 11 Truck.
According to GDOT State Functional Map, US 19/129/GA 11 have been rerouted onto the Glenn Gooch Bypass. Cleveland St and Pat Harrison are now Local roads. This redesignation happened in January 2015. GMSV shows the Jan 2016 signage at the US 76 intersection with US 19/129/GA 11. US 76, US 19 and US 129 all need to be updated to reflect the new route.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on March 17, 2017, 01:36:16 pm
Thank you for bringing that update to my attention.  I didn't see that update on Google Street View.  The Glenn Gooch Bypass and the path of US 76/SR 2/SR 515 through Blairsville used to be the path of US 129 Truck/SR 11 Truck (not very well marked).  That was the last update that I knew of.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapcat on May 07, 2017, 04:48:32 pm
What are we waiting on in order to activate this system?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Wadsteckel on May 12, 2017, 07:58:26 pm
Hi all,

Back home (as I am lately) for the weekend after my travels during the week.  On Thursday, I drove from Gaffney SC to Gainesville GA to deliver a load, and took GA 17 from I-85 to US 23.  I see on the TM system that the routing is currently using its historical route through Avalon.  From what I saw on the signage, the route is on the bypass.  Is GA going to create a Business route through Avalon?  Is the TM system going to be updated to show GA 17 on the bypass?

Many thanks to everyone on the hard work keeping this going.

Regards,
-Ed S
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Eth on May 14, 2017, 05:50:06 pm
TM has GA 92 ending at US 19/41 north of Griffin, but I can't find any evidence of this. As far as I can tell, GA 92 still continues down US 19/41 and then Business 19/41 into downtown Griffin to end at GA 16 as it has for decades. GDOT's most recent Spalding County map shows this, though it is admittedly from 2013. GSV still shows GA 92 signed as such as of 2016.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: kjslaughter on June 01, 2017, 10:04:27 am
Found a route that needs to be fixed during my travels through Commerce, GA yesterday.  GA 334 needs to be extended past it's current end point in the system to end at GA 98 just a few miles north.  It threw me off when I realized there was no corresponding route shown in system for that stretch of US 441 Bus which isn't like GADOT at all.  Google street view confirms if you look at 567 S. Elm St., look north and clearly see route marker.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: rickmastfan67 on September 07, 2017, 02:05:47 am
http://tm.teresco.org/hb/?units=miles&r=ga.ga025consav

It's missing the '7' point from I-516/GA-21/GA-25.  Should be between the 'LatAve' & 'US80_W' points in the file.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on September 23, 2017, 07:39:03 pm
Update on feedback regarding fall line fwy and GA112

I drove the fall line fwy  from Wrens to Macon today.

The part leaving west from GA 24 is signed as GA 243. GA 112 north was truncated to this road as well
Title: GA: Georgia 21 Alternate
Post by: Jim on January 01, 2018, 08:18:29 pm
By email from user aaroads:

Quote
Also on the way northward last month, I drove the new port connector at Garden City/Port Wentworth, GA, which is an extension of Jimmy DeLoach Parkway. It is signed as Georgia 21 Alternate, with the route using Sonny Dixon Interchange (an access road linking GA 21 with the parkway) and along the connector freeway southeast to GA 307.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Eth on April 15, 2018, 07:53:51 am
GA166, GA316, and GA400 should probably be moved into this system (all currently in usansf), especially since they all now include the non-freeway portions of those routes.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: oscar on April 15, 2018, 08:00:01 am
GA166, GA316, and GA400 should probably be moved into this system (all currently in usansf), especially since they all now include the non-freeway portions of those routes.

usansf is an active system, undesirable to demote its routes to a preview system.

Usually, we make that move when we promote the preview system to active.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Jim on April 15, 2018, 10:52:01 am
In the past, I believe we and CHM before replaced the freeway-only routes in usansf with the full-length routes until the entire statewide system was activated.  This, as Oscar points out, would prevent an active route from temporarily being demoted to preview status.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: neroute2 on April 19, 2018, 10:17:21 am
GA21AltPortWen is a new route. It begins at the 21/307 junction, heads east on 307, then turns north on Jimmy Deloach Connector and rejoins 21 at Sonny Dixon Interchange.
(http://i.imgur.com/TlYStlP.jpg)
(http://i.imgur.com/PKTGNb0.jpg)
Title: GA - Fall Line Freeway (GA 243 / GA 540)
Post by: Wadsteckel on May 06, 2018, 11:41:39 am
Hi,

Taking a load through GA down to Tallahassee, I followed the named route above.  The signage showed it as GA 243 from GA 24 to GA 57, but I believe 243 has been routed up to Milledgeville as we have it on TM.  Google shows it as GA 540.  TM has no routing between GA 24 and GA 243.

What is the time frame on the official routing for this area?

Regards,
-Ed S
Title: Re: GA - Fall Line Freeway (GA 243 / GA 540)
Post by: Eth on May 07, 2018, 12:09:37 pm
As I understand it, 243 up toward Milledgeville is the old routing and has been removed from the state highway system. OSM was updated at some point (http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=13/33.0020/-83.2327) to reflect this.

I don't know at this point if GDOT is even actually planning on ever signing it as GA 540; that's what's been used as the internal planning number.
Title: GA: GA28 and GA28Pin
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on June 09, 2018, 03:37:09 am
Both of GA 28's segments are actually signed as east-west highways, not north-south ones, as in the highway browser. I'm not sure if that is a problem on this site.
Title: Re: GA: GA28 and GA28Pin
Post by: mc49399 on June 14, 2018, 09:10:04 pm
I can't speak for the southern portion but the Pine Mountain section was north/south when I passed through last year.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Wadsteckel on July 13, 2018, 09:52:22 pm
Hi all,

Back again, with some more travels through the Peach State.  Is there a truck route on GA 61 and GA113 through Cartersville?  Trying to get up to I-75, I came across this sign northbound near the intersection of West Ave (GA61/113) and Old Mill Rd:
https://www.google.com/maps/@34.148019,-84.8304385,3a,75y,55.71h,83.47t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sO6oKuNjfK15UCUiJE4HO0Q!2e0!7i13312!8i6656

I followed Truck Route signs from there, continuing on Old Mill Rd to S Erwin St, which transitioned into S Bridge Dr.  Approaching the intersection with US41/GA3, I saw this sign denoting directions to I75 N and S:
https://www.google.com/maps/@34.1579188,-84.7884308,3a,25.2y,82.24h,91.3t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1slMv45XzLwgOCRCqcnO94aQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656

Taking US41/GA3 north to Main St (GA113) would complete its truck route, whereas a turn westward on Main St to reach Tennessee St would complete the truck route for GA61. 

Not sure if GA uses official truck routes on their state routes, but I wanted to bring it up.  If, for nothing else, than to add a waypoint at Old Mill Rd.

Regards,
-Ed S
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on July 13, 2018, 11:58:40 pm
Georgia does use Truck plates above their state highway shields.  I'm not sure about how this particular case would be handled, though.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Jim on September 08, 2018, 09:46:12 am
This system has been in preview for over 19 months.  Is it awaiting further review before activation?
Title: Re: GA: GA28 and GA28Pin
Post by: michih on October 07, 2018, 08:44:13 am
Both of GA 28's segments are actually signed as east-west highways, not north-south ones, as in the highway browser. I'm not sure if that is a problem on this site.

I can't speak for the southern portion but the Pine Mountain section was north/south when I passed through last year.

Is it a matter? Should it be changed?

btw: It's a preview system. Merging topics.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: michih on October 07, 2018, 08:54:31 am
By email from user aaroads:

Quote
Also on the way northward last month, I drove the new port connector at Garden City/Port Wentworth, GA, which is an extension of Jimmy DeLoach Parkway. It is signed as Georgia 21 Alternate, with the route using Sonny Dixon Interchange (an access road linking GA 21 with the parkway) and along the connector freeway southeast to GA 307.

Merged into this thread because it's a preview system.
Title: Re: GA - Fall Line Freeway (GA 243 / GA 540)
Post by: michih on October 07, 2018, 08:59:39 am
Hi,

Taking a load through GA down to Tallahassee, I followed the named route above.  The signage showed it as GA 243 from GA 24 to GA 57, but I believe 243 has been routed up to Milledgeville as we have it on TM.  Google shows it as GA 540.  TM has no routing between GA 24 and GA 243.

What is the time frame on the official routing for this area?

Regards,
-Ed S

As I understand it, 243 up toward Milledgeville is the old routing and has been removed from the state highway system. OSM was updated at some point (http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=13/33.0020/-83.2327) to reflect this.

I don't know at this point if GDOT is even actually planning on ever signing it as GA 540; that's what's been used as the internal planning number.

Merged into this thread because it's a preview system.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on October 07, 2018, 08:27:07 pm
This system has been in preview for over 19 months.  Is it awaiting further review before activation?

Per some discussions elsewhere, I've offered to pick up the system. I'm looking over the issues and working my way through things (trying to learn some of it, too.  ;) ).

Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: yakra on October 13, 2018, 11:39:37 pm
Broken concurrency:
GA23@GA144_W mismatches GA57@GA144_W&GA144@GA23/57.
Recommend changing GA23@GA144_W to http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=31.939848&lon=-81.937907
This is the only broken multiplex I've spotted, and there's a LOT of multiplexing in GA!

Labels:
GA7BusVal (concurrent with I-75BLVal & US41BusVal) has points labeled OldGA125 and OldUS221_N. These should be named after the current road names instead. I'm gonna close the browser window now before I disappear down a rabbit hole; it's possible there could be more of these around the state.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on October 14, 2018, 12:05:57 am
Speaking of concurrencies, Georgia actually ties the current record for most highways in a single concurrency (counting an unsigned highway).  In Athens, US 29, US 78, US 129, US 441, GA 8, GA 10 Loop, GA 15, and the unsigned GA 422 travel in part of the city together.

Every Interstate highway in the state has an unsigned state route companion.  Every U.S. Highway has at least one signed state route companion.  There are so many concurrencies all across the state.  In fact, there are lots of five-, six-, and seven-highway concurrencies mixed in.
Title: Georgia (U.S.): GA 540 (Fall Line Freeway) signed
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on December 10, 2018, 12:08:35 pm
I was out of town on Saturday.  On my way back, I took US 1/GA 4 from Tobacco Road in Augusta, Georgia to Barton Chapel Road (also in Augusta).  The entire path was also signed as GA 540!  I just looked online and found a news story that says that in Columbus, Georgia, GA 540 is signed there.  Does anyone have any good information on the actual signing of the highway?  It is relevant because it needs to be added to the highway browser.
Title: Re: Georgia (U.S.): GA 540 (Fall Line Freeway) signed
Post by: dfilpus on December 10, 2018, 12:45:30 pm
GDOT installs new signs along GA Highway 540
http://www.wtvm.com/2018/09/27/gdot-installs-new-signs-along-ga-highway/
This article talks about signs being installed along the Fall Line Freeway from Columbus to Augusta.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on December 10, 2018, 06:53:17 pm
Wonder if Georgia will drop new useless multiplexes with GA 540 - GA 88 west of US 1, the entirety of GA 243, GA 57 western end, GA 96 west of Ft Valley
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on December 10, 2018, 07:41:11 pm
That looks like the same news story I saw, with a later slight update in October.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Eth on December 14, 2018, 09:40:33 pm
For what it's worth, I drove I-75 down to Florida today and didn't see any evidence of GA540 signage there.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on December 15, 2018, 11:06:04 am
Does anyone know how to find out when each part was/is/will be signed?  Does anyone know what the exact route of the highway is?  Does anyone know if the part from near Scottsboro to near Sandersville was completed?  I need online reliable sources, please.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: dfilpus on December 15, 2018, 11:53:24 am
Does anyone know how to find out when each part was/is/will be signed?  Does anyone know what the exact route of the highway is?  Does anyone know if the part from near Scottsboro to near Sandersville was completed?  I need online reliable sources, please.

From GA DOT http://www.dot.ga.gov/AboutGeorgia/Board/Presentations/FallLineFreeway.pdf gives a detailed routing of the Fall Line Freeway.
The segment from Scottsboro to near Sandersville was opened in 2016 http://www.dot.ga.gov/PartnerSmart/Public/PressReleases/Fall%20Line%20Freeway%20opening%20Monday%20afternoon-10-12-16.pdf#search=fall%20line%20freeway


Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on December 16, 2018, 12:24:33 am
Thank you so much.  I kept using Bing and Google, but couldn't find this stuff.  It also looks like GDOT removed the search feature on their website.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: dfilpus on December 16, 2018, 09:47:11 am
Thank you so much.  I kept using Bing and Google, but couldn't find this stuff.  It also looks like GDOT removed the search feature on their website.
There's a search box in the right end of the menu bar on http://www.dot.ga.gov/
Searching "Fall Line Freeway" gives all sorts of stuff.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on December 16, 2018, 10:37:43 am
Is there any way you could put a screenshot?  On my PC, I can't find the search box.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: dfilpus on December 16, 2018, 11:11:58 am
I played with the web-site. The search window vanishes if the browser window is not wide enough. Try expanding the browser window.

(http://roadgeek.filpus.org/Pictures/GDOT.jpg)
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on December 16, 2018, 07:04:19 pm
I have the browser maximized.  I scrolled all the way to the right, but the screen turns white to the right.  Does it matter what browser is used?

I can see the search bar on my phone, but using it on my computer is better for copying and pasting.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapcat on January 04, 2019, 08:11:44 pm
GA138: waypoint GA10us should be GA10Bus

GA8ConVil exists (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.7286722,-84.8998118,3a,43.2y,94.82h,95.17t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sg8u5s9kj1059z-1rJUW7GQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Eth on January 05, 2019, 02:31:26 pm
GA8ConVil exists (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.7286722,-84.8998118,3a,43.2y,94.82h,95.17t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sg8u5s9kj1059z-1rJUW7GQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)

Well, I'll be damned. Naturally, when I was driving through here on US 78 a couple years ago, I was heading west, from which there seems to be no mention of the route, and it's too short to show up on the GDOT state map, so I had no idea it was there. >:(
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapcat on January 05, 2019, 03:43:13 pm
@Eth: Not too far out of the way for you, is it?

Not knowing how long it was as I was zooming past, I skipped it, and forfeited an opportunity to add a clinch in about 30 seconds. Doubt I'll be back there anytime soon.


Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 05, 2019, 04:45:02 pm
All changes local for now. I will make a push this evening.

DCIAirPk: Removed
ChrMisCRd: Renamed to ArlRd
GA37: moved
PhiRd: Renamed to CouLineRd
+X012: Removed
+X015: Moved and renamed to HanRd
+X020: Moved and renamed to CalGar
EDepSt: Removed (there's no access there, anyway)
DavisRoad: Doesn't look too major. Is this really used as a bypass around town?
+X025: Moved and renamed to BobPurRd
+X026: Moved and renamed to WelRd (appears to be more major than the airport rd, but I can see arguments for the latter)
+X027: Moved and renamed to WadSt
+X029: Moved and renamed to MonRd
+X030: Removed
+X032: Moved and renamed to YouFarmRd
HunRd: Added
+X034: Moved and renamed to PoiRd
WestRomeByp: Renamed to GA1Lp_S (I need to figure out if this is one route with the north/east Ga1Lp or a separate route)
+X038: Removed
RivPkwyNE: Renamed to RivPkwy
GA1Lp: Renamed to Ga1Lp_N
+X039: Renamed to SilHillRd
GA100_End: Renamed to GA100/114
+X042: Moved and renamed to MouViewRd
WarSt: Moved
LeeAMillRd: Moved and renamed to LGMillRd
McFAve: Renamed to McFarAve_S
DodAve: Renamed to McFarAve_N


The start of suggested feedback for you to consider with the Georgia State Route set...

GA 1: DCIAirPk point necessary?; ChrMisCRd -> ArlRd?; GA 37 point needs to be moved west to new alignment of US 27/GA 1?; PhiRd -> CouLinRd?; +X012 move to Riverbend Rd?; add pt (or move +X015) at Hancock Rd in northern Columbus (connection to US 80 exit)?; +020(US27) -> Callaway Gardens?; EDepSt in LaGrange necessary?; add pt (or move +X024) at DavisRd Bypass n of LaGrange?; move +X025 to BobPurRd?; move +X026 to GumTreeAirRd?; move +X027 to WadSt?; mpve +X029 to MonMilRd?; move +X030 to MorChuRd?; move +X032 to HunRd?; move +X034 to HutRd?; WestRomeByp is signed as GA 1 Loop from US 27 SB; RivPkwyNE -> RivPkwy?; move X+039 to SilHilRd?; GA100_End -> GA100/114?; move +X042 to MouVieRd?; WarSt off-center?; LeeAMillRd -> LeeGorMillRd?; DodAve->McFarAve_N?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 05, 2019, 05:40:58 pm
All changes local for now.

GA 1 Bus (Blakely): +X02 removed
GA 1 Bus (Cedartown): PieAve moved and renamed to JohnHandRd
GA 1 Loop (West Rome): To Do

GA 2:
+X002: Moved and renamed to CheValRd
+X003: Renamed to WooRd
OldUS441: Renamed to OldFedRd
OrvLaneDr: Renamed to OrvLanCon
US19/129: Renamed to US19/129_N
US129Trk_S: I assume with the reroute of US129, this route is no longer? Not changing yet. Need to investigate.
US19/129_S: Added
CroCreCon: Moved
HopDr: Moved and renamed to HooDr
AppTr: Moved

GA 3:
MocRd: Added (though I wish I could have used Egg and Butter Road)
+X002: Moved and renamed to MicRd
+X008: Moved and renamed to HinRd
+X009: Moved and renamed to GarRd
GA208: Moved
+X010: Moved and renamed to WesChuRd
+X012: Removed
+X013: Moved and renamed to AllRd
+X016: Moved and renamed to VegaRd
PatRd: Added
Atlanta-area suffixes: Removed
McDStSW: Renamed to McDanSt
WWesRdNW: Renamed to WesRd
McCPkwyNW: Renamed to McColPkwy
KenDueWRdNW: Renamed to KenDueRd
GA176: Renamed to MarsHillRd
RedTopMRdSE: Renamed to RedTopRd
UniGrRd: Added
+X021: Moved and renamed to NanSprRd
HosCon: Renamed to ChaRd
GA/TN: Not changing (yet?)


GA 1 Bus (Blakely): +X02 moved to 1st Kolomoki Rd?
GA 1 Bus (Cedartown): Move Piedmont Ave to John Hand Rd?

The West Rome Bypass/Horseleg Creek Rd is signed as GA 1 Loop from limited GMSV at US 27 SB and also at Black Creek Rd

GA 2: move +X002 to Cherokee Valley Rd?; +X003 -> WooRd?; OldUS441 -> OldUS411 or OldFedRd; OrvLaneDr -> OrvLanDr?; US19/129 -> US19/129_N; US129Trk->PatHarMemDr; new point needed for US19/129_S at Glenn Gooch Bypass east of Blairsville (US 19/129 rerouted in Blairsville); CroCreCon is pretty off center; HopDr->HooDr; AppTr is pretty far off;

GA 3: point needed between GA202 and GA188 (out of shape), suggest McMillan Rd; +X002 needs to be moved south to fix out of shape, suggest MicrowaveRd; move +X008 to HarrisFarmRd?; +X009 is pretty far off and could be moved to Wainwright Rd; need a point btw +X009 and GA208 (out of shape), suggest wilsonRd; GA208 off center; move +X010 to WesleyChurch Rd?; consider +X012 -> OldGA22Spr  which was GA22Spr until 2005 and connected to US 80?; move +X013 to AllenRd?; move +X016 to Vega Rd or Sandefur Rd?; point needed between GA18 and US 41 (out of shape), suggest the northern Patton Rd; most metro Atlanta/Marietta points have cardinal direction suffixes; GA176 seems to be decommissioned?  not on 2017 Official GA map or in GMSV; need point at Union Grove Rd to connect to I-75 exit 310?; move +X021 to NanceSpringRd?; HosCon->ChaRd?; TN/GA appears to be off but does match the TN US 41 point
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 05, 2019, 06:24:35 pm
All changes local for now.

GA3ConAtl To be investigated

GA 4:
DixUniRd: Added
JamRd: Moved and renamed to ChuRd
GA15_S: Moved
DunLakeRd: Added
GA130: Moved
+X006: Moved and renamed to FivePoiRd
GA86_E: Looks like this was already done; swapped GA86_E to primary and ChiLn to AltLabel
+X011: Moved and renamed to GreMillRd
US1BusWad_S: Moved and renamed to GA4BusWad_S (Or should this remain US1Bus?)
US1BusWas_N: Renamed to GA4BusWad_N (Ditto here)
LFBriAPRd: Renamed to CamRd
SteMatRd: Renamed to WooDr

GA 4 Bus Wad:
GA4_S: Moved

GA 5:
StaRd: Renamed to StarPoiRd
+X002: Moved and renamed to OldNotRd
+X004: Moved and renamed to GilRd
+X005: Moved and renamed to BriStarRd
AusPSRd: Renamed to AusPowRd
+X007: Moved and renamed to WesDr
+X008: Removed

GA 6:
+X013: Moved and renamed to EnonRd

GA 6 Bus Rockmart:
EuhSt: Renamed to MLKingSt

GA3ConAtl is a waypoint on US19-41/GA 3 files but does not have its own .wpt file.  It is Tara Blvd between I-75(235) and US 19/41.  Note as far as I can tell there are no GA 3 CONN postings but it is on an inset of the 2013 Clayton County Map.

GA 4: add a point between US1/23Bus and +X004 (out of shape), suggest Dixie Union Rd?; JamRd point should be moved to Corinth Church Rd (out of shape segment)?; GA15_S point is off?; need a point between MainSt and LenRd (out of shape), suggest DunnsLake or Wayne Jones Rd?; GA130 is very far off; move +X006 to 5PointsRd?; US 1/GA 4 has a new bypass of Oak Park and therefore the GA86_E and GA46/86 points need to be moved to HarringtonRd and the new GA 46/86 jct respectively; move +X011 to either Greens Old Mill Rd or Wadley Coleman Lake Rd?; US1BusWad_S is very far off (same with the US1Bus/GA4Bus files); LFBriAPRd->CamRd?; SteMatRd->WooAcaRd?; 

GA 5: StaRd->StaPoiRd?; move +X002 to Old5NotchRd?; Move +X004 to GilesRd?; Move +X005 to BrightStarRd?; AusPSRd->LoveRd?; move +X007 to WestsideDr?; Delete or move +X008 to GarrisonRd?

GA 6: move +X013 to enonRd?

GA6BusRoc: EuhSt->MLKAve?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 05, 2019, 06:58:29 pm
Oh, this thing (Github) is going to kill me.

I changed 10 files locally (GA1 through GA6, plus some bannered routes). I committed the change locally. I thought I had fetched origin this morning before I started on this, but it apparently failed. So when I fetch it now, I have my commit of 10 files, and a merge commit of 3400 or so files. And it won't let me push them.

Authentication failed. You may not have permission to access the repository or the repository may have been archived. Open options and verify that you're signed in with an account that has permission to access this repository.

What step am I missing?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 05, 2019, 09:20:13 pm
Changes are local until I can figure out what step I'm missing to submit these.

GA 7:
MainSt: Renamed to MainSt_Lak (see below)
KinBrgRd: Renamed to CenAve
GA32Con: Removed
GA32_E: Moved
11thStS: Renamed to JoeWriDr
6thSt: Renamed to 7thSt
I-75BLCor_N: If it's not posted, then the route probably should be removed?
+X006: Moved and renamed to LibChuRd
+X010: Moved and renamed to CloLakeRd
SugHilRd: Renamed to +X010
+X011: Moved and renamed to MainSt_Mil

GA 8:
+X002: Moved and renamed to PolRd
CopLakeRd: Renamed to CooLakeRd
+X007: Moved and renamed to PebRd
PeaSt: Removed
JunSt: Moved
PieAve: Moved
Removed a handful of direction suffixes
+X008: Moved and renamed to JohRd
GA20/124_N: Renamed to GA20/124
+X010: Moved and renamed to DacRd
GA11/53_N: Renamed to GA11/53
+X011: Removed
OcoCon: Added
PetSt: Renamed to GA10Lp(9)
+X019: Moved and renamed to KesRd

GA 9:
GA236: Renamed to LinDr
WinPkwyNE: Moved. NE suffix kept to avoid conflict with WinPkwy (Windward vice Windsor)
+X002: Renamed to HamRd
+X003: Moved and renamed to ACSmiRd
+X006: Moved and renamed to YahRd

GA 10:
+X000: Moved and renamed to PadCir
+X004: Moved and renamed to PeteDicRd
GA22_N: Renamed to GA22_E
GA77_W: Renamed to GA77_S
GA77_E: Renamed to GA77_N
WillWinRd: Renamed to WillWynRd
GA44_S: Renamed to GA44_W
US1Con: Removed (the ramp mentioned appears to be the northbound exit to US25Bus_S anyway)

GA 10BusWas:
LinCir: Moved and renamed to 3rdSt

GA 7: KinBrgRd->CenAve?; GA32_E point is off (could also be merged with the 32Con point which is not signed as such); 11thSt_S ->JoeWriDr?; 6thSt is not at 6th St...a few choices of what to call it; I-75BusCor_N->FarMarRd?  I-75Bus not posted from anywhere that I could find...?; move +006 to LibChuRd?; move +X010 to CloLakeRd?; SugHillRd is not a road...change to +X point?; move +X011 to OldUS41?;

GA 8: move +X002 to PollardRd?; AusPSRd->LoveSt?; CopLakeRd->CooLakeRd; Move +X007 to PebRd?; PeaSt->WestPeaSt? (PeaSt is nearby); Move +X008 to JohnsonRd?; Move +X010 to DaculaRd?; Move +X011 to WallRd?; need point btw US78/78Bus_W and GA10Lp at OconeeConnector (connects to 10loop)?; PetSt->Ga10Lp(9)?; Move +X019 to Hartwell Speedway Rd?

GA 9: GA236->LinDr (GA 236 ends at GA 237 east of here); WinPkwy point needs to be moved to what appears to be a new alignment; +X002->HambyRd?; Move +X003 to SilverCityRd?; Move +X006 to YahoolaRd?;

GA 10: move +X000 to HowardAve Connector?; move +X004 to Pete Dickens Rd?; GA22 N-S should be E-W; GA77 E-W should be N-S; WillWinRd->WillWynRd?; GA44_S -> GA44_W?; US1Con point should be deleted (the only ramp to Bay St starts at the previous US25Bus point) as the ramp is signed as US 25BUs/GA 28?  Bay St itself is not in the primary system.

GA 10BusWas: LinCir moved to 3rd St? (connects to US 78);
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: oscar on January 05, 2019, 09:54:37 pm

GA 4:
DixUniRd: Added
JamRd: Moved and renamed to ChuRd
GA15_S: Moved
DunLakeRd: Added
GA130: Moved
+X006: Moved and renamed to FivePoiRd
GA86_E: Looks like this was already done; swapped GA86_E to primary and ChiLn to AltLabel
+X011: Moved and renamed to GreMillRd
US1BusWad_S: Moved and renamed to GA4BusWad_S (Or should this remain US1Bus?)
US1BusWas_N: Renamed to GA4BusWad_N (Ditto here)
LFBriAPRd: Renamed to CamRd
SteMatRd: Renamed to WooDr

GA 4 Bus Wad:
GA4_S: Moved

These and many other Georgia state routes are largely concurrent with US routes. GA 4 in particular is concurrent with US 1, and at its south end US 23 and/or US 301, except for a short non-concurrent segment in Augusta. Are the changes you're making also being made to the concurrent routes, so that GA 4 stays in synch with those routes?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 05, 2019, 11:11:29 pm
I will be making those changes. They aren't in the current pull request; I wanted to make sure I knew what I was doing (with the preview system) before I committed those changes in an active system.

Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: michih on January 06, 2019, 02:29:30 am
Oh, this thing (Github) is going to kill me.

I changed 10 files locally (GA1 through GA6, plus some bannered routes). I committed the change locally. I thought I had fetched origin this morning before I started on this, but it apparently failed. So when I fetch it now, I have my commit of 10 files, and a merge commit of 3400 or so files. And it won't let me push them.

Authentication failed. You may not have permission to access the repository or the repository may have been archived. Open options and verify that you're signed in with an account that has permission to access this repository.

What step am I missing?

I will be making those changes. They aren't in the current pull request; I wanted to make sure I knew what I was doing (with the preview system) before I committed those changes in an active system.

It seems that you've managed it now? There is a pull request without conflicts and only 15 files changed: https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/2484
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: michih on January 06, 2019, 02:44:02 am
This system has been in preview for over 19 months.  Is it awaiting further review before activation?
Per some discussions elsewhere, I've offered to pick up the system. I'm looking over the issues and working my way through things (trying to learn some of it, too.  ;) ).

Is there anyone more experienced who can check that the changes are fine?

I could but I'm not very familar with US stuff... The very first pull (https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/2484) does only contain usaga files and no files from active systems though.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Eth on January 06, 2019, 09:11:15 am
@Eth: Not too far out of the way for you, is it?

Nah, only about 40 minutes or so away, though I rarely have reason to be in that area. I'll probably go pick it up someday along with the parts of GA 61 and 101 over there that I need.

WestRomeByp: Renamed to GA1Lp_S (I need to figure out if this is one route with the north/east Ga1Lp or a separate route)

I'm pretty sure they're eventually intended to be one route. Currently, though, per GIS shapefiles, this one is officially shown as SR 746 (though not signed as that, obviously), while the other one is the expected 1LO, with the two routes having separate mile markers.

All changes local for now.

GA3ConAtl To be investigated

GA3ConAtl is a waypoint on US19-41/GA 3 files but does not have its own .wpt file.  It is Tara Blvd between I-75(235) and US 19/41.  Note as far as I can tell there are no GA 3 CONN postings but it is on an inset of the 2013 Clayton County Map.

Tara Blvd is still officially 3CO according to the shapefiles, though to my knowledge this number has never been signed, so I'd probably not reference it. (Also, GA3ConAtl is already a route in the HB in downtown Atlanta, concurrent with US29.)
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 06, 2019, 08:03:42 pm
Oh, this thing (Github) is going to kill me.

I changed 10 files locally (GA1 through GA6, plus some bannered routes). I committed the change locally. I thought I had fetched origin this morning before I started on this, but it apparently failed. So when I fetch it now, I have my commit of 10 files, and a merge commit of 3400 or so files. And it won't let me push them.

Authentication failed. You may not have permission to access the repository or the repository may have been archived. Open options and verify that you're signed in with an account that has permission to access this repository.

What step am I missing?

I will be making those changes. They aren't in the current pull request; I wanted to make sure I knew what I was doing (with the preview system) before I committed those changes in an active system.

It seems that you've managed it now? There is a pull request without conflicts and only 15 files changed: https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/2484

Correct. I had failed to make a fork. But I'm up and running now.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 06, 2019, 08:04:59 pm
This system has been in preview for over 19 months.  Is it awaiting further review before activation?
Per some discussions elsewhere, I've offered to pick up the system. I'm looking over the issues and working my way through things (trying to learn some of it, too.  ;) ).

Is there anyone more experienced who can check that the changes are fine?

I could but I'm not very familar with US stuff... The very first pull (https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/2484) does only contain usaga files and no files from active systems though.

My plan is to make the US highway changes locally, but not to submit them with the GA route changes. I'll push all of those in one batch at the end.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 06, 2019, 09:23:24 pm
All changes local for now. I probably won't get a chance to look at this again until Friday.

GA 11:
+X006: Moved and renamed to PineLevRd
+X008: Moved and renamed to JackAllRd
GA49_S: Moved
HouRd_S: Removed
+X013: Moved and renamed to IndParkDr
LibChuRd: Removed
+X015: Moved and renamed to MeadRd
US129_GraN: Renamed to CliSt
+GrayByp: Unhidden and renamed to US129 (GA11 is shown on OSM as going through and around Gray; need to research)
+X020: Moved and renamed to LibChuRd
+X021: Moved and renamed to CouLineRd
CR213: I see neither reassurance markers nor a sign at the corner, but it appears it should be 2nd St. Renaming.
+X022: Moved and renamed to ThuBacRd
+X025: Moved and renamed to HanBriRd
+X026: Moved and renamed to EbeChuRd
GaiMillRd: Added
ShoeFacRd: Renamed to CleSt
Rerouted GA11 around east side of Blairsville. Need to check if anything still follows Cleveland St.

GA 11BusPer:
+X001: Moved and renamed to MorDr

GA 11BypLak:
GA135_N: Satellite imagery shows the angle all the way to Church Ave. So the point is where the centerlines cross.

GA 12:
GA260: Renamed to GleRd
HigTrl: Moved
+X007: Moved and renamed to SwoRd
+X008: Moved and renamed to CarStaRd
GA44_S: Renamed to GA44_W

GA 13:
GA332: Added


GA 11:  move +X006 to PineLevelChurchRd?; move +X008 to JackAllenRd?; GA49_S and Houston Rd points are now pretty far off due to intersection relocations; move +X013 to nearby roads?; move +X015 to MeadRd?; +GrayByp can be turned into a waypoint as the bypass opened in late 2016..however I cannot find any evidence it has been assigned a primary route number; move +020 to Liberty Church Rd?; move +X021 to County Line Rd?; CR213 ->2ndAve? (CR 213 not signed as such); move +X022 to Thurman Baccus Rd?; move +X025 to Hancock Br Rd?; move +X026 to Ebenezer Church Rd?; need a point between GA323 and I-985 (out of shape), suggest Gaines Mill Rd; Blairsville points need relocating as route now uses bypass around the east to US 76 then back west

GA 11BusPer: move +X001 to MorningsideDr?

GA 11BypLak: GA135_N point is off

GA 12: GA260 ->GleRd (GA260 ends at I-20); HigTrl point is off; Move +X007 to SwordsRd?; Move +X008 to Carey Station Rd?; GA44_S -> GA44_W;

GA 13: need point for GA 332 (just east of GA 53);

GA 14: move +X001 to Old WestPointRd?; need point between GA100_N and CowHeaRd (out of shape), suggest RallRd; move +X004 to Cedar Creek Rd?; MainSt_Uni->WatSt; move +X007 to Stonewall Tell Rd?; NavAve->NabAve;

GA 15: need a point between MainSt and LenRd (out of shape), suggest DunnsLake or Wayne Jones Rd?; move +X007 to BraddyRd?; move +X015 to EleyRd?; GA44_S -> GA44_W; PetSt->Ga10Lp(9)?; move +X026 to CooperFarmRd or delete?; move +X027 to BereaRd?; move +X028 to WhiteHillSchRd?; move +X031 to ApplePieRidgeRd?; LevGroRd ->GA15Con; need point btw US441BusCla_N and GA15Lp_S (out of shape?), suggest Travis Smith Rd in Turnerville; OldUS441Lak_S point is pretty off; move +X037 to campcreekRd?;
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: rlee on January 06, 2019, 11:22:16 pm
My observations from last July: US 19/US 129/GA 11 have been relocated to the Glen Gooch Bypass east of the downtown then west along US 76/GA 515 back west to Murphy Hwy where US 19/129/GA 11 return to their routing head north.  There are no highway signs through the downtown streets (Cleveland St or Blue Ridge St) including US 129 Truck, which appears to be no more. Most all signage on US 76/GA 515 appears to have been replaced somewhat recently as part of the process of moving US 19/US 129/GA 11 to US 76 and the Gooch Bypass.

P.S. changes to US 19 and 129 files and deletion of US 129 Truck needs to be done as well.

All changes local for now. I probably won't get a chance to look at this again until Friday.

GA 11:
ShoeFacRd: Renamed to CleSt
Rerouted GA11 around east side of Blairsville. Need to check if anything still follows Cleveland St.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Eth on January 07, 2019, 10:17:41 am

GA 11:
+GrayByp: Unhidden and renamed to US129 (GA11 is shown on OSM as going through and around Gray; need to research)
...
Rerouted GA11 around east side of Blairsville. Need to check if anything still follows Cleveland St.

Again looking at the GIS shapefile (available from here (https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/policyinformation/hpms/shapefiles.cfm)), GA11 is routed on the bypass around the west side of Gray along with US129; former GA11 through Gray is no longer on the state highway system.

Cleveland St in Blairsville also appears to no longer be on the state highway system.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 11, 2019, 10:41:29 pm
Changes local for now.

GA 14:
+X001: Moved and renamed to WestPoiRd
RalRd: Added
+X004: Moved and renamed to CedCreRd
MainSt_Uni: Moved and renamed to WatSt
+X007: Moved and renamed to StoTellRd
NavAve: Renamed to NabAve

GA 15:
DunLakeRd: Added
+X007: Moved and renamed to BraRd
+X015: Moved and renamed to EleyRd
GA44_S: Renamed to GA44_W
PetSt: Renamed to GA10Lp(9)
+X026: Removed
+X027: Moved and renamed to SmiBriRd
+X028: Moved and renamed to HooMillRd
+X031: Moved and renamed to AppRidRd
LevGroRd: Renamed to GA15Con
ThaRd: Added
OldUS441Lak_S: Moved
+X037: Moved and renamed to CampCreRd

GA 14: move +X001 to Old WestPointRd?; need point between GA100_N and CowHeaRd (out of shape), suggest RallRd; move +X004 to Cedar Creek Rd?; MainSt_Uni->WatSt; move +X007 to Stonewall Tell Rd?; NavAve->NabAve;

GA 15: need a point between MainSt and LenRd (out of shape), suggest DunnsLake or Wayne Jones Rd?; move +X007 to BraddyRd?; move +X015 to EleyRd?; GA44_S -> GA44_W; PetSt->Ga10Lp(9)?; move +X026 to CooperFarmRd or delete?; move +X027 to BereaRd?; move +X028 to WhiteHillSchRd?; move +X031 to ApplePieRidgeRd?; LevGroRd ->GA15Con; need point btw US441BusCla_N and GA15Lp_S (out of shape?), suggest Travis Smith Rd in Turnerville; OldUS441Lak_S point is pretty off; move +X037 to campcreekRd?;
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 12, 2019, 09:49:25 am
All changes local for now.

GA 16:
+X005: Renamed to PopSt
+X006: Moved and renamed to HighFalRd
HighFalRd: Renamed to EngChaRd

GA 17:
LFBriAPRd: Renamed to CamRd
+X015: Renamed to FaiRd
The Avalon Bypass appears to be open. Need to verify and change GA328 (and add a few shaping points)
+X018: Renamed to HilCroRd

GA 17AltToc:
+X000: Moved and renamed to BlaMouRd_E
+X002: Moved and renamed to BlaMouRd_W

GA17BusWas:
GA44_N: Renamed to GA44_E

GA 18:
+X001: Moved and renamed to CroRd
EastMilRd: Moved and renamed to McKinRd
JenRd: Added
US129_N: Added at Gray Bypass
Old US129_N point renamed to JacAve
GA18Spr: Will verify before deleting

GA 18SprGor: Will verify before deleting

GA 19:
+X004: Renamed to PauChuRd
+X006: Moved and renamed to OchRd
OldMacRd: Moved
ColSt: Moved
MonSt_Mac: Added
PateRd does not cross the RR tracks and reach GA19. No changes made here.

GA 16: +X005 ->PopSt?; move +X006 to HighFallsRd?; delete +X007 and move JacRd to Bailey Jester Rd?;

GA 17: LFBriAPRd->CamRd?; +X015->FaiRd?; +X018->Hills Crossing?;

GA 17AltToc: +X000 ->BlaMouRd_E?; +X002 -> BlaMouRd_W?

GA17BusWas: GA44_N -> GA44_E

GA 18: +X001 -> ParRd?; EastMilRd->MilRd?; Add a point at Jenkins Rd btw I-75 and US 23 (connection to I-75)?; need a pont at Gray Byp right before US129_S; GA18Spr (Gordon) appears to have been decommissioned btw 2008-12...rename as MaconRd?;

GA 18SprGor: delete route? - see last note under GA 18

GA 19: +X004 ->StPauChuRd?; +X006->OchRd?; OldMacRd point is off; GA96_W -> GA96_E; The ColSt point in Macon is in an odd location, as both directions of 41Bus/19 pass through the Georgia Ave/College St intersection.  If the thought was to reflect the subsequent split routing west of here, suggest adding a point located at Monroe and Tinsley Ln; move KloRd point to PateRd which has ramps from I-75?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 12, 2019, 05:50:16 pm
All changes local.

GA 20:
+XWestRomeByp: Renamed to GA1Lp_S
CowDr: Added
GA369: Moved
SuwDamRd: Renamed and moved slightly
+X010: Renamed to HokeOkeRd
+X013: Moved and renamed to KelRd

GA 21:
GA21Bus_SylS: Renamed to GA21BusSyl_S

GA 22:
CouRd: Moved and renamed to TealRd
+X007: Moved and renamed to AllRd
CliSt_E: Added. Need to verify GA22 takes bypass around town. If so, need to update the route here.
GA77: Names changed

GA 22SprCol:
+X001: Renamed to UniAve

GA 23:
DonRd: Moved and renamed to GeoSwiRd
+X007: Moved and renamed to CanRd

GA 24:
+X009: Moved and renamed to SteRd

US 278 TrkMad/GA12TrkMad: Will investigate further

GA 25:
GA25SprDar: Renamed to FortGeoDr
+X007: Moved and renamed to ChuRd
GA57/99: Renamed to GA57
+X008: Moved and renamed to HarNeckRd
+X010: Moved and renamed to LewFraRd
+X014: Moved and renamed to CanRd

GA 26:
GA90 points renamed
OldMacRd: Moved
+X012: Moved and renamed to OldReiRd
+X013: Moved and renamed to ColRd
+X015: Moved and renamed to ZetAve

GA 27:
CR76: Moved and renamed to EntChuRd
GA90_N: Renamed to GA90_W
LivFarmRd: Renamed to OweRd

GA 29:
+X001: Moved and renamed to BraRd

GA 20: +Xwest rome bypass ->Ga1LpSW; shaping point needed between ReyBriRd and US41_N; GA369 point is off; SwuDamRd->SuwDamRd; +X010 -> BriscoeRd?; +X013 ->KelleytownRd?;

GA 21: GA21Bus_SylS -> GA21BusSyl_S;

GA 22: move CouRd point to TealRd?; move +X007 to the old GA22Spr near US 19 (existed until 2005)?; need a point at Gray Bypass east of town?; GA77_E -> GA77_N; GA77_W -> GA77_S;

GA 22SprCol: +X001 ->UniAve?

GA 23: DonRd->GeoSwiRd?; move +X007 to CanoocheeRd?;

GA 24: move +X009 to StembridgeRd?;

US 278 TrkMad/GA12TrkMad:  There is a fully signed US 278 Truck and GA 12 Truck for Madison that uses GA 24 Spur, US 441 south, then US 441 Bypass north back around to US 278/GA 12

GA 25: GA25SprDar -> Old GA25Spr or ForKGeoDr? (route decommissioned); move +X007 to ChurchillRd?; GA57/99 -> GA99 (GA 57 END shield is at I-95); add point at Harris Neck Rd (was GA 131 until 1990)?; move +X010 to Lewis Frasier Rd?; move +X014 to Canebrake Rd?;

GA 26: GA90_N -> GA90_W; GA90_S -> GA90_E;  OldMacRd point is off; move +X012 to OldReiRd?; move +X013 to WillHillRd?; move +X015 to ZetRd?

GA 27: CR76 ->SemRd? (CR 76 not marked as such); GA90_N -> GA90_W; LivFarmRd->OweRd;

GA 29: move +X001 to BraddyRd?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 12, 2019, 06:06:15 pm
Changes local for now.


GA 122: US19 => US19/84 Done

GA 133: Request point between GA133 and CanRd, for CR44 (better) or Hempstead Church Rd. Either would approximate my turnaround point, which is somewhere (not necessarily an intersection) north of the county line. We haven't done non-intersection county line points,and I don't suggest changing that; thus my search for nearby intersections. HemChuRd added

US 1 and GA 86:  i agree with Mapmikey that both routes need to be adjusted, to reflect the new US 1 bypass of Oak Park. Alas, GMSV hasn't run a camera car through Oak Park since the US 1 reroute, and the online mapping is confused about the numbers other than GA 86 for the old route. ince theFXexpert seems to live not too far from Oak Park, maybe some early spring field-checking is in order? I seem to remember this discussed later in the thread. Will come back to it.

GA 18 and GA 109:  In GA18 file, waypoint GA109_E is west of waypoint GA109 -- shouldn't they be GA109_W and GA109_E respectively? Similar issue in GA109 file for GA18 points. On GA18, GA109_W would be at US27Alt_N (end of a concurrency). GA109_E is the other end of the concurrency. Plain GA109 is farther east along GA18 and is the east end of GA109. I think the existing tags are probably the best solution. Same for GA109 w/r/t GA18.

GA 299: Waypoints are in east to west order, rather than usual west to east. GA299 is labeled as a N/S route, so it is correctly ordered south to north.
[/quote]
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 12, 2019, 06:38:39 pm
Changes still local.

GA 30:
+X001: Moved and renamed to SevPleRd
GA215 points renamed
US319/441_N: Moved
+X007:Moved and renamed to ChuSt

GA 31:
+X003: Removed
GA31Con: Moved
US280_E: Moved

GA 32:
GA520: Renamed to GA45/520
LesHwy: Added (GA195 no longer follows this routing)

GA 33:
+X000: Moved and renamed to OzeRd
+X001: Moved and renamed to SalRd
GA82: Renamed to US82

GA 35:
+X004: Moved and renamed to KellRd
RidAve: Added

GA 35ConTho:
To be added later

GA 36:
SunnRd: Moved and renamed to IrvRd (another SunRd already on this route)
+X003: Removed
GA74_S: Renamed to GA74_E
GA168: Renamed to GA162

GA37:
US1: Moved
+X005: Moved and renamed to BayRd

GA 37TrkCam:
To be added later

30-39:

GA 30: move +X003 to Pleasant View Rd?; GA215_W -> GA215_N; GA215_E -> GA215_S; US319/441_N point needs to be moved east to new configuration; move +X007 to ChurchSt?;

GA 31: GA31Con point is at wrong road.  It is on Murray Blvd near +X003 (GA31Conlak.wpt is on the correct routing, however); US280_E point needs to be moved east to new configuration

GA 32: GA520 -> GA45/520?; need a point added after US19_N for nearby GA 195;

GA 33: move +X000 to OzellRd?; move +X001 to Salem Rd or Airline Rd?; GA82->US82;

GA 35: move +X004 to KellRd?; need a point at RidgeAve (direct connection to I-75) in Tifton?;

GA 35ConTho: No .wpt file for this route

GA 36: SunnRd->SunRd; GA74_S -> GA74_E; GA168->GA162;

GA 37: US27 point needs to be moved west to new alignment of US 27/GA 1?; move +X005 to BayRd;

GA 37TrkCam:  There is a fully signed GA 37 TRUCK in both directions using Oakland Ave and a bit of US 19 in Camelia
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 13, 2019, 03:17:03 pm
Changes local. Will submit tonight.

GA 40SprStM:
Delete this, since it's unsigned?

GA 41:
+X008: Added between DocBroRd and US80_W

GA 40SprStM:  Camden County map shows GA 40 SPUR ending at the north Mush Bluff Rd jct (appears to be no signage in the field anywhere)

GA 41: need a shaping point between DrBrownRd and US80_W
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 13, 2019, 03:52:10 pm
GA 42:
OldBetRd: Moved
+X007: Moved and renamed to CouLineRd
+X008: Moved and renamed to LocGriRd
EllRd: Renamed to ForPkwy

GA 44:
CliSt: Added (renamed from US129_S)
US129_S: Moved to the Gray Bypass
MatRd: Moved and renamed to StaRd
+X002: Moved and renamed to ScoRd

GA 45:
BilNewRd: Added

GA 46:
This one's already been done.

GA 47:
+X007: Moved and renamed to NeaMillRd

GA 49:
US19 has already been done.
US41_S: Moved
HouRd_S: Moved
+X009: Moved and renamed to IndParkDr
+X011: Moved and renamed to MeadRd

GA51
+X004: Moved and renamed to NewProRd

GA52
OldUS441: Renamed to OldUS411

GA 42 to GA 52

GA 42: OldBetRd point is pretty far off; move +X007 to DeanPatrickRd?; move +X008 to MLKBlvd?; EllRd->ForPkwy;

GA 44: need a point at the Gray Bypass; MatRd (unpaved) needs to change to a shape point and moved southwest a little to eliminate an out-of-shape section; move +X002 to ScottRd?;

GA 45: need a point (out-of-shape) between GA 200 and GA 216, suggest Billy Newberry Rd;

GA 62 TrkArl: There is a fully signed GA 62 Truck in Arlington (could be argued there is also a fully signed GA 216 TRUCK too...45 TRUCK is 100% current with GA 45 ALT though)

GA 46: US1_S point needs to be moved south to new location;

GA 47: move +X007 to NealMillRd?

GA 49: US19_S and Houston Rd points are now pretty far off due to intersection relocations; move +X009 to nearby roads?; move +X011 to MeadRd?

GA 51: move +X004 to NewProspectRd?

GA 52: OldUS441->OldUS411
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 13, 2019, 04:17:14 pm
GA 53:
GA82_W: Renamed to GA82

GA 54:
+X003: Moved and renamed to EbeRd

GA 60:
LowStarCRd: Renamed to OldDialRd

GA 60BusDah:
AndDr: Moved and renamed to CampWahRd
+X000: Removed

GA 62:
GA45Alt_S and GA45Alt_N: Added

GA 67:
WynnRd: Added
GA121_S: Moved
GA23_S: Moved I'll get back to GA23 later

GA 70:
+X000: Moved and renamed to JimStaRd
CocMillRd_N: Added

GA 72:
ColComRd: Added

GA 73:
LakRd: Renamed to ParSt_W
GA21Bus: Renamed points
+X004: Moved and renamed to HarRd

GA 73:
Will come back to this

GA 74:
I-575: Renamed to I-475

GA 53: GA82_W -> GA82?

GA 54: move +X003 to Ebenezer Rd?

GA 60: LowStarCRd->OldDialRd? (no GMSV in area)

GA 60BusDah: move AndRd point to CampWahsegaRd?

GA 62: Both GA45Alt points are missing in Arlington

GA 67: Need shaping point north of GA 46; GA121_S point needs to be moved south to new intersection location; GA23_S point needs to be moved south to new intersection location (I missed this on my GA 23 review)

GA 70: +X000 -> Jim Starr Rd?; need a point at Cochran Mill Rd (just south of GA 92)?  This was where GA 70 left GA 154 until about 2007;

GA 72: +X000 ->Middleton Church Rd?

GA 73: LakRd -> ParSt_W?; GA21Bus_W -> GA21Bus_N; GA21Bus_E -> GA21Bus_S; move +X004 to Harmony Rd?

GA 73BypSta: no .wpt file, however despite it being on the official map it does not seem to be posted anywhere I could find along US 301 BYpass

GA 74: I-575 -> I-475;
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 13, 2019, 05:53:11 pm
Local changes. To be submitted tonight.

GA75altcle:
+X000: Moved and renamed to JohnHeadRd

GA 77:
+X014: Moved and renamed to RopRd

GA 77conlav:
+X000: Removed
+X001: Moved and renamed to RidRd

GA 78:
RubyRd: Renamed to NewChuDr

GA 80:
+X005: Moved and renamed to RicRd

GA 81:
TurLakeRd: Added

GA 82:
+X001: Moved and renamed to PicSimRd
PleHillCRd: Moved and renamed to BowMillRd

GA75altcle: +X000 -> GloverRd?

GA 77: move +X014 to RockyFordRd?

GA 77conlav: combine +X001 and +X002 into one waypoint at RidgeviewRd?

GA 78: Ruby Rd is not named that in GMSV

GA 80: move +X005 to RicketsonRd?

GA 81: need point at Turner Lake Rd (direct connection to I-20) in Covington?

GA 82: move +X001 to PicklesimonRd?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 13, 2019, 06:36:35 pm
GA 84:
US29: Renamed to US78

GA 85:
GA92_N: Moved

GA 86:
Work already done (US1_S -> HarSt)

GA 87:
US341Bus: Renamed to US341Bus_N
+X001: Moved and renamed to EasByp
WillHenRd: Renamed to AlbJenRd
I-75(167A): Marked as closed
I-75(167): Moved to new ramps (they still appear to be there in the satellite view)

GA 88:
US25: Moved

GA 89:
ChaRd: Moved and renamed to CR204

GA 90:
+X007: Changed to match GA11
6thSt: Changed to match GA7
I-75BL: Changed to FarMarRd

GA 45TrkCol and GA91TrkCol
Will come back to these later

GA 92:
+X002: Moved and renamed to InmRd
OakIndBlvd: Added
GA154 points: Renamed to GA70/154

GA 93:
+X001: Moved and renamed to RidRd

GA 97:
US84Bus_E: Renamed to US84Bus_W

GA 100:
+X008: Moved and renamed to MonMillRd
LineBraRd: Renamed to LimeBraRd

GA 101:
OakSt: Moved

GA 102:
GA296 points updated

GA 105:
GA184: Looks good on OSM, and matches the point on GA184

GA 84: US29->US78

GA 85: Has the GA92_N point moved to new alignment with traffic circle via Hood Ave?

GA 86: US1_N -> US1 and also moved south to relocated intersection; US1_S ->OldUS1

GA 87: US341Bus -> US341Bus_N?; move +X001 to Antioch Church Rd?; WillHenRd->AlbJenRd?; I-75(167A) and I-75(167) points need to be reclassified as CLOSED points (ramps are gone);

GA 88: US25 point has been moved southward

GA 89: move ChaRd (unpaved) point to CR204 (paved)?

GA 90: move +X007 to PineLevelChurchRd?; 6thSt is not at 6th St...a few choices of what to call it; I-75BusCor_N->FarMarRd?  I-75Bus not posted from anywhere that I could find...?

GA 45TrkCol and GA91TrkCol There are fully signed truck routes for GA 45 and GA 91 in Colquitt that follow US 27 and GA 91spr, with GA 45 truck then using GA 91 back into downtown Colquitt
 
GA 92: move +X002 to GozaRd?; need point at Oakley Ind Blvd in Fairburn?  signed as TO I-85; GA154 points add GA 70 label as well?;

GA 93: +X001->RidgeRd?

GA 97: US84Bus_E->US84Bus_W;

GA 100: move +X008 to Monroe MillRd?; LineBraRd->LimeBraRd?

GA 101: OakSt point is pretty far off

GA 102: GA296->GA296_S; need new point for GA296_N 1 block east of 296_S

GA 105: GA184 point is off;
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 13, 2019, 06:41:20 pm
All route changes through GA105 have been submitted.

After I finish going through these, I'll verify the concurrencies and update the US highways.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: oscar on January 13, 2019, 10:33:24 pm
I have comments on various routes on page 3, supplementing Mapmikey's. Most of them are for routes above 105, but you should check my comments on GA 18 before you move on to 106 and higher.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 14, 2019, 07:12:17 pm
I have comments on various routes on page 3, supplementing Mapmikey's. Most of them are for routes above 105, but you should check my comments on GA 18 before you move on to 106 and higher.

GA 18 and GA 109:  In GA18 file, waypoint GA109_E is west of waypoint GA109 -- shouldn't they be GA109_W and GA109_E respectively? Similar issue in GA109 file for GA18 points.

On GA18, GA109_W would be at US27Alt_N (end of a concurrency). GA109_E is the other end of the concurrency. Plain GA109 is farther east along GA18 and is the east end of GA109. I think the existing tags are probably the best solution. Same for GA109 w/r/t GA18.

Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 19, 2019, 01:44:14 pm
Changes local for now.

GA 112:
Will investigate further

GA 117:
+X002: Moved and renamed to KinRd
FirRd: Moved
GA257: Moved
+X000: Removed

GA 120:
EstLp: Moved

GA 121:
+X011: Moved and renamed to CanRd
US25_S: Moved
GA23_S: Moved
GA88: Moved
US1Con: Removed

GA 122:
+X000: Moved and renamed to GatCreRd
+X002: Removed
+X003: Moved and renamed to SalRd

GA 124:
+X000: Moved and renamed to OldFouRd
GumSprCRd: Moved

GA 125:
ErnSumRd: Renamed to EarSumRd

GA 126:
EastChiRd: Renamed to ChiRd

GA 106-126

GA 112:  The 2017 Georgia Official map shows GA 112 ending at the Fall Line Freeway, which is marked as GA 243 east to GA 24 (this also affects the GA 24 and GA 29 files)...?

GA 117: move +X002 to KinnettRd?; FirRd point is very far off; GA257 point if off-center; +X000(GA117) is off

GA 119:  The visible distance error will have to be accepted IMO.  Even if you add a point at Old GA 129 there is still >10 miles to US 280 and there do not seem to be any roads or base entrances along GA 119.

GA 120: EstLp point is pretty far off;

GA 121: move +X011 to CanoocheeRd?; US25_S point needs to be moved south to new intersection location; GA23_S point needs to be moved south to new intersection location;GA88 point has been moved southward; US1Con point should be deleted (the only ramp to Bay St starts at the previous US25Bus point) as the ramp is signed as US 25BUs/GA 28?  Bay St itself is not in the primary system.

GA 122: move +X000 to GatCreRd?; remove +X002 and +X003 and instead put a point at SalemRd?

GA 124: move +X000 to OldFouRd?; GumSprCRd is pretty far off

GA 125: ErnSumRd->EarSumRd

GA 126: EastChiRd->ChiRd?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 19, 2019, 09:44:10 pm
Edits local.

GA 127:
+X007: Moved and renamed to HarRd

GA 129:
+X002: Moved and renamed to CanRd

GA 130:
+X000: Removed
+X001: Moved and renamed to CedVidRd
US1: Moved

GA 133:
OldAdelRd: Moved

GA 135:
CR185: Moved and renamed to TowBluRd

GA 136:
+X014: Moved and renamed to HillCityRd

GA 137:
HenCurRd: Moved


GA 127-137

GA 127: move +X007 to JuicePLantRd?;

GA 129: move +X002 to CannochieRd?

GA 130: move +X001 to Cedar Crossing Vidalia Rd?; US1 point needs to be moved south to new intersection

GA 133: OldAdelRd point needs to be moved to new intersection to the SE

GA 135: CR185->TowBluRd? (CR185 not signed here);

GA 136: +X014->HillCityRd?

GA 137: HenCurRd point needs to be moved SW to new intersection location
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 19, 2019, 09:58:55 pm
Local changes for now.

GA 138:
CamSt: Renamed to GA92_N
+X004: Moved and renamed to HemRd
+X005: Moved and renamed to OldConRd
GA10us: Renamed to GA10Bus

GA 142:
+X001: Moved and renamed to FlatRockRd

GA 144:
I don't think AndWay would be all that useful, and since it won't eliminate the visible point error, I'm not planning to add it.

GA 146:
US41: Renamed to US41/76

GA 151SprRin:
US41: Renamed to US41/76

US41trkrin:
Will get back to this

GA 153:
+X001: Renamed to WilReesRd

GA 138-153

GA 138: CamSt -> GA92_N?; +X004 ->HemphillRd?; +X005 ->OldConyersRd?; GA10us->GA10Bus

GA 142: move +X001 to FlatRockRd?

GA 144: a point east of RogRd could be added at Anderson Way which looks like a fully open road but doesn't get rid of the visual distance error over to GA 119;

GA 146: US41->US41/76?

GA151sprrin: US41->US41/76?

US41trkrin: There is a signed US 41 TRUCK that uses GA 151 and GA 151 Spur...very well posted as US 41 TRUCK, only 1 US 76 TRUCK posting at all that I saw in GMSV

GA 153: +X001->Willard Rees Rd?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on January 19, 2019, 11:24:40 pm
Changes local for now.

GA 112:
Will investigate further

GA 117:
+X002: Moved and renamed to KinRd
FirRd: Moved
GA257: Moved
+X000: Removed

GA 120:
EstLp: Moved

GA 121:
+X011: Moved and renamed to CanRd
US25_S: Moved
GA23_S: Moved
GA88: Moved
US1Con: Removed

GA 122:
+X000: Moved and renamed to GatCreRd
+X002: Removed
+X003: Moved and renamed to SalRd

GA 124:
+X000: Moved and renamed to OldFouRd
GumSprCRd: Moved

GA 125:
ErnSumRd: Renamed to EarSumRd

GA 126:
EastChiRd: Renamed to ChiRd





GA 112 was definitely truncated to the fall line freeway. I have driven by there since I offered the GA routes feedback.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 20, 2019, 10:59:18 am
Local right now. Planning on submitting this and the ones above tonight.
GA 154:
CocMillRd: Added
+X003: Moved and renamed to StoTellRd
+X004: Moved and renamed to EnonRd
GA154ConAtl: Will investigate further

GA 155:
+X004: Moved and renamed to TeaRd
GA136Con: Can't find these labels. I think this was comment was meant for GA156.

GA 156:
GA136Con: Labels swapped.

GA 158:
+X000: Moved and renamed to CouLineRd
HebChuRd: Moved
US441Trk: Renamed to GA206

GA 159:
+X001: Moved and renamed to AmbRebRd

GA 166:
Appears to have been removed from the repository previously. Need to look into if this still exists. GA166ConPor is still in the repo.

GA 177:
+X000, +X001, +X002, +X006: Removed

GA 177far:
SCFosSP: Moved to parking area
End: Added at pavement end

GA 154-177

GA 154: need a point at Cochran Mill Rd (just south of GA 92)?  This was where GA 70 left GA 154 until about 2007; move +X003 to Stonewall Tell Rd?; move +X004 to EnonRd?; Has GA154ConAtl been decommissioned?  signs removed at GA154 and not on the official map.  There is one shield leaving I-20

GA 155: move +X004 to TeamonRd?; the GA136Con E-W labels are reversed

GA 158: move +X000 to County LineRd?; HebChuRd point is pretty far off; US441Trk should either be labeled GA158Trk or GA206.  US441Truck is not signed from US441 (e.g. not a true US 441 truck route)

GA 159: move +X001 to Amboy-RebeccaRd?

GA 166: move +X010 to Stonewall Tell Rd?; move +X011 to EnonRd?

GA 177: neither +X001 nor +X002 are needed

GA 177far: all evidence points to GA 177 ending at the dead end (coincides with end of GMSV coverage) - official maps and Charlton County maps show this.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapcat on January 20, 2019, 11:52:55 am
GA 166:
Appears to have been removed from the repository previously. Need to look into if this still exists. GA166ConPor is still in the repo.
It's in usansf (as are GA 316 & GA 400) because part of it is a freeway. Rather than make up a separate file for the non-freeway portion, TheFXexpert just extended the existing route.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 20, 2019, 03:19:40 pm
Another local batch.

GA 32Trk and GA 158Trk:
Will come back to these later

GA 208:
US19: Moved

GA 215:
+X000: Moved and renamed to NobGinRd
+X001: Moved and renamed to WilCro

GA 216:
+X002: Moved and renamed to NicRd
GA45Alt: Added
+X003: Moved and renamed to HarRd
+X004: Neither road here (near Moye) is paved. Leaving as a shaping point.

GA 216TrkArl:
Will get to this one later

GA 228:
+X000: Moved and renamed to LacRd

GA 206-240

GA 32Trk and GA 158Trk:  These appear to be legitimate truck routes in Douglas following GA 206 and US 221

GA 208: US19 off center;

GA 215: move +X000 to Noble Gin Rd?; move +X001 to Williford Crossing?

GA 216: +X002 -> nickelsvilleRd?; missing GA45Alt point in Arlington (Cedar St); there is definitely a GA216Trkarl (follows 45 ALT and 62 west back to 216); move +X003 to Lovic Davis Rd?; move +X004 to BevisRd?

GA 228: move +X000 to LaCrosseRd?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 20, 2019, 09:11:36 pm
Pull request submitted (through GA 228).
https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/2546
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on January 21, 2019, 05:37:00 pm
Making changes locally for now.

GA 243:
Will investigate further, but based on previous commentary, I suspect this should be moved south.

GA 246:
Will split into 3 files. Won't be done immediately.

GA 252:
US1/23: Removed. I'm fairly certain this is how it's signed in the field. I wish I had thought about this 3 weeks ago when I was driving through Folkston, just to reconfirm everything.

GA 253:
+X005: Moved and renamed to CooRd
+X006: Movedand renamed to EldRd

GA 253sprbai:
Points reversed. Incidentally, is the preferred direction S to N or from its parent? Either way it's the same on this one.

GA 254:
+X000: Renamed to WebLakeRd

GA 256:
+X002: Moved and renamed to PineForRd

GA 257:
+X004: Moved and renamed to LimRd
+X005: Removed
+X006: Moved and renamed to RodHwy

GA 262:
+X003: Moved and renamed to CarlCloRd

GA 268:
CypAve: Renamed to CypSt

GA 241-274

GA 243: correct unless it follows Fall Line over to GA 24 as shown on 2017 Official

GA 246: should really be in 3 pieces (as should NC 106)...this is no different than VA/WV 102.  All 5 of the GA/NC crossings are marked in the field though there are no state route shields that I saw in GMSV between westernmost and easternmost crossings...I am open to discussion on this (since I would be responsible for NC 106 changes)...

GA 252: GA 252 appears to have been truncated to GA 40 CONN; 2017 official and 2015 Charlton County map show this.  Not posted at US 1-23-301; contradictory posting on latest GMSV at GA 40 CONN.  I did not notice this when reviewing GA 4-15 files so point name change with alt name needed for those...

GA 253: +X005 -> CooktownRd?

GA 253sprbai: reverse points for conventional direction?

GA 254: +X000 -> WebsterLakeRd?

GA 256: +X002 ->DouthitRd?

GA 257: move +X004 to LimestoneRd?; +X005 and +X006 could be consolidated as a point at Roddy Hwy

GA 262: move +X003 to Carl CloudRd?

GA 268: CypAve->CypSt
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on January 21, 2019, 06:00:22 pm
GA 243 was definitely signed on the Fall Line over to GA 24.

However will GA 243 go away entirely with the signing of GA 540 that has now commenced?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Eth on January 23, 2019, 11:19:24 am
GA154ConAtl: Will investigate further

GA 154: need a point at Cochran Mill Rd (just south of GA 92)?  This was where GA 70 left GA 154 until about 2007; move +X003 to Stonewall Tell Rd?; move +X004 to EnonRd?; Has GA154ConAtl been decommissioned?  signs removed at GA154 and not on the official map.  There is one shield leaving I-20

The shield at the end of the I-20 ramp was still present as of November 10, 2018. Most recent available GIS shapefiles still identify it as 154CO.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Wadsteckel on January 25, 2019, 08:24:44 pm
GA 243 was definitely signed on the Fall Line over to GA 24.

However will GA 243 go away entirely with the signing of GA 540 that has now commenced?

I was on the Fall Line today and noticed a lot of GA 540 signs between Sandersville and the Bobby Jones Expressway (I-540, where there is actually an ‘END’ sign).  I thought it strange that no mention of GA 88 was made until its points where it broke off the Fall Line.

-Ed S
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on February 02, 2019, 12:01:56 am
I drove from Augusta to Wrens.  I was able to confirm that GA 540 is indeed signed on US 1/GA 4 all the way from I-520 in Augusta to the southern part of Wrens.  There has even been extra confirming signage added to US 1/GA 4 for the GA 88 and GA 17 concurrencies.

In Thomson, which I added to this trip, I saw that US 78/GA 10 are still signed along GA 17 Byp. east of the city.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on February 02, 2019, 09:55:21 pm
Making local changes for now.

GA 282:
OldUS411: Renamed to OldUS411_N

GA 283:
+X000: Renamed to JimHoodRd
+X001: Moved and renamed to BenParRd
+X003: Removed

GA 284:
+X001: Moved and renamed to NopRd

GA 293concas:
Points swapped

GA 296:
GA102: Renamed to GA102_W
GA102_E: Added

GA 298:
+X000: Removed
+X001: Moved and renamed to NakCreRd

GA 300:
MocRd: Added
+X002: Moved and renamed to MicRd
US82_W: Renamed to US82_E

GA 301:
+X000: Renamed to MicRd

GA 302:
GA302Con: Renamed to GA302Spr

GA 303:
US17_S: Renamed to US17/82
US17_N: Renamed to US17

GA 305:
+X003: Moved and renamed to FarBriRd

GA 307:
JimDelCon: Added

GA 275-308

GA 282: OldUS411->OldUS411_N?

GA 283: +X000 -> JimHooodRd?

GA 284: move +X001 to Nopone or Glade Farm Rd?

GA 293concas: reverse points for standard direction?

GA 296: GA102->GA102_W; need point 1 block east for GA102_E

GA 298: move +X001 to Secret ForestRd?

GA 300: point needed between GA202 and GA188 (out of shape), suggest McMillan Rd; +X002 needs to be moved south to fix out of shape, suggest MicrowaveRd; US82_W->US82_E

GA 301: +X000->MichaelsRd?

GA 302: GA302Con->GA302Spr

GA 303: US17_S -> US17/82?; US17_N -> US17?

GA 305: move +X003 to FarmersBridgeRd?

GA 307: need a point at DeLoach Pkwy?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: charliezeb on February 05, 2019, 08:33:25 pm
Waypoint issue on US 411 / GA 20 between Rome and Cartersville. I have GA 20 in that stretch, and it's not giving me credit for US 411 between ReyBriRd (wpt 15) and US41_N (wpt 16). Those two are wpts 18 and 20 on GA 20; problem could be the existence of a wpt 19 (CowDr) on GA 20 that's not in the US 411 file.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on February 09, 2019, 07:38:26 pm
That's a temporary breakage. While going through and updating the GA routes, I didn't update the concurrent US routes. Should be fixed in a couple of weeks or so.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on February 09, 2019, 07:40:00 pm
-- Copied from new travels forum to check with the files --

 Re: New Travels and Stats Discussion
« Reply #253 on: February 01, 2019, 11:58:18 pm »

    Quote
    Modify
    Split Topic

I live in a suburb of Augusta, Georgia. This morning (2/1/2019), while on an extended lunch, I decided to drive down to Wrens, GA and then to Thomson.  There was no new mileage added, but I was able to confirm that GA 540 is indeed signed on US 1/GA 4 from Augusta to the southern part of Wrens, with lots of confirming signage added in Wrens itself for the GA 80 and GA 17 concurrencies, as well.  At the eastern terminus of GA 540, on US 1/GA 4, at their interchange with I-520, there is an "END" sign eastbound and a "JCT" sign and a GA 540 sign with an arrow pointing straight ahead westbound.  In Thomson, I confirmed that US 78/GA 10 do indeed still follow GA 17 Byp. east of the main part of the city.  On my way back, I drove on Harrison Road in the city, which I heard might be an older path of US 78/GA 10.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: rlee on February 14, 2019, 09:21:11 pm
All changes local for now. I probably won't get a chance to look at this again until Friday.

GA 11:
ShoeFacRd: Renamed to CleSt
Rerouted GA11 around east side of Blairsville. Need to check if anything still follows Cleveland St.

As of last July, no routes used Cleveland St. US 19, US 129, and GA 11 all used the east bypass. I did not get any photos unfortunately.

There is a break in the concurrency at the intersection of GA 11 S (US 19/129 S) and GA 2/515.  GA 515 does not have a point for GA 11 (US 19/129 S), and GA 2 and GA 11 do not show GA 515 at that intersection.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: kjslaughter on February 15, 2019, 08:07:28 am
I was doing some driving around central Georgia yesterday and noticed several changes to highways around Gray.  OpenStreets maps show the changes of US 129/GA11/GA 22, but my driving into town from the N on GA 11 and departure SW on US 129 confirmed that those roads have all been rerouted onto the new northern bypass.  Unusual for Georgia, I didn't see where a new GA 11 Bus route was created through town.  AS I look back through the threads, I see there was an open question on this earlier this year, so I can confirm.

Also, waypoint addition suggestion for GA 362 between Williamson and Griffin in Rover at Rover-Zetella Rd.  Traffic light there and Google maps routed me that way on trip north from Zebulon.  I'm not sure what the criterion for adding a waypoint is though.  For what it's worth, there is a waypoint where Rover-Zetella Rd. meets GA 16 further north.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Eth on February 15, 2019, 08:59:22 am
Also, waypoint addition suggestion for GA 362 between Williamson and Griffin in Rover at Rover-Zetella Rd.  Traffic light there and Google maps routed me that way on trip north from Zebulon.  I'm not sure what the criterion for adding a waypoint is though.  For what it's worth, there is a waypoint where Rover-Zetella Rd. meets GA 16 further north.

There's also a waypoint for Vaughn Rd (Rover-Zetella Rd's continuation) on GA 92.

Speaking of GA 92, I brought this up a while back but it doesn't seem to have been addressed yet: it follows US 19/41 and Business 19/41 to end at GA 16 in Griffin, but the HB is still showing it ending at US 19/41.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on February 17, 2019, 10:21:39 am
Changes local for now.

GA 309:
US84Bus_E: Renamed to US84Bus_W

GA 311:
GA97_N: Renamed to GA97

GA 313:
+X000: Moved and renamed to BryDr

GA 316:
WalBlvd: Marked as closed
UniCenDr: Marked as closed
WimWay: Added
+X011: Moved and renamed to DroCreRd
OcoCon: Added

GA 320:
+X001: Moved and renamed to NewBetRd

GA 324:
Point order reversed
+X001: Moved and renamed to DacRd
+X000: Moved and renamed to FenRd

GA 309-324

GA 309: US84Bus_E->US84Bus_W

GA 311: GA97_N -> GA97?

GA 313: +X000 -> MeddersRd?

GA 316: WalBlvd and UniCenLn should be closed waypoints?; need a point at Wimberly Ln ramp east of GA 20/124?; move +X011 to Drowning Creek Rd?; need point at Oconee connector (direct connection to GA 10 Loop?)

GA 320: move +X001 to New BethelRd?

GA 324: reverse points for standard direction (GA 324 is signed E-W)?; move +X000 to FenceRd and +X001 to DaculaRd?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapcat on February 17, 2019, 11:03:06 am
GA 316:
WalBlvd: Marked as closed
UniCenDr: Marked as closed
These are both really close to current waypoints, so they may be unnecessary. How long have they been closed? Maybe more importantly, how long were they open? No one is currently using either point, FWIW.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on February 17, 2019, 02:11:28 pm
Local changes for now.

GA 330:
+x000: Renamed to NewSavRd

GA 332:
+X003: Moved and renamed to TalRd

GA 334:
+X001: Renamed to SeaMillRd
+X002: Renamed to HLCemRd
+X003: Moved and renamed to AllRd

GA 335:
+X000: Moved and renamed to JefRivRd
+X001: Removed
Apple Valley Rd appears to be more useful (also a thicker line on OSM)

GA 337:
AL/GA: Moved

GA 341:
+X001: Moved and renamed to KenRd
+X003: Removed
+X004: Moved and renamed to MisRidRd

GA 354:
+X002: Removed
+X003: Remoed

GA 355:
+X001: Renamed to OldGA137
+X002: Renamed to OldGA103

GA 325-358

GA 330: +X000 -> SavageRd?

GA 332: new point at either Main/Talmo Tr or Main/Old Gainesville Hwy?; move +X003 to Talmo Rd?

GA 334: +X001 -> Seagraves MillRd?; +X002 ->Harris Lord Cemetery Rd?; +X003 -> Allen Rd (was US 441)?

GA 335: move +X000 to Jefferson River Rd?; move AppVal Rd to ThyBro Rd and delete +X001?

GA 337: AL/GA point is off by a fair bit;

GA 341: move +X001 to KensingtonRd?; move +X004 to Mission Ridge Rd?

GA 354: neither +X002 nor +X003 are necessary

GA 355: +X001 ->OldGA137?; +X002 -> OldGA103?;
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on February 17, 2019, 06:46:10 pm
Still keeping locally for now.

GA 360:
GA120_W: Renamed to GA120_E
+X001: Renamed to SanRd

GA 362:
+X005: Renamed to RovZetRd

GA 365:
+X021: Moved and renamed to MudCreRd
+x022: Moved and renamed to DemRd

GA 369:
GA20: Moved
+X005: Moved and renamed to MemParkDr

GA 372:
ProRd: Moved

GA 360-378

GA 360: GA120_W -> GA120?; +X001 -> SandtownRd?

GA 362: +X005 -> MorelandRd?

GA 365: move +X021 to MudCatRd?; move +X022 to Demorest-Mt Airy Hwy? (this one affects GA 15 which I did not notice before)

GA 369: GA20 point is off; move +X005 to Memorial ParkRd?

GA 372: ProRd point is off
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on February 17, 2019, 06:57:06 pm
Will submit this (and the last several batches) tonight.

GA 382:
GA515: Renamed to GA5/515

GA 385:
US441 points renamed to US23/441

GA 400:
BurStaRd: Added

GA 515:
OrvLaneDr: Renamed to OrvLanDr
US19/129: Renamed to US19/129_N
US129Trk_S: Renamed to CleSt
US19/129_S: Added
CroCrkCon: Moved

GA 520:
InnSt: Renamed to InmSt

GA 380-520
This completes my detailed suggested feedback on the Georgia State Highways

GA 382: GA515 -> GA5/515?

GA 385: US441_S -> US23/441_S; US441_N -> US23/441_N?

GA 400: need shaping point north of GA136 (out of tolerance)

GA 515: OrvLaneDr -> OrvLanDr?; US19/129 -> US19/129_N; US129Trk->PatHarMemDr; new point needed for US19/129_S at Glenn Gooch Bypass east of Blairsville (US 19/129 rerouted in Blairsville); CroCreCon is pretty off center;

GA 520: InnSt->InmSt
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on February 17, 2019, 07:08:01 pm
Next steps:

1. Go back through the routes, fixing any locations where I added a point to one route, but not its concurrent route, or adjusted them differently.
2. Update the US routes to reflect the new points/locations.
3. Finish going through the rest of the review comments.

Item 1 will be started next weekend.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: oscar on February 17, 2019, 07:18:27 pm
Next steps:

1. Go back through the routes, fixing any locations where I added a point to one route, but not its concurrent route, or adjusted them differently.
2. Update the US routes to reflect the new points/locations.
3. Finish going through the rest of the review comments.

Item 1 will be started next weekend.

I suggest starting with item 3, to pick up and address any comments you missed. I think you covered all of mine.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: neroute2 on February 17, 2019, 07:46:43 pm
I think you missed my comment on GA 299, for example.
http://forum.travelmapping.net/index.php?topic=215.msg12758#msg12758

Confirmed on the Goog: https://www.google.com/maps/@34.9750691,-85.4043446,3a,33.5y,347.92h,85.3t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sqD2bZ_SFXUwVrLetGr-8sQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on March 13, 2019, 09:29:34 pm
Work has gotten in the way recently. Looks like it will be a couple more weeks before I can put in any significant time. Still working through the comments.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: formulanone on May 22, 2019, 08:19:30 am
GA 1 Loop for the western leg of the Rome Bypass (US 27 to GA 20) is missing an entry.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on June 14, 2019, 02:55:02 am
When will GA 540 be added to the highway browser? It is signed along US 80/GA 22 from the Alabama state line to Geneva, GA 96 from Geneva to Fort Valley, GA 49 Conn in the Fort Valley area, GA 49 from Fort Valley to Byron, I-75 from Byron to Macon, I-16 in Macon, US 80 in Macon, US 23/US 129 Alt from Macon to East Macon, and GA 57 from East Macon to the Gordon area. It has a solo alignment from there to southeast of Milledgeville. Then, it follows GA 24 from there to Sandersville, GA 88 from Sandersville to Wrens, and US 1/GA 4 from Wrens to Augusta.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: neroute2 on June 14, 2019, 09:55:51 pm
the Gordon area. It has a solo alignment from there to southeast of Milledgeville.
Since when?
http://www.google.com/maps/@32.9772217,-83.2144804,3a,27.2y,49.53h,90.66t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s9N5hbdxjUeY8zhS1sAl7aw!2e0!7i16384!8i8192
http://www.google.com/maps/@33.0385796,-83.1168359,3a,15y,339.17h,86.92t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s1quuYPnuYAP-LlZUAdRaYQ!2e0!7i16384!8i8192
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on June 15, 2019, 11:04:05 am
At either the end of last year (2018) or sometime this year, GA 243 was decommissioned.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: michih on September 14, 2019, 06:43:17 am
There are some HIDDEN_JUNCTION data errors: http://travelmapping.net/devel/datacheck.php?rg=GA
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: yakra on September 18, 2019, 11:57:14 pm
GA15 has broken concurrencies near Tallulah Gorge SP.
WilCon <-> +X036(GA15)
GA15Lp_S <-> US441BusCla_N


Are GA19 & US41BusMac concurrent between I-75 and the Georgia Ave / College St intersection? They're plotted differently.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: neroute2 on September 22, 2019, 05:21:58 pm
US 41 and SR 3: GA3ConMan -> GA3ConMar
US 41 and SR 3: requesting a point at http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=33.88871&lon=-84.47428 for WinRidPkwy
SR 120: requesting a point at http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=33.969417&lon=-84.489090 for ELakePkwy (I turned off onto Robinson Road, but that name is ambiguous since it returns to SR 120)
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: yakra on October 04, 2019, 01:50:09 am
Just took a look at GA90. Many of the hidden shaping points are at or near road junctions, and should be converted to visible points.
"Prefer an intersection to act as a shaping point location wherever possible. Shaping points that coincide with intersections should be added as normal, visible waypoints labeled in the usual way." (http://travelmapping.net/devel/manual/includepts.php)
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: yakra on October 10, 2019, 06:51:49 pm
US27:
GA100Ced_S -> GA100_Ced: this is a town suffix for disambiguation purposes, rather than a city abbreviation for one of multiple bannerless GA100 routes. With no other GA100_Ced point to disambiguate from (having US278_W instead), no need for the additional 'S' at the end.
GA100_End style labels have been deprecated a while; GA100/114, as GA1 has it, would work.

GA100:
US27Ced_S -> US27_Ced
US27 -> US27_Sum?

GA1: GA100Ced_S -> GA100_Ced
GA53: GA211_WinN -> GA211_Win
GA211: GA53Win_W -> GA53_Win

Similar labeling may be a wider issue.

There are some HIDDEN_JUNCTION data errors: http://travelmapping.net/devel/datacheck.php?rg=GA
A quick look at US27 & GA1 in side-by-side browser tabs shows lots of broken concurrencies. Some of these cases will be HIDDEN_JUNCTION, some VISIBLE_HIDDEN_COLOC, some NMPs, and some plain old points included in one route but not another. The HDX (http://courses.teresco.org/metal/hdx/) is a great help in checking concurrencies.
One especially tricky one I noticed:
US1: GA46/86 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=32.3692444&lon=-82.3236297
GA46: US1_S http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=32.3692444&lon=-82.3236297
These both use 7 decimal places while GA4 uses the standard 6, breaking the junction & concurrency.
GA4: GA46/86 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=32.369244&lon=-82.323630
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on October 14, 2019, 05:40:44 am
I just noticed that GA 73 Byp (Statesboro) is missing from the highway browser. It is entirely concurrent with US 301 Byp (Statesboro).
Title: GA: GA 73 Byp (Statesboro) Missing
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on October 16, 2019, 02:41:11 am
The GA 73 Bypass for Statesboro, Georgia is missing from the highway browser.  It is completely concurrent with US 301 Byp (Statesboro).
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: kjslaughter on October 17, 2019, 09:47:30 am
Hey, I made a post on another board/thread, but just wanted to say thanks for the work on this system (and the whole site really!).  I'd love to help if I knew what the need was.  I've lived in Georgia my whole life and my background is analytics (accounting, into finance and now business analytics) so I'm glad to lend a hand on this site doing whatever I can to help.  I don't want to just be a user if I can give back and help in anyway.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: michih on October 17, 2019, 12:11:11 pm
@kjslaughter:

I've added:

usaga Georgia State Highways reviewer: ntallyn

Sorry, I was being confusing. I'm not reviewing the GA highways, I'm doing the update work (I picked it up around Christmastime).

well, no. I thought that your "update work" is also the peer-review. But if I'm not mistaken, you are quite new, your first "new" system? If so, I think that another more experienced contributor should peer-review it. If you prefer being peer-reviewed, just edit the first post and replace your name by t.b.d.

You are not the "more experienced contributor" but any kind of review is better than no review. Just go through the routes and official state sources and report what seems to be wrong. I don't know how familar you are to our rules but you can find them in the manual (http://travelmapping.net/devel/tools.php).

I think ntallyn might want to complete the update work first?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on November 01, 2019, 05:45:04 am
GA 28:
Should GA 28's southern segment remain in the system, since part of it in Augusta is a freeway (John C. Calhoun Expressway)?

GA 29/243:
With GA 243 being totally decommissioned, the portion that was concurrent with US 441 Bus (Milledgeville) has been redesignated as GA 29 Bus (Milledgeville).

GA 35:
GA 35, which is completely concurrent with US 319, has two special routes: GA 35 Conn (Thomasville) and GA 35 Loop (Tifton). Both are missing from the highway browser.

GA 73:
In the Statesboro area, GA 73 Byp (Statesboro) is missing from the highway browser. It is indeed a signed highway that is totally concurrent with US 301 Byp (Statesboro). Its southern portion is also concurrent with GA 67 Byp (Statesboro).

GA 540:
GA 540 is still missing from the highway browser.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: michih on November 01, 2019, 02:17:06 pm
GA 73:
In the Statesboro area, GA 73 Byp (Statesboro) is missing from the highway browser. It is indeed a signed highway that is totally concurrent with US 301 Byp (Statesboro). Its southern portion is also concurrent with GA 67 Byp (Statesboro).

You already reported it twice upthread. I think that the responsible highway data manager for Georgia will address it when s/he has time.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on November 01, 2019, 10:45:48 pm
I know that I reported it twice, but no one commented on it to inform me as to whether they saw it.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: rickmastfan67 on November 01, 2019, 11:42:23 pm
I know that I reported it twice, but no one commented on it to inform me as to whether they saw it.

Look @ how I'm currently dealing with the FL thread.  I'm dealing with each post one at a time, and in order of them being posted (with a few minor exceptions).  I'm sure ntallyn will comment on your posts when they have the chance. ;)
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on November 02, 2019, 02:20:53 am
I apologize for sounding upset.  I don't post much on this forum; when I do, I seem to get chewed out.  All I wanted was some recognition that my post was seen.  That's all.  Also, I was giving needed suggestions for the Georgia portion of the "project".
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapcat on November 02, 2019, 01:44:52 pm
All I wanted was some recognition that my post was seen.  That's all.
And now you are aware that in some regions that recognition will not come promptly. This is not personal.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on November 16, 2019, 08:45:57 pm
GA 11 Byp. (Cleveland) and GA 75 Conn. (White County) are missing from the highway browser.  Since the connector is just north of Cleveland, the disambiguator could be that city instead of the county.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 17, 2019, 09:46:16 am
The Glenn Gooch Bypass (not sure of exact spelling) is not US 19 or US 129.  It is US 129 Truck and SR 11 Truck.
According to GDOT State Functional Map, US 19/129/GA 11 have been rerouted onto the Glenn Gooch Bypass. Cleveland St and Pat Harrison are now Local roads. This redesignation happened in January 2015. GMSV shows the Jan 2016 signage at the US 76 intersection with US 19/129/GA 11. US 76, US 19 and US 129 all need to be updated to reflect the new route.
Updated locally.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 17, 2019, 10:03:04 am
Hi all,

Back home (as I am lately) for the weekend after my travels during the week.  On Thursday, I drove from Gaffney SC to Gainesville GA to deliver a load, and took GA 17 from I-85 to US 23.  I see on the TM system that the routing is currently using its historical route through Avalon.  From what I saw on the signage, the route is on the bypass.  Is GA going to create a Business route through Avalon?  Is the TM system going to be updated to show GA 17 on the bypass?

Many thanks to everyone on the hard work keeping this going.

Regards,
-Ed S

GA 17 moved locally. Also adjusted the end of GA 328. There is no evidence of a GA 17 Bus there.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 17, 2019, 10:12:28 am
TM has GA 92 ending at US 19/41 north of Griffin, but I can't find any evidence of this. As far as I can tell, GA 92 still continues down US 19/41 and then Business 19/41 into downtown Griffin to end at GA 16 as it has for decades. GDOT's most recent Spalding County map shows this, though it is admittedly from 2013. GSV still shows GA 92 signed as such as of 2016.

GMSV, as of September 2018 shows the following
* GA 92 southbound approaching US 19/41: no signage for GA 92 turning south
* GA 16 eastbound approaching US 19/41: no signage for GA 92
* US 19/41 southbound before GA 92: GA 92 both south and west from intersection.
* US 19/41 southbound after GA 92: GA 92 SOUTH sign

Is it signed? Sure. Can a driver follow it? Maybe? Will put it on my to-check list.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 17, 2019, 10:16:31 am
Found a route that needs to be fixed during my travels through Commerce, GA yesterday.  GA 334 needs to be extended past it's current end point in the system to end at GA 98 just a few miles north.  It threw me off when I realized there was no corresponding route shown in system for that stretch of US 441 Bus which isn't like GADOT at all.  Google street view confirms if you look at 567 S. Elm St., look north and clearly see route marker.

GA334 extended locally.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 17, 2019, 10:26:48 am
http://tm.teresco.org/hb/?units=miles&r=ga.ga025consav

It's missing the '7' point from I-516/GA-21/GA-25.  Should be between the 'LatAve' & 'US80_W' points in the file.

That one is a bit of a mess. One could argue that at 1PPI, I-516 is already represented. But as I-516 has separate points, I'll add the point to GA25ConSav. Local, for now.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 17, 2019, 10:49:49 am
Update on feedback regarding fall line fwy and GA112

I drove the fall line fwy  from Wrens to Macon today.

The part leaving west from GA 24 is signed as GA 243. GA 112 north was truncated to this road as well

GA 112 shortened to GA 540 (Fall Line Freeway).
GA 243 moved from Milledgeville routing to FLF routing.
Old 243 appears to no longer be signed as anything.
GA 540 is in my queue.

All changes local for now.
Title: Re: GA: Georgia 21 Alternate
Post by: ntallyn on November 17, 2019, 11:08:08 am
By email from user aaroads:

Quote
Also on the way northward last month, I drove the new port connector at Garden City/Port Wentworth, GA, which is an extension of Jimmy DeLoach Parkway. It is signed as Georgia 21 Alternate, with the route using Sonny Dixon Interchange (an access road linking GA 21 with the parkway) and along the connector freeway southeast to GA 307.

Added locally.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 17, 2019, 11:21:56 am
Broken concurrency:
GA23@GA144_W mismatches GA57@GA144_W&GA144@GA23/57.
Recommend changing GA23@GA144_W to http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=31.939848&lon=-81.937907
This is the only broken multiplex I've spotted, and there's a LOT of multiplexing in GA!

Labels:
GA7BusVal (concurrent with I-75BLVal & US41BusVal) has points labeled OldGA125 and OldUS221_N. These should be named after the current road names instead. I'm gonna close the browser window now before I disappear down a rabbit hole; it's possible there could be more of these around the state.

Both items fixed locally. Also fixed OldGA94 (on GA7BusVal) and OldUS41 (on I-75BLVal). Added hidden labels for the "Old" names on US41Bus and I-75BL.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 17, 2019, 11:33:14 am
GA8ConVil exists (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.7286722,-84.8998118,3a,43.2y,94.82h,95.17t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sg8u5s9kj1059z-1rJUW7GQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)

Added locally.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 17, 2019, 11:41:58 am

P.S. changes to US 19 and 129 files and deletion of US 129 Truck needs to be done as well.


Changes made locally. Incidentally, is there any reason we still have 2 files for the route listings? i.e. usausb.csv AND usausb_con.csv?
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Markkos1992 on November 17, 2019, 01:31:53 pm
ntallyn, the below link is to direct you to the posts in the SC State Highways Thread on the NMP with US 221/GA 150 at the GA/SC Line.

http://forum.travelmapping.net/index.php?topic=104.msg16182#msg16182
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 17, 2019, 06:20:23 pm
ntallyn, the below link is to direct you to the posts in the SC State Highways Thread on the NMP with US 221/GA 150 at the GA/SC Line.

http://forum.travelmapping.net/index.php?topic=104.msg16182#msg16182

Updated locally.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Jim on November 17, 2019, 06:58:51 pm
Incidentally, is there any reason we still have 2 files for the route listings? i.e. usausb.csv AND usausb_con.csv?

Both are needed, as in some systems there are routes that cross regional boundaries that are part of a single route.  We've called these "connected" routes, hence the _con in the file name.  Inconsistencies between these files are considered a fatal error in the site update process and will cause that site update to terminate without any database modification.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Eth on November 17, 2019, 09:51:59 pm
TM has GA 92 ending at US 19/41 north of Griffin, but I can't find any evidence of this. As far as I can tell, GA 92 still continues down US 19/41 and then Business 19/41 into downtown Griffin to end at GA 16 as it has for decades. GDOT's most recent Spalding County map shows this, though it is admittedly from 2013. GSV still shows GA 92 signed as such as of 2016.

GMSV, as of September 2018 shows the following
* GA 92 southbound approaching US 19/41: no signage for GA 92 turning south
* GA 16 eastbound approaching US 19/41: no signage for GA 92
* US 19/41 southbound before GA 92: GA 92 both south and west from intersection.
* US 19/41 southbound after GA 92: GA 92 SOUTH sign

Is it signed? Sure. Can a driver follow it? Maybe? Will put it on my to-check list.

Apart from the lack of signage for the first turn onto US 19/41, I'd say a driver can follow it:

GA 92 SOUTH departing US 19/41, using Business 19/41 into downtown (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.2674608,-84.2901456,3a,75y,154.5h,91.53t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sAZCgpw9HfK6_MuUeuAl_Zw!2e0!5s20180901T000000!7i13312!8i6656?hl=en)*

GA 92 SOUTH signed on the ramp after departure (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.2648962,-84.290128,3a,75y,198.55h,82.4t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sQcSV_bUAFjgbwqOf1ZjEwQ!2e0!5s20180901T000000!7i13312!8i6656?hl=en)

END GA 92, as Business 19/41 prepares to turn left onto eastbound GA 16 (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.2481307,-84.2867038,3a,75y,163.95h,90.89t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1soGYbIahmPoobgO2jRflAgg!2e0!5s20180901T000000!7i13312!8i6656?hl=en)

* Note that this one also raises some questions about GA 3 and GA 7. Signage here, and only here, claims that GA 3 is also following Business 19/41 while the freeway is shown as GA 7. I can find no other mention of GA 3 on the business route, which in GMSV continues to be signed as GA 92/16/155 as expected. The only signage I can find of either 3 or 7 at the south end of the bypass is on northbound US 19 (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.1952509,-84.2842053,3a,75y,48.42h,90t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sCOvMJHz314hnOATjKCnCJQ!2e0!5s20180901T000000!7i16384!8i8192?hl=en), which is inconclusive. GDOT 2018 Spalding County map (http://www.dot.ga.gov/DriveSmart/MapsData/Documents/CountyMaps/Spalding.pdf) still shows 3 on the bypass, not 7. So I'd probably assume that the current TM routings of 3 and 7 are still correct.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: neroute2 on November 17, 2019, 10:44:44 pm
Still 3 on reassurance (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.2342999,-84.2943077,3a,17y,14.16h,90.55t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sk7Zuom5aO6Tew8dhfOveUQ!2e0!5s20180901T000000!7i16384!8i8192?hl=en) on the bypass and trailblazers (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.2473546,-84.2979611,3a,17.1y,107.25h,91.58t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sl0g2uOSoWscE6Bd5KKq4VQ!2e0!5s20180901T000000!7i13312!8i6656?hl=en) on 16. I agree that the sign pointing 3 on the business route is in error.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 18, 2019, 09:12:25 pm
I have a handful of notes to still make my way through, as well as any comments on this thread beginning with #165.

I'm expecting to be able to push the last batch of updates over Thanksgiving weekend (including all of the items I've marked above as "local").

After I finish those updates, I will still need to go back and verify concurrencies/intersections among routes, and updating the concurrent US routes.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on November 19, 2019, 10:02:20 am
That sounds good.  Thank you for going through the updates and thread.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: yakra on November 21, 2019, 04:34:06 am
GA21:
GA21Spr -> GA21SprGar
GA21Spr_Spr -> GA21SprSpr

Quote from: http://travelmapping.net/devel/manual/wayptlabels.php
US40:US40BusWhi
US73:US40BusWhi    US40BusTho

Distinguish two different same-bannered same-numbered routes as needed with the 3-letter city abbreviations.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 29, 2019, 02:09:44 pm
GA15 has broken concurrencies near Tallulah Gorge SP.
WilCon <-> +X036(GA15)
GA15Lp_S <-> US441BusCla_N


Are GA19 & US41BusMac concurrent between I-75 and the Georgia Ave / College St intersection? They're plotted differently.

Fixed the US highways locally for both of these. The one in Macon is quite a mess with the one-way couplet being several blocks wide and making a turn in the middle of it.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 29, 2019, 02:22:31 pm
US 41 and SR 3: GA3ConMan -> GA3ConMar
US 41 and SR 3: requesting a point at http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=33.88871&lon=-84.47428 for WinRidPkwy
SR 120: requesting a point at http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=33.969417&lon=-84.489090 for ELakePkwy (I turned off onto Robinson Road, but that name is ambiguous since it returns to SR 120)

Local changes for now.

Fixed the spelling error.
Added WinRidPkwy (only because the similar AkeMillRd is already there on the other side of I-285).
Did not add ELakePkwy, as it doesn't really do much. It's only 1.5 miles between existing points already.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 29, 2019, 02:54:50 pm
Just took a look at GA90. Many of the hidden shaping points are at or near road junctions, and should be converted to visible points.
"Prefer an intersection to act as a shaping point location wherever possible. Shaping points that coincide with intersections should be added as normal, visible waypoints labeled in the usual way." (http://travelmapping.net/devel/manual/includepts.php)

Significantly updated (locally). Made matching changes to GA 11, 96, and 127 where concurrent.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 29, 2019, 03:05:07 pm
US27:
GA100Ced_S -> GA100_Ced: this is a town suffix for disambiguation purposes, rather than a city abbreviation for one of multiple bannerless GA100 routes. With no other GA100_Ced point to disambiguate from (having US278_W instead), no need for the additional 'S' at the end.
GA100_End style labels have been deprecated a while; GA100/114, as GA1 has it, would work.

GA100:
US27Ced_S -> US27_Ced
US27 -> US27_Sum?

GA1: GA100Ced_S -> GA100_Ced
GA53: GA211_WinN -> GA211_Win
GA211: GA53Win_W -> GA53_Win

Similar labeling may be a wider issue.

One especially tricky one I noticed:
US1: GA46/86 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=32.3692444&lon=-82.3236297
GA46: US1_S http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=32.3692444&lon=-82.3236297
These both use 7 decimal places while GA4 uses the standard 6, breaking the junction & concurrency.
GA4: GA46/86 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=32.369244&lon=-82.323630

Fixed all of these above (as well as a couple of non-concurrency points on US1 and GA86 that had 7 decimal places.

There are some HIDDEN_JUNCTION data errors: http://travelmapping.net/devel/datacheck.php?rg=GA
A quick look at US27 & GA1 in side-by-side browser tabs shows lots of broken concurrencies. Some of these cases will be HIDDEN_JUNCTION, some VISIBLE_HIDDEN_COLOC, some NMPs, and some plain old points included in one route but not another. The HDX (http://courses.teresco.org/metal/hdx/) is a great help in checking concurrencies.

That will be part of the next batch of cleanup. I still have to learn how to use the various tools beyond the waypoint editor.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 29, 2019, 03:10:47 pm
GA 28:
Should GA 28's southern segment remain in the system, since part of it in Augusta is a freeway (John C. Calhoun Expressway)?

GA 29/243:
With GA 243 being totally decommissioned, the portion that was concurrent with US 441 Bus (Milledgeville) has been redesignated as GA 29 Bus (Milledgeville).

GA 35:
GA 35, which is completely concurrent with US 319, has two special routes: GA 35 Conn (Thomasville) and GA 35 Loop (Tifton). Both are missing from the highway browser.

GA 73:
In the Statesboro area, GA 73 Byp (Statesboro) is missing from the highway browser. It is indeed a signed highway that is totally concurrent with US 301 Byp (Statesboro). Its southern portion is also concurrent with GA 67 Byp (Statesboro).

GA 540:
GA 540 is still missing from the highway browser.

GA28: If it's signed as GA28, it will remain in the system.
GA29Bus (Milledgeville): to be added.
GA243: Still signed along the Fall Line Freeway. New routing updated locally.
GA35 routes: to be added.
GA73Byp (Statesboro): to be added.
GA540: to be added.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 29, 2019, 03:14:19 pm
GA21:
GA21Spr -> GA21SprGar
GA21Spr_Spr -> GA21SprSpr

Fixed locally.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 29, 2019, 03:29:17 pm
I've made it through all of the comments above and made changes locally. Here's what's left:

GA11Byp (Cleveland): add
GA12Trk/US278Trk (Madison): add?
GA29Bus (Milledgeville): add?
GA32Trk (Douglas): add
GA35Con (Thomasville): add
GA35Lp (Tifton): add
GA37Trk (Camilla): add
GA45Trk (Colquitt): add
GA62Trk (Arlington): add
GA73: update routing
GA73Byp (Statesboro): add
GA75Con (Cleveland/White Co.): add
GA86 (Oak Park): update
GA91Trk (Colquitt): add
GA92: end location at Griffin? Probably leaving this one as-is for now.
GA154ConAtl: add?
GA158Trk (Douglas): add
GA166: update
GA216Trk (Arlington): add
GA246: split
GA540: add

US1 (Oak Park): update
US278Trk (Madison): add?

Gray Bypass (all routes): update

I hope to push all of the above before the end of the weekend. Then the hard work begins:

GA route concurrency/intersection checks
US route updates to reflect GA route updates
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 29, 2019, 04:29:48 pm
GA29Bus (Milledgeville): add?

Based on this turn sign https://www.google.com/maps/@33.0828522,-83.2338621,3a,75y,307.67h,89.07t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sUQcXlQH0uKlu9aGRDsSM5Q!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 (and one at the previous northbound turn), I'm going to add GA29BusMid for the entire route of US441BusMil, rather than ending it where GA243 used to end. Unfortunately, the signage goes cold after that, but this would also allow it to meet back up with GA29 on the north side of town.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 29, 2019, 04:46:45 pm
GA32Trk (Douglas): add

I can find no signs along the presumptive route on GMSV. Nor are there any signs for Truck 32 heading east towards Douglas. The only signs I can find are approaching the loop around Douglas from the various other routes (including westbound 32). I also don't recall seeing any along the western side of town (following 206) when I was there last month.

Wanting to leave this out for now...
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on November 29, 2019, 09:49:34 pm
Pull request submitted:
https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3367

But there are conflicts (in the usausb.csv files). So obviously I'm doing something wrong. I figured when the system fetched the origin branch, it would update my master branch, as it does when I do it at work (though that is git, not github), and notify me of the conflict at that time. But that certainly isn't the case, as every file that I haven't changed has the time stamp of when I created the branch in the first place.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: yakra on November 30, 2019, 04:57:56 pm
US27:
GA100Ced_S -> GA100_Ced: this is a town suffix for disambiguation purposes, rather than a city abbreviation for one of multiple bannerless GA100 routes.
Ack, lemme try to be more clear on this.
The abbreviation being tacked directly onto the end of a route designation (no underscore) implies there's a route by that .list name.
Whereas when there is a suffix, what comes before it would be the .list name (or just the route+banner, whatever's necessary to get rid of ambiguity).
Suffixes added to disambiguate otherwise-identical (http://205.209.84.174/devel/manual/wayptlabels.php#disambiguation) labels (when we're not using an abbrev (http://travelmapping.net/devel/manual/syshwylist.php)) come after an underscore. Compare the _A _B _C _N _S _E _W suffixes that perform the same function.
It's the subtle difference between this rule (http://205.209.84.174/devel/manual/wayptlabels.php#abbrev) and this one (http://205.209.84.174/devel/manual/wayptlabels.php#over2). In this case, the latter applies.

Thus:
US27 should have GA100_Ced, not GA100Ced
GA1 should have GA100_Ced, not GA100Ced
GA100 should have US27_Ced, not US27Ced. US27_Sum looks good.
GA211: GA53_Win looks good.

GA8ConVil:
http://205.209.84.174/devel/manual/wayptlabels.php#parentonly
This may show up on other bannered (spr/con/etc.) routes.

GA29BusMil:
AllMemDrSW -> AllMemDr
VinHwySE -> VinHwy (http://205.209.84.174/devel/manual/wayptlabels.php#dropdirection)
MLKingJrDr -> MarKingDr or MLKingJDr (http://205.209.84.174/devel/manual/wayptlabels.php#truncate)

GA35ConTho: GA35Con -> GA35

GA53:
There is no junction at GA1Lp_A.
GA211_Win label looks right :)

US19/129:
Missing an interchange at what's in the HB as US129TrkBla (which I assume no longer exists as such?); labeling might be tricky.

US23:
OldGA361 -> ArkRd or BassRd
OldBetRd is off (coords on GA42 are good)
GEHBMemHwy -> HoodAve or AnvBloRd (also affects GA42)
OldUS441Lak_S's coords are off. Realigned intersection? GA15 has better coords here. Should become OldUS441_S, unless the road at the actual intersection is determined to be part of Terrora Circle.
OldUS441Lak_N would become OldUS441_N or OldUS441 as the case may be.

US76:
US129Trk_S: Is this still a US129Trk route?

US129:
GA2_E -> US76_E
US76 +US76_W -> US76_W +US76

US411:
There is no junction at GA1Lp_A.

US441:
Many of the OldUS441 points have modern stable road names to use instead.
For example, OSM shows the first one as Bacon St.
The remaining ones will need their city suffixes shifted to after the underscore (An old route will not be in the database and will by definition not have an abbrev). Most of those with a directional suffix in addition to the city will need the directional character dropped, unless the city alone is insufficient to disambiguate.

US129TrkBla:  Does this still exist?

A lot of the rest of what I saw while skimming thru the changes looks good:
• Replacing OldFoo labels with modern stable road names like GriAve.
• Replacing hidden shaping points with visible points, particularly on GA90. I didn't look in exhaustive detail, but this probably goes a ways toward fixing broken concurrencies.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: yakra on December 02, 2019, 02:52:47 am
I've copied over the changes from #3367 (https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3367) into my fork, fixing the broken CSVs in the process.
Before we start discussion on merging it into the master branch, and how to best restore ntallyn:master to working order, a couple more notes...

US76:
Rather than move the in-use AltLabel US19/129_S to a new location and mess up stats & maps for those using it, the new point could be called US19_S, allowing us to leave the existing AltLabel in place. Probably best for US19/129_N (still in the HB as US19/129) to become US19_N in the process.

GA1LpRow needs a shaping point S of BlaBluRd

GA21AltPor:
missing Grange Rd interchange
SonDixInt -> JimDelPkwy (https://www.google.com/maps/@32.1629439,-81.1793726,3a,15y,56.84h,90.11t/data=!3m10!1e1!3m8!1skXkAztZudKu9x_Jft9ebsw!2e0!6s%2F%2Fgeo3.ggpht.com%2Fcbk%3Fpanoid%3DkXkAztZudKu9x_Jft9ebsw%26output%3Dthumbnail%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26thumb%3D2%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D193.53859%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i13312!8i6656!9m2!1b1!2i40) (While Sonny Dixon Int (https://www.google.com/maps/@32.1633326,-81.1788705,3a,75y,342.41h,83.77t/data=!3m10!1e1!3m8!1sNDHym6aoHPf9DVyT2x6fTw!2e0!6s%2F%2Fgeo2.ggpht.com%2Fcbk%3Fpanoid%3DNDHym6aoHPf9DVyT2x6fTw%26output%3Dthumbnail%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26thumb%3D2%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D60.232178%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i13312!8i6656!9m2!1b1!2i40) does appear to be an actual road name, it's part of GA21Alt itself, not what GA21Alt intersects with.
GA25 -> GA21_N



I can get this stuff ready to merge back in, but would like to address some of these items from my last couple posts in the process.
@ntallyn, once you go to merge it back into your master branch, there will be merge conflicts. Rather than poke the git gods with a stick & try to resolve them, I'm thinking that resetting your master branch to the state it was in before your last commit may be the safer option. It's a clunky process, a bit roundabout. I can post instructions.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Jim on December 02, 2019, 07:56:05 am
I can get this stuff ready to merge back in, but would like to address some of these items from my last couple posts in the process.
@ntallyn, once you go to merge it back into your master branch, there will be merge conflicts. Rather than poke the git gods with a stick & try to resolve them, I'm thinking that resetting your master branch to the state it was in before your last commit may be the safer option. It's a clunky process, a bit roundabout. I can post instructions.

For our purposes it might be easiest to delete and recreate the fork.  I think this would only be problematic if there are changes in the local clone that are not yet either in the TravelMapping master or in the offending pull request that yarka's working through.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: neroute2 on December 02, 2019, 08:22:14 am
To update your own repository, use this link (replacing neroute2 with your own username): https://github.com/neroute2/HighwayData/compare/master...TravelMapping:master
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: yakra on December 02, 2019, 10:13:07 am
To update your own repository, use this link (replacing neroute2 with your own username): https://github.com/neroute2/HighwayData/compare/master...TravelMapping:master
That would cause some hairy merge conflicts.

For our purposes it might be easiest to delete and recreate the fork.  I think this would only be problematic if there are changes in the local clone that are not yet either in the TravelMapping master or in the offending pull request that yarka's working through.
Probably easier, yes. ntallyn would lost the existing pull request and issue history for his fork. And it looks like there are none (https://github.com/ntallyn/HighwayData/pulls).
Yes, delete and recreate looks simpler here.

https://xkcd.com/1597/
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: dave1693 on December 20, 2019, 01:41:21 pm
Yes, delete and recreate looks simpler here.

https://xkcd.com/1597/

 ;D  ::)  X-D
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on December 21, 2019, 10:59:41 pm
Pull request submitted:
https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3367

But there are conflicts (in the usausb.csv files). So obviously I'm doing something wrong. I figured when the system fetched the origin branch, it would update my master branch, as it does when I do it at work (though that is git, not github), and notify me of the conflict at that time. But that certainly isn't the case, as every file that I haven't changed has the time stamp of when I created the branch in the first place.

Fixed the above and resubmitted a pull request: https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3446

Comments after the above-quoted post have not yet been implemented, as well as my local to-do list (see earlier post) from GA37 up.

Nick
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on December 22, 2019, 12:25:59 am
I've made the changes from #208 and #209 locally, too. Only 2 of the OldUS441's remained (that's how it's signed on the blades).

Still to come:
Gray Bypass(all routes): update
GA37Trk (Camilla): add
GA45Trk (Colquitt): add
GA62Trk (Arlington): add
GA73: update routing
GA73Byp (Statesboro): add
GA75Con (Cleveland/White Co.): add
GA86 (Oak Park): update
GA91Trk (Colquitt): add
GA92: end location at Griffin?
GA154ConAtl: add?
GA158Trk (Douglas): add
GA166: update
GA216Trk (Arlington): add
GA246: split
GA540: add
US1 (Oak Park): update

GA route concurrency checks
US route updates to reflect GA route updates


Nick
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on December 22, 2019, 12:52:25 am

GA 45TrkCol and GA91TrkCol There are fully signed truck routes for GA 45 and GA 91 in Colquitt that follow US 27 and GA 91spr, with GA 45 truck then using GA 91 back into downtown Colquitt


I don't know if I'd call them fully-signed. I could find no signage for GA91 Trk on GMSV (all from Dec 2018), and only could find a couple for GA45 Trk on westbound Main St. There was also a sign "All Trucks" heading south on First St at Main St (indicating to head east on Main). Nothing on or at US27. Staying out for now.
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: Jim on December 22, 2019, 09:43:33 am
Pull request submitted:
https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3367

But there are conflicts (in the usausb.csv files). So obviously I'm doing something wrong. I figured when the system fetched the origin branch, it would update my master branch, as it does when I do it at work (though that is git, not github), and notify me of the conflict at that time. But that certainly isn't the case, as every file that I haven't changed has the time stamp of when I created the branch in the first place.

See the comments in the pull request.  It looks to include changes that undo lots of recent activity in the usausb.csv and usausb_con.csv files.

Fixed the above and resubmitted a pull request: https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3446

Comments after the above-quoted post have not yet been implemented, as well as my local to-do list (see earlier post) from GA37 up.

Nick
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: ntallyn on December 22, 2019, 12:07:09 pm
See the comments in the pull request.  It looks to include changes that undo lots of recent activity in the usausb.csv and usausb_con.csv files.

Should be fixed now. Pull request resubmitted, along with all of the GA changes mentioned below:

Gray Bypass(GA11/18/22/44, US129): updated
GA11Byp (Cleveland): added
GA12Trk (Madison): added
GA29Bus (Milledgeville): added
GA35Con (Thomasville): added
GA35Lp (Tifton): added
GA37Trk (Camilla): added
GA45Trk (Arlington): added
GA62Trk (Arlington): added
GA75Con (Cleveland/White Co.): added
GA92: modified end location
GA154ConAtl: added
GA158Trk (Douglas): added
GA166: updated
GA246: split
GA540: added
US129Byp (Cleveland): added
US278Trk (Madison): added

The following changes mentioned in previous comments were NOT made:
GA32Trk (Douglas): add - only signed while approaching town. Not signed along the route itself.
GA45Trk (Colquitt): add - found minimal signage on GMSV (December 2018). See previous post regarding this one.
GA73: update routing - appears to have been previously completed
GA73Byp (Statesboro): add - appears to have been previously completed
GA86 (Oak Park): update - appears to have been previously completed
GA91Trk (Colquitt): add - found no signage on GMSV (December 2018)
GA216Trk (Arlington): add - only signed from GA45/62 (probably to avoid the turn downtown). It is NOT signed from GA216 itself.
US1 (Oak Park): update - appears to have been previously completed

The following items remain:
GA route concurrency checks
US route updates to reflect GA route updates
Title: Re: usaga (Georgia State Highways) - Preview
Post by: mapmikey on December 22, 2019, 02:30:30 pm

GA 45TrkCol and GA91TrkCol There are fully signed truck routes for GA 45 and GA 91 in Colquitt that follow US 27 and GA 91spr, with GA 45 truck then using GA 91 back into downtown Colquitt


I don't know if I'd call them fully-signed. I could find no signage for GA91 Trk on GMSV (all from Dec 2018), and only could find a couple for GA45 Trk on westbound Main St. There was also a sign "All Trucks" heading south on First St at Main St (indicating to head east on Main). Nothing on or at US27. Staying out for now.

Looks like they removed postings between the 2013 GMSV I had available in 2017 and the updated shots...
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on December 22, 2019, 08:55:19 pm
GA 45 Truck and GA 91 Truck travel concurrently with US 27/GA 1 from College Street to 4th Street. Then, they use 4th Street to GA 91 (Main Street).  Here, GA 91 Truck ends, and GA 45 Truck follows GA 91 to GA 45.

GA 91 Spur is the aforementioned portion of 4th Street, from US 27/GA 1 to GA 91.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on December 25, 2019, 01:51:40 am
GA 73 Byp (Statesboro) and GA 135 Truck (Hazlehurst) are both missing from the Highway Browser.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: michih on December 25, 2019, 02:32:12 am
GA 73 Byp (Statesboro) and GA 135 Truck (Hazlehurst) are both missing from the Highway Browser.

The following changes mentioned in previous comments were NOT made:

[...]

GA73Byp (Statesboro): add - appears to have been previously completed

[...]

The following items remain:
GA route concurrency checks
US route updates to reflect GA route updates
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on December 25, 2019, 01:13:40 pm
GA 73 Byp (Statesboro) and GA 135 Truck (Hazlehurst) are both missing from the Highway Browser.

Not sure where GA73 Bypass went off to. I saw that it was done, but now it is missing. I'll take a look at both of these over the holidays (with the concurrency checks and data errors).
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on December 25, 2019, 07:50:00 pm
Thanks.  I know you said that GA 73 Byp (Statesboro) was previously completed.  After I refreshed the Highway Browser, I didn't see it.  That's why I mentioned it.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: kjslaughter on December 25, 2019, 09:48:33 pm
Thanks for the work on Georgia over the holidays!  I'm checking the updates and updating my route log.  Everything looks correct to me.  I can help double check the concurrency end points after they are updated.  I know in Georgia keeping all that straight with all the US highways is a bitch.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on December 26, 2019, 08:55:45 am
GA 73 Byp (Statesboro) and GA 135 Truck (Hazlehurst) are both missing from the Highway Browser.

Not sure where GA73 Bypass went off to. I saw that it was done, but now it is missing. I'll take a look at both of these over the holidays (with the concurrency checks and data errors).

Turns out I messed up on my notes on this one. I could find no posted signage for GA73 Bypass. Approaching the 301/301Byp split, I found no signs on GMSV (mostly from summer 2019) from the north or the south. Nor did I see any on the bypass itself, or approaching it from US80.

I'm leaving this one out for now.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on December 26, 2019, 09:12:10 am
...GA 135 Truck (Hazlehurst) are both missing from the Highway Browser.

Fix made locally. Will be pushed later this week.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on December 26, 2019, 09:19:15 am
Thanks for the work on Georgia over the holidays!  I'm checking the updates and updating my route log.  Everything looks correct to me.  I can help double check the concurrency end points after they are updated.  I know in Georgia keeping all that straight with all the US highways is a bitch.

It's an easy time to work on the routes. I'm off all week from the regular job (holidays, not vacation), and the wife (nurse) works 4 out of the next 5. Any assistance/comments are appreciated.

Apart from the GA135Trk route mentioned below and a datacheck error on GA7, everything in the HB is updated with my most recent. After I go through the remaining datacheck errors, I'll start working on the concurrencies. First batch will be state routes only, I'll update the US routes on the second pass.

Nick
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: kjslaughter on December 26, 2019, 10:47:14 am
GA 73 Byp (Statesboro) and GA 135 Truck (Hazlehurst) are both missing from the Highway Browser.

Not sure where GA73 Bypass went off to. I saw that it was done, but now it is missing. I'll take a look at both of these over the holidays (with the concurrency checks and data errors).

Turns out I messed up on my notes on this one. I could find no posted signage for GA73 Bypass. Approaching the 301/301Byp split, I found no signs on GMSV (mostly from summer 2019) from the north or the south. Nor did I see any on the bypass itself, or approaching it from US80.

I'm leaving this one out for now.

GA 73 Byp must exist as long as US 301 Byp exists as every US highway has a state overlay. :-)  Did some research and GA 73 Byp is on the current GA DOT map of Bulloch County, so I think it should be added.

http://www.dot.ga.gov/DriveSmart/MapsData/Documents/CountyMaps/Bulloch.pdf
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on December 26, 2019, 11:15:43 am
TM has a policy of not including unsigned routes, unless the system is maintained by certain people. In this specific case, I think that's silly because anyone clinching Georgia will drive it anyway as part of usaush.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on December 26, 2019, 11:59:36 am
Also, the Statesboro city map (http://www.dot.ga.gov/DriveSmart/MapsData/Documents/CityMaps/Statesboro_BullochCounty.pdf (http://www.dot.ga.gov/DriveSmart/MapsData/Documents/CityMaps/Statesboro_BullochCounty.pdf)) shows GA 73 Byp on US 301 Byp.

On a side note, I had no idea that GA 73 Byp was no longer signed in the city.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on December 26, 2019, 06:33:15 pm
...GA 135 Truck (Hazlehurst) are both missing from the Highway Browser.

Fix made locally. Will be pushed later this week.

Pull request submitted. Also cleared datacheck errors on GA routes.

Still need to work on concurrency checks. Any suggestions on an easy way to do those? Or just go through them one at a time?
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on December 27, 2019, 12:30:12 am
The above has been merged and a couple more datacheck errors were fixed locally (including the newly introduced DUPLICATE LABEL on US221).
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: michih on December 27, 2019, 03:08:47 am
Still need to work on concurrency checks. Any suggestions on an easy way to do those? Or just go through them one at a time?

We have some tools and logs for it: http://travelmapping.net/devel/tools.php

You might open http://courses.teresco.org/metal/hdx/
Go to option 1 on the left and enter Geo, select the US state, not the Asian country.
Press enter.
Wait, the graph is automatically loaded after about 15s (the usaga graph, it's faster with smaller graphs but takes longer with larger graphs, sometimes minutes).
Press "Done" on the left to close the AV table.
Deselect "Show Data Tables" to close the table to the right.
You see a map of Georgia with yellow dots all over Georgia now.
Deselect "Show Markers".
You see a map of Georgia with funny colors now
Select "Show Markers" again, it was just to show you what happened

Zoom in where you wanna check concurrencies. Top left or directly to US routes or whatever.
I recommend GA1 / US27 south of Chattanooga because concurrency is actually broken here (and many times more to the south)
The funny colors are created by lines. blue line = one route, green = two concurrent routes, magenta = 3 etc.
When there is a green line (2 routes concurrent) but interrupted by a dark blue line at visible or hidden wps, it's a sign that concurrencies are broken (dark blue because two standard blue lines are overlapping).
All "non-standard-colors" like the dark blue are possible broken concurrencies.
Check GA1/GA100/US27 south of Cedartown. It should be magenta but it is a mix of green and blue due to the broken concurrency
Just east of Cedartown is a mix of magenta and blue, just 3 routes are concurrent but it should be 4

Click on the lines or markers to get info about the route name and wp labels. It's sometimes difficult to click all routes when they are mostly overlapped.

Extended expert mode (for a second run or regions with less broken concurrencies):

Load HDX as described before.
Open http://travelmapping.net/devel/tools.php in another browser TAB or window.
Select NMP files filtered by region (individual files) (http://travelmapping.net/logs/nmpbyregion/)
Select the ga.nmp file and download it - not esp-ga.nmp ;)
Open a 2nd instance of HDX
Go to option 3 on the left and select the downloaded ga.nmp file
You can see about 30...40 colored dots on the map now. These are near-miss-points (NMPs). Points very close together.
The points are intentionally off to brake concurrencies (yellow) which are usually marked FP (they will apear green later).
The red points must be checked. These are most likely broken concurrencies or intersecting routes where the wps do not match.
Not matching wps means, that when you are in HB, the other route does not appear as "intersecting route", you cannot directly jump to the other route in HB. This should be fixed to, if the wp is really off by accident. It's possible that the wps are apart by intent though.

Since you only see the points but not the whole network graph, you might need to go to the other HDX instance to get the whole picture. To figure out which routes should intersect, what's going on there etc. For instance, it's possible that the routes are only broken on a very short segment you don't see (or missed) with the "option 1 view style".

Graphs and NMP files are updated with every site update (twice per year the graph generation is suspended when Jim needs it for his students. He notifies the suspension on the forum).

Just ask if you are not sure about details :)
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on December 27, 2019, 07:54:03 am
Still need to work on concurrency checks. Any You might open http://courses.teresco.org/metal/hdx/
Go to option 1 on the left and enter Geo, select the US state, not the Asian country.
Press enter.
Wait, the graph is automatically loaded after about 15s (the usaga graph, it's faster with smaller graphs but takes longer with larger graphs, sometimes minutes).
Press "Done" on the left to close the AV table.
Deselect "Show Data Tables" to close the table to the right.
You see a map of Georgia with yellow dots all over Georgia now.
Deselect "Show Markers".
You see a map of Georgia with funny colors now
Select "Show Markers" again, it was just to show you what happened

Zoom in where you wanna check concurrencies. Top left or directly to US routes or whatever.
I recommend GA1 / US27 south of Chattanooga because concurrency is actually broken here (and many times more to the south)
The funny colors are created by lines. blue line = one route, green = two concurrent routes, magenta = 3 etc.
When there is a green line (2 routes concurrent) but interrupted by a dark blue line at visible or hidden wps, it's a sign that concurrencies are broken (dark blue because two standard blue lines are overlapping).
All "non-standard-colors" like the dark blue are possible broken concurrencies.
Check GA1/GA100/US27 south of Cedartown. It should be magenta but it is a mix of green and blue due to the broken concurrency
Just east of Cedartown is a mix of magenta and blue, just 3 routes are concurrent but it should be 4

Click on the lines or markers to get info about the route name and wp labels. It's sometimes difficult to click all routes when they are mostly overlapped.

Excellent overview. I was going to start investigating the HDX today, but this will probably shorten the learning curve quite a bit.

Thanks, Michael!
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: Jim on December 27, 2019, 09:38:46 am
Wow, that overview of how to use HDX should get its own page in the manual.  Thanks for posting.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: michih on December 27, 2019, 10:42:56 am
Wow, that overview of how to use HDX should get its own page in the manual.  Thanks for posting.

yes, I thought the same. Maybe more kind of "best practise" than manual (first). I have it on my list..... After roudj and gbnb.....

Manual: step-by-step to introduce a new highway system (https://github.com/TravelMapping/Web/issues/343)
Manual: Peer review procedures (https://github.com/TravelMapping/Web/issues/342)

Can you assign the issues to me?
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on December 27, 2019, 04:33:41 pm
Wow, that overview of how to use HDX should get its own page in the manual.  Thanks for posting.

I was thinking the same thing. Just got a chance to check it out, and the instructions make it so easy.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: yakra on December 28, 2019, 02:52:20 pm
Wait, the graph is automatically loaded after about 15s (the usaga graph, it's faster with smaller graphs but takes longer with larger graphs, sometimes minutes).
My aging computer takes a bit longer to render the graphs, and then pan/zoom around, primarily due to the number of point markers that need to be drawn.
One thing that I find helps:
I first open up the District of Columbia graph, then deselect "Show Markers".
Then I open up whatever graph I'm actually interested in. It renders a lot faster without the markers being drawn at first.
I pan/zoom to the location I want to examine (which goes faster with just the polylines onscreen), and then reselect "Show Markers".

The points are intentionally off to brake concurrencies (yellow)
These look intentional, and often are, but sometimes are not. Best to still look these over too of course, and fix or mark FP as appropriate.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: michih on December 28, 2019, 03:03:23 pm
My aging computer takes a bit longer to render the graphs, and then pan/zoom around, primarily due to the number of point markers that need to be drawn.

Thanks, but I think that this should be fixed in HDX...
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: Jim on December 28, 2019, 04:59:34 pm
My aging computer takes a bit longer to render the graphs, and then pan/zoom around, primarily due to the number of point markers that need to be drawn.

Thanks, but I think that this should be fixed in HDX...

What needs to be fixed?
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: michih on December 28, 2019, 05:05:43 pm
What needs to be fixed?

The loading performance. I think it was (much) better last spring and that it got very slow due to the summer work. Sure, there are a lot of improvements but the performance suffered. I don't know, maybe it's just my feeling or just an issue on my end caused by a firefox update or whatever. Loading the GA graph takes about 15s here.

I think that yakra's desciption helps to find the slow element. It seems to be markers (and/or data for their info window)?
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: Jim on December 28, 2019, 05:17:40 pm
What needs to be fixed?

The loading performance. I think it was (much) better last spring and that it got very slow due to the summer work. Sure, there are a lot of improvements but the performance suffered. I don't know, maybe it's just my feeling or just an issue on my end caused by a firefox update or whatever. Loading the GA graph takes about 15s here.

I think that yakra's desciption helps to find the slow element. It seems to be markers (and/or data for their info window)?

Certainly agree: https://github.com/TravelMapping/EduTools/issues/301
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on December 29, 2019, 10:27:53 am
I think that yakra's desciption helps to find the slow element. It seems to be markers (and/or data for their info window)?

My computer can handle all of the markers, but after reading these, it's SO much faster to do the HDX review without them. Of course, I have to turn them on occasionally, but only when I'm zoomed in fairly close anyway.

Incidentally, I just created a pull request for my HDX fixes for non-bannered GA routes through GA20. https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3466

To clarify, this doesn't mean I'm only changing GA routes 1-20. I'm tracing the entire routes one at a time and making changes in all affected files when issues are found. So there will be changes in higher route numbers as well as some US routes. I've been a bit more careful this time in trying to avoid breaking .list files (alt labels, updating the updates.csv, etc.)
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: yakra on December 29, 2019, 11:15:10 am
I think it was (much) better last spring and that it got very slow due to the summer work. Sure, there are a lot of improvements but the performance suffered. I don't know, maybe it's just my feeling or just an issue on my end caused by a firefox update or whatever. Loading the GA graph takes about 15s here.
That was my experience as well. Seems I noticed things really slowing down at the time traveled graphs were implemented.

I think that yakra's desciption helps to find the slow element. It seems to be markers (and/or data for their info window)?
It's not just the markers, though; the slowdown was all-around. Loading NY-regions-collapsed.tmg just now, without markers, took ~90s on BiggaTomato.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: michih on December 29, 2019, 11:21:47 am
It's not just the markers, though; the slowdown was all-around. Loading NY-regions-collapsed.tmg just now, without markers, took ~90s on BiggaTomato.

I know. GA is pretty small. Try ENG.

Wait, the graph is automatically loaded after about 15s (the usaga graph, it's faster with smaller graphs but takes longer with larger graphs, sometimes minutes).
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: yakra on December 29, 2019, 11:28:36 am
I just tried GA. Twice. 1st time took 2.5 minutes (unless I DERP DERP DERP read my stopwatch wrong); 2nd time took 3.5 mins.
Seems a bit odd, compared to NY, as there are fewer vertices & fewer edges. Maybe it's because there are many more concurrencies in GA, which have to be parsed from longer edge name strings, containing more commas. But anyway...
So nah, I don't feel like trying ENG right now. :)
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on January 16, 2020, 09:34:43 pm
I decided to go through the U.S. Routes to find disagreements with the underlying state route files.

US 1/US 221: LFBriAPRd -> CamRd
US 1/540: SteMatRd -> WooAcaRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.2647778,-82.3064693,3a,15y,3.47h,88.4t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s54UrGfawSYUuyhgIdCzxvw!2e0!7i16384!8i8192)
US 17: GA25SprDar -> FortGeoDr
US 17: GA57/99 -> GA99 (or GA99_Eul?)
US 19: move GA208 to match point on 3 and 208
US 19/3: GA20Con -> LowWooRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.3702006,-84.2965233,3a,29.6y,298.55h,83.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sRRrRtM3Vkuk4owXI0VV_aw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
US 19/US 29/US 41: starting at CleAveSW and ending at MackDobRdNW, remove directional suffixes; also McDStSW -> McDanSt (or on 3, McDanSt -> McDSt)
US 19: GA141 -> GA141_S
US 19: GleDrNE -> GleDr, and many other suffixes here that are in both the US 19 and 9 files
US 19: add missing points (from 400's file) between GA136 and GA60_S
US 23/US 341: LivRarmRd -> OweRd
US 23: GA13/155 -> GA13_S
US 23: replace +X007(US23) with GA87ConEas to match the EasByp point on 87
US 23/US 129altmac: WillHenRd -> AlbJenRd? neither is posted
US 23/US 129altmac/87: GA87Con -> GA87ConMac
US 23: I-75(167A) -> *I-75(167A), move I-75(167) to match 87
US 23: I-675(2) -> I-675
US 23: EllRd -> ForPkwy
US 23: I-20(60) -> I-20
US 23: I-85(91) -> I-85
US 23: replace +X021(US23) with MudCreRd to match 365
US 23/US 441: LevGroRd -> GA15Con
US 25: move GA121_S to match 67
US 25: move GA88 to match 121
US 27: PhiRd -> CouLineRd
US 27: WestRomeByp -> GA1Lp_S, GA1Lp -> GA1Lp_N
US 27: RivPkwyNE -> RivPkwy
US 27: McFAve -> McFarAve_S, DodAve -> McFarAve_N
US 29/139: NavAve -> HarShePkwy (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.6899755,-84.4368911,3a,15y,360.72h,89.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sAsfKyh5MU17wArDGwyfONA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192)
US 29: starting at RocRdNW and ending at GloRdNW, remove directional suffixes
US 29: GA20/124_N -> GA20/124
US 29: replace +X011(US29) with DroCreRd to match 316
US 29/US 129/US 441: PetSt -> GA10Lp(9)
US 41: MainSt -> MainSt_Lak
US 41: OldUS41 -> FoxAve
US 41: KinBrgRd -> CenAve
US 41: 11thStS -> JoeWriDr
US 41: 6thSt -> 7thSt??
US 41: W11thSt -> 11thSt
US 41: US341 -> US341_Per
US 41: RicPetBlvd -> LowWooRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.3702006,-84.2965233,3a,29.6y,298.55h,83.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sRRrRtM3Vkuk4owXI0VV_aw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
US 41: WWesRdNW -> WesRd
US 41: GA176 -> MarsHillRd
US 41: RedTopMRdSE -> RedTopConn (https://www.google.com/maps/@34.1403154,-84.7458096,3a,24.5y,241.78h,94.72t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sqT8jO1AqHaESHmtRWgq9Kg!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
US 41: RivRd -> OldRivRd
US 41/US 76: HosCon -> ChaRd
US 76: SMainSt -> MainSt_Eli
US 76/515: OrvLaneDr -> OrvLanCon
US 76: US19_N -> US19/129_N, US19_S -> US19/129_S
US 76: GA17/515_N -> GA17/515
US 78: MirBlvd -> GA8Con
US 78/US 278: CopLakeRd  -> CooLakeRd
US 78: GA22_N -> GA22_E
US 78: GA77_W -> GA77_S, GA77_E -> GA77_N
US 78/10: GA22_S -> GA22_W (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.852549,-83.0944735,3a,25y,168.64h,86.01t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s6nThYhD5TKVxKoDL__OIiA!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
US 78: WillWinRd -> WillWynRd
US 80: I-16 -> I-16(2)
US 82: InnSt -> InmSt
US 82: I-95(29) -> I-95
US 129: MackHEnRd -> MackHenRd
US 129: HouRd_N -> HouRd
US 129/11/49: I-16 (1A) -> I-16
US 129: AppPkwy -> US129BypCle_S, HulRd -> US129BypCle_S
US 278: GA260 -> GleRd
US 280: I-185(1) -> I-185
US 280: WallSt -> WallSt_W
US 280: GA215_W -> GA215_N, GA215_E -> GA215_S
US 301: LakRd -> ParSt_W
US 319: US84BusTho_W -> US84Bus
US 319: US441BypDub_S -> US441Byp
US 319: RubyDr -> NewChuRd
US 341: US341Bus_N -> US341BusEas_N
US 341: replace +X013(US341) with MorDr to match 11busper
US 341: US41 -> US41_Bar
US 441/29: FallLineFwy -> GA540

3: RedTopRd -> RedTopConn (https://www.google.com/maps/@34.1403154,-84.7458096,3a,24.5y,241.78h,94.72t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sqT8jO1AqHaESHmtRWgq9Kg!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
4: GA4BusWad_* -> US1BusWad_*
4: WooDr -> WooAcaRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.2647778,-82.3064693,3a,15y,3.47h,88.4t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s54UrGfawSYUuyhgIdCzxvw!2e0!7i16384!8i8192)
5/515: OldUS76 -> BalRd
10: GA44_W -> GA44_S (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.7445309,-82.7463222,3a,38.8y,201.24h,86.83t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sQFfDXIYvZzZ-qpQrsWh0iQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
11: GA11Byp_S -> GA11/135Byp
11: US129BusCle_* -> US129BypCle_*
11: US341/341Byp -> US341_N
12: WireRd_W -> WireRd
14: NabAve -> HarShePkwy (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.6899755,-84.4368911,3a,15y,360.72h,89.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sAsfKyh5MU17wArDGwyfONA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192)
15: OldUS441Cen_N -> OldUS441_Cen
15: OldUS441Com_N -> OldUS441_Com
20: RicPetBlvd -> LowWooRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.3702006,-84.2965233,3a,29.6y,298.55h,83.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sRRrRtM3Vkuk4owXI0VV_aw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
22: move US129_N to match US 129 and 44
23: US301_N -> US1/23_N
25: GA57 -> GA99 (or GA99_Eul?)
27: US129_S -> US129/129Bus
30: US80/280 -> US80_W
35: US84Bus_W -> US84Bus
47: US78/378 -> US78
75altcle: GA75Con -> US129Byp
87: EasByp -> GA87ConEas
87ConEas: create a file and add a point on US 341/27
87: OldGA361 -> BassRd
115: AppPkwy -> US129Byp and move to match
282: OldGA5 -> MainSt
282: GA2 -> GA2_W
520: WallSt_N -> WallSt_W, WallSt_S -> WallSt_E
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: Eth on January 17, 2020, 02:13:28 pm
US 19/3: GA20Con -> LowWooRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.3702006,-84.2965233,3a,29.6y,298.55h,83.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sRRrRtM3Vkuk4owXI0VV_aw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
...
US 41: RicPetBlvd -> LowWooRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.3702006,-84.2965233,3a,29.6y,298.55h,83.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sRRrRtM3Vkuk4owXI0VV_aw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)

Tangentially related: would it make sense to add a point on US19/US41/GA3 at Woolsey Rd/Richard Petty Blvd (the actual one, not the mislabeled one)? Woolsey Rd is the former routing of GA 20, moved in about the mid-2000s.

Also, is AMSpeed (on all three routes) a valid waypoint name?
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on January 17, 2020, 04:23:54 pm
Now the bannered routes:

US 19busalb/US 82busalb: W3rdAve -> 3rdAve
US 19busdah: replace AndDr and +X000(US19B) with CampWahRd to match 60busdah
US 27altnew: I-85(41) -> I-85
US 27busbai: EColSt -> ColSt
US 27busbre: BucStS -> BucSt
US 27busced: replace PieAve with JohnHandRd to match 1busced
US 29buswin: GA11/53_N -> GA11/53
US 41busmac: I-75(164) -> I-75
US 78busath: OldGA8 -> AtlHwy_W, GA422 -> GA10Lp(18)
US 78buswas: replace LinCir with 3rdSt to match 10buswas
US 129busgai: OldUS129_S -> MarKingBlvd, OldUS129_N -> DowBlvd
US 221trkdou: GA158_W -> GA158
US 221trkdou: US441 -> US441_N
US 278busroc: EuhSt -> MLKingSt
US 301bussyl: GA21Bus_W -> GA21Bus_N, GA21Bus_E -> GA21Bus_S
US 341bypper: I-75(138) -> I-75
US 441busmil: AllMemDrSW -> AllMemDr, VinHwySE -> VinHwy, MLKingJrDr -> MarKingDr (?!)
US 441bypdub: replace lines 2-4 with the FirRd and GA257 lines from 117
US 441trkdou: GA158 -> GA158_E
US 441trkdou: fix the coordinates at US441_SE to match US441_SW - but see below!

1busbla: add a shaping point to match +X002(US27B) on US 27busbla
8: US29/29Bus_S -> US29/316?, US29/29Bus_N -> US29/53
11: US129BusGai -> US129/369
14altatl: GA14_S -> GA14_W, GA14_N -> GA14_E
16: US27/27Alt -> US27
19: US41/41Bus -> US41/247
85: US27/27Alt -> US27

Does US 25busaug not have a state route number? Or is it unsigned? Same for the southernmost two blocks of US 341bushaw.

The Douglas truck routes don't make sense. If trucks traveling US 221 are routed along US 221trkdou, why is the entire segment of US 221 that gets bypassed part of US 441trkdou? I looked at GSV on the south approach; the newest images have nothing, but older imagery (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.4871717,-82.8513129,3a,20.7y,63.27h,90.88t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sjHbFkzF4uiyCvgzX3Et_uw!2e0!5s20160101T000000!7i13312!8i6656) has only signs for 32 and 158. Similarly, traffic approaching from the north on US 441 sees only signs for US 221 and 135 (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5397132,-82.8511762,3a,40.5y,191.04h,88.28t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sUSs-P9E4NMWu5N3xsx915g!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) (older signage (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5395068,-82.851019,3a,15y,217.91h,89.55t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sEL6SrR01QudkB7hGHGOpTw!2e0!5s20130301T000000!7i13312!8i6656), which included 32 and 158, even pointed Truck US 441/31 straight through downtown!), and traffic approaching from the northeast on US 221 sees signs for US 441, 31, 32, and 158 (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5395326,-82.8092566,3a,22y,217.83h,89.09t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s6ifzegF_U39uSKJwJXF-NA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192), but not US 221. (Interestingly, the latter would imply trucks on US 221 south, which overlaps US 441 south of town, should turn right and go through downtown on US 441!) This means that these truck routes do not exist as actual routes, but as signs on intersecting routes pointing trucks around 32 and 158 through downtown, which trucks are banned from. On the other hand, 158trkdou does exist and is simple, as does a 32trkdou that goes around the north side westbound (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5090116,-82.8309833,3a,19.1y,317.99h,88.87t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1ssSs1rCrxYpKtMJHXwZhWOg!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) and around the south side eastbound (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5136579,-82.8736383,3a,15y,142.33h,89.3t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sBnFt-QNsBNShVcap2ikzSg!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) (ugh!)
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on January 17, 2020, 08:30:28 pm
All U.S. Highways in Georgia are supposed to have a concurrent state highway. However, there is no signage for any state highway on US 25 Bus (Augusta, Georgia-North Augusta, South Carolina) from the 5th Street intersection to the 13th Street intersection. The southernmost block uses GA 28, and the entire 13th Street portion uses GA 4.

By the way, I live in the Augusta area, so I can verify routes here, if needed.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: mapmikey on January 17, 2020, 10:00:58 pm
All U.S. Highways in Georgia are supposed to have a concurrent state highway. However, there is no signage for any state highway on US 25 Bus (Augusta, Georgia-North Augusta, South Carolina) from the 5th Street intersection to the 13th Street intersection. The southernmost block uses GA 28, and the entire 13th Street portion uses GA 4.

By the way, I live in the Augusta area, so I can verify routes here, if needed.

It appears the US 25 Bus portion between 13th and 5th is not in the primary system.

The traffic count map https://gdottrafficdata.drakewell.com/publicmultinodemap.asp clearly identifies (click on the dot with a traffic count) the 13th St part as GA 4 and there is a point between 5th and US 1-25-78-278 clearly identified as GA 28.  Points on the rest of US 25 bus give a route number consistent with secondary route designations (route 2720).

Still trying to find other resources that might give a different answer.  The 1992 and 1998 Richmond County maps do not show an accompanying state route with US 25 Business either.  The entirety of Washington St was part of GA 28 when US 25 Business was first created.

Just found this interactive State Classification map that also says it is not a state highway but signed US 25 Bus - https://itos.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=962a2591f91a4303aeafe016ba8db96b

For Hawkinsville, Commerce St is GA 26 throughout.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on January 17, 2020, 10:14:59 pm
For Hawkinsville, Commerce St is GA 26 throughout.
Ooh, so the 26 file needs to be fixed.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on January 18, 2020, 08:23:33 am
US 129/247: missing GSJ at SarChuRd north of Warner Robins
US 41/11/49: ditto
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on January 18, 2020, 10:33:11 am
US 129/247: missing GSJ at SarChuRd north of Warner Robins
US 41/11/49: ditto

Not sure what you mean here.

But I've been working through the routes, fixing up a few broken concurrencies (whether different point locations or missing waypoints), and I've just submitted the (non-bannered) GA route fixes through GA100. https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3538

Next steps:
HDX verification of remaining GA mainline routes
HDX verification of all GA bannered routes
(As a side effect, these should clear up any issues on the US and bannered US routes)
Label checks (including the comments from last week, as well as checking out any "OldXXX" labels). I agree that labels should be as consistent between concurrent routes as reasonable (with the specific exceptions noted in the manual, such as end-of-concurrency or using the parent route on bannered routes).
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on January 18, 2020, 11:17:06 am
US 129/247: missing GSJ at SarChuRd north of Warner Robins
US 41/11/49: ditto

Not sure what you mean here.
There are missing grade separated junctions at the new extension of Sardis Church Road.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: Eth on January 18, 2020, 02:34:20 pm
All U.S. Highways in Georgia are supposed to have a concurrent state highway. However, there is no signage for any state highway on US 25 Bus (Augusta, Georgia-North Augusta, South Carolina) from the 5th Street intersection to the 13th Street intersection. The southernmost block uses GA 28, and the entire 13th Street portion uses GA 4.

By the way, I live in the Augusta area, so I can verify routes here, if needed.

It appears the US 25 Bus portion between 13th and 5th is not in the primary system.

The traffic count map https://gdottrafficdata.drakewell.com/publicmultinodemap.asp clearly identifies (click on the dot with a traffic count) the 13th St part as GA 4 and there is a point between 5th and US 1-25-78-278 clearly identified as GA 28.  Points on the rest of US 25 bus give a route number consistent with secondary route designations (route 2720).

Still trying to find other resources that might give a different answer.  The 1992 and 1998 Richmond County maps do not show an accompanying state route with US 25 Business either.  The entirety of Washington St was part of GA 28 when US 25 Business was first created.

Just found this interactive State Classification map that also says it is not a state highway but signed US 25 Bus - https://itos.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=962a2591f91a4303aeafe016ba8db96b

That is...extremely weird, but correct as far as I can tell. That's the only instance of this I'm aware of anywhere in the state. (Google Maps, if you zoom in far enough, shows it as GA 104, but since official sources say otherwise, I'd say that's an error.)
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: bejacob on January 18, 2020, 06:00:56 pm
GA40Spr in St. Mary's is signed. Field checked on 1/18/2020. Heading north I spotted only one sign (https://www.google.com/maps/@30.7647881,-81.5763043,3a,48.9y,8.49h,90.12t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sosSx1hISzSriP9edBwW1ww!2e0!7i16384!8i8192). My photo also attached.

There are at least 2 signs heading south. I did not drive the full length of the route in that direction, so I don't know if there are more. This one (https://www.google.com/maps/@30.7909426,-81.5768966,3a,75y,173.7h,85.34t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1spliWg73JRKIA2R6lVfny2Q!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) is just south of the intersection with Kings Bay Rd.

The other attached photo is at the corner of Mush Bluff Rd, roughly where the route ends at the Crooked River launch. That does not seem to appear in the most recent GMSV capture at that location.

I believe this route had been previously included but was removed after being incorrectly marked as unsigned. Hopefully the draft of the route file is still around and can be put back in to usaga.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: charliezeb on February 03, 2020, 09:30:29 am
Re the Fall Line Fwy (GA 540), I see that waypoint 74, the intersection with the now-former GA 243 (Gordon Hwy) in Wilkinson Co, is actually labeled "FallLineFwy", a vestige of the old GA 243 routing (waypoint 6). That waypoint name would be valid for 243 (if it still exists), but not for 540, where I would suggest GorHwy as that old routing of 243 is no more.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: CharlotteAllisonCDTG on February 04, 2020, 12:36:14 am
According to signage, the former path of GA 243 here is actually Pennington Highway, not Gordon Highway.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: mikeandkristie on February 16, 2020, 06:19:09 am
GA40Spr in St. Mary's is signed. Field checked on 1/18/2020. Heading north I spotted only one sign (https://www.google.com/maps/@30.7647881,-81.5763043,3a,48.9y,8.49h,90.12t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sosSx1hISzSriP9edBwW1ww!2e0!7i16384!8i8192). My photo also attached.

There are at least 2 signs heading south. I did not drive the full length of the route in that direction, so I don't know if there are more. This one (https://www.google.com/maps/@30.7909426,-81.5768966,3a,75y,173.7h,85.34t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1spliWg73JRKIA2R6lVfny2Q!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) is just south of the intersection with Kings Bay Rd.

The other attached photo is at the corner of Mush Bluff Rd, roughly where the route ends at the Crooked River launch. That does not seem to appear in the most recent GMSV capture at that location.

I believe this route had been previously included but was removed after being incorrectly marked as unsigned. Hopefully the draft of the route file is still around and can be put back in to usaga.

We can confim this as well.  We spotted the signs on GA 40 while driving into and out of St. Marys for Cumberland Island NS from I-95.  We will try to either turn on it and drive down this evening on our way back from St. Marys again or tomorrow as we head out to get more details.

Mike
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: bejacob on February 17, 2020, 06:01:10 pm
I still don't understand how GA40Spr got removed in the first place. It seems that during the peer review, no signs were found on GMSV. Knowing that sometimes images there can go years between updates, it might be wise to exercise caution when suggesting a route be removed simply because no signs could be found on GMSV. In this particular case, there WERE in fact signs on GMSV but apparently they were missed by the person reviewing the route.

GMSV might be an okay to confirm the existence of signs on a route, but using it to prove signs don't exist is a bit more difficult (signs are easy to miss when scrolling along a route). Perhaps it would be possible to use GMSV to identify routes that MIGHT need to be removed due to lack of signs and then see if someone is able to do some field research to verify.

Adding routes is one thing. Removing routes because the reviewer didn't find any signs in GMSV is at best troublesome IMHO, as GA40Spr proves. Signs were in place, and they were in GMSV when the review said the route was unsigned. Has this happened with other routes that have been removed for lack of signage?

I've been impressed by the comments in response to requests for changes to the route files. Thanks for making sure that only changes that are necessary actually make it into the HB. I wish the same had been the case for GA40Spr. Oh well. I'm sure it will be added back sooner or later.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on February 17, 2020, 08:31:14 pm
Adding routes is one thing. Removing routes because the reviewer didn't find any signs in GMSV is at best troublesome IMHO, as GA40Spr proves. Signs were in place, and they were in GMSV when the review said the route was unsigned. Has this happened with other routes that have been removed for lack of signage?
http://forum.travelmapping.net/index.php?topic=3387.0
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on February 20, 2020, 06:06:20 pm
So for the next week I'm going to be up in Helen. Is there anything that needs to be checked in the area? I'm already planning on exiting I-75 at Perry to check out whether http://travelmapping.net/hb/?r=ga.ga011busper now has a hanging end.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: mapmikey on February 20, 2020, 08:13:55 pm
I still don't understand how GA40Spr got removed in the first place. It seems that during the peer review, no signs were found on GMSV. Knowing that sometimes images there can go years between updates, it might be wise to exercise caution when suggesting a route be removed simply because no signs could be found on GMSV. In this particular case, there WERE in fact signs on GMSV but apparently they were missed by the person reviewing the route.

GMSV might be an okay to confirm the existence of signs on a route, but using it to prove signs don't exist is a bit more difficult (signs are easy to miss when scrolling along a route). Perhaps it would be possible to use GMSV to identify routes that MIGHT need to be removed due to lack of signs and then see if someone is able to do some field research to verify.

Adding routes is one thing. Removing routes because the reviewer didn't find any signs in GMSV is at best troublesome IMHO, as GA40Spr proves. Signs were in place, and they were in GMSV when the review said the route was unsigned. Has this happened with other routes that have been removed for lack of signage?

I've been impressed by the comments in response to requests for changes to the route files. Thanks for making sure that only changes that are necessary actually make it into the HB. I wish the same had been the case for GA40Spr. Oh well. I'm sure it will be added back sooner or later.

This may have been a misinterpretation of what I wrote in Post #44...I was saying there was no indication of field signage at the north endpoint.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: bejacob on February 21, 2020, 02:16:41 pm
This may have been a misinterpretation of what I wrote in Post #44...I was saying there was no indication of field signage at the north endpoint.

It may have been that. I see the reply on #123 where it was noted the route would be deleted.

Having driven the route end to end, I can attest that there aren't many signs along the. The northernmost one (on the southbound side) appears to be a relatively recent addition, though the others have been in place a while.

I'm suggesting that going forward, GMSV can be a useful tool to confirm the existence of signage, although depending on how recent the images are, even that isn't perfect. Where I think caution is needed is using it to confirm that signage doesn't exist as it can be easy to skip past signs especially on routes that are 'lightly' signed  It's impractical to field check every route, but I feel additional care should exercised when relying solely on GMSV when considering deleting a route due to lack of signs. It's easier to prove a positive (signs exist) than to disprove a negative (no signs anywhere along a route). Mistakenly deleting signed routes does not seem to happen often, but GA40SprStM is not the only time.

I suppose this is just part of the process of getting a state like GA activated. It looks close, and I'll be eager to see it move beyond the preview state. Thanks to all who have worked to get it this far.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: mikeandkristie on February 21, 2020, 07:19:17 pm
We almost forgot about doing GA 40 Spur as we were staying by I-95 at Exit 3 and got on it, so we got off at Exit 5 and made our way over to it at the main entrance to the navy base.  Went northbound to the boat ramp and turned around.  Saw the initial southbound sign that folks are saying is fairly new.  Then drove the full length southbound.  Saw three southbound signs and one northbound one in my sideview mirror.  Sounds like this is going to get reinstated at some point, so I'll keep my eye out for it.

Mike
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: Eth on February 21, 2020, 10:29:14 pm
So for the next week I'm going to be up in Helen. Is there anything that needs to be checked in the area? I'm already planning on exiting I-75 at Perry to check out whether http://travelmapping.net/hb/?r=ga.ga011busper now has a hanging end.

I just checked Street View to see if it was updated recently enough, and it seems that it is. Looks like there is now an END assembly (https://www.google.com/maps/@32.459041,-83.7336168,3a,39.5y,271.79h,84.83t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s4D9WXVHl6zKHT2nZPk9NLQ!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) on GA11BusPer at the intersection with GA7 (old US341) downtown. The route previously turned left here.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on February 22, 2020, 10:51:18 pm
I also confirmed that it's not signed south of there, and mileposts 1 and 2 have been moved to reflect the truncation.

Also, the US 129/11/22 junction at Gray needs to be moved west.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on February 24, 2020, 08:06:49 pm
On 11, US129BusCle_* -> US129BypCle_*
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on February 26, 2020, 06:06:49 pm
Can I get a point on 60 at Cooper Gap Road (south of GA180) please? That's where I turned off for a nice forest drive.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on February 27, 2020, 07:56:08 am
10 (and US 78) has two waypoints in a row named ParkPlaBlvd and ParkPlBlvd.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: Eth on March 03, 2020, 08:42:22 am
I noticed this morning that the east terminus of GA120 was recently renamed from ClaSt back to GA20. Did GDOT reverse its changes to the routing of GA20 from a few years back? (Note that the GA20 .wpt file wasn't changed, so this point isn't even at GA20 in the HB.)
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on March 03, 2020, 01:20:17 pm
I noticed this morning that the east terminus of GA120 was recently renamed from ClaSt back to GA20. Did GDOT reverse its changes to the routing of GA20 from a few years back? (Note that the GA20 .wpt file wasn't changed, so this point isn't even at GA20 in the HB.)
Assuming no reversal, it looks like 120 should be extended east to new 20 (Buford Drive) per signage on old 20 westbound (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.9559376,-83.9883099,3a,75y,357.95h,119.8t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sBvpyOHzi9eu7CnXifd8mCQ!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) and eastbound (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.9568816,-83.9896441,3a,75y,176.12h,87.04t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sZuzWeoSu-WP5xczLjKqZSA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192).
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: Eth on March 08, 2020, 04:10:06 pm
I noticed this morning that the east terminus of GA120 was recently renamed from ClaSt back to GA20. Did GDOT reverse its changes to the routing of GA20 from a few years back? (Note that the GA20 .wpt file wasn't changed, so this point isn't even at GA20 in the HB.)
Assuming no reversal, it looks like 120 should be extended east to new 20 (Buford Drive) per signage on old 20 westbound (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.9559376,-83.9883099,3a,75y,357.95h,119.8t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sBvpyOHzi9eu7CnXifd8mCQ!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) and eastbound (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.9568816,-83.9896441,3a,75y,176.12h,87.04t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sZuzWeoSu-WP5xczLjKqZSA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192).

I decided to do a field check this afternoon, since I needed to reclinch the new US 29 alignment anyway. It turns out the point is moot, because GA 120 has actually been truncated all the way back to 316, as I suspected it might be. All the 120 shields east of 316 are gone, and this also jives with GDOT's official state map.

EDIT: Also, GA120 will need a new point where US29/GA8 join it (Lawrenceville-Suwanee Rd).
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: oscar on March 14, 2020, 07:27:20 am
Look for changes in the Perry area, associated with the relocation of US 341 to a bypass north of downtown (http://forum.travelmapping.net/index.php?topic=2455.msg18001#msg18001). This will affect that route, US 41 (at least point relabels), and also at least one state route (ditto).
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 14, 2020, 01:21:23 pm
Just finished the point adjustments for all the non-bannered GA routes. Also re-added GA40SprStM.
https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3661

Still to do:
Check bannered GA routes
Remove "Old*" names where possible
Common point names for common points (where possible/sensible)
Various route updates mentioned in the last 30 or so comments on this thread.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 14, 2020, 07:07:00 pm
RE: GA19Con Hazlehurst

Any thoughts on this one? It "should" connect at its southern end to US221. However, the current routing of US221 ignores that point, as it is in the middle of a one-way split. I feel like I should add that point to US221 (as it's an intersection with another route in the HB), but then the southbound routing of US221 is incorrect (as it follows Tallahassee St, rather than Coffee St). I suppose I could then move the current point (on US221) to Tallahassee St and ignore the northbound one-way portion. I'd keep the Coffee St point for US23 &341. Other thoughts?
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: yakra on March 14, 2020, 08:13:01 pm
ga.ga040.wpt: ChaSmiHwy -> GA40Spr
ga.ga247.wpt: I-75 should not be relabeled I-75(160), as no other point has an I-75 label.
The rest looks good.

As far as this forum thread goes, there's a backlog of stuff for me to look at.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: mikeandkristie on March 15, 2020, 02:40:21 pm
Just finished the point adjustments for all the non-bannered GA routes. Also re-added GA40SprStM.
https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3661

Still to do:
Check bannered GA routes
Remove "Old*" names where possible
Common point names for common points (where possible/sensible)
Various route updates mentioned in the last 30 or so comments on this thread.

Thank you for GA40SprStM.

Mike
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 15, 2020, 06:03:09 pm
ga.ga040.wpt: ChaSmiHwy -> GA40Spr
ga.ga247.wpt: I-75 should not be relabeled I-75(160), as no other point has an I-75 label.
The rest looks good.

As far as this forum thread goes, there's a backlog of stuff for me to look at.

GA40: fixed.
GA247: fixed. I originally changed this one when I thought I had evidence that GA247 reached I-75 at exit 167 also. At this point, I'm still not 100% convinced that it doesn't, but that (very) short piece between I-75 and US23 doesn't appear to be signed.

Pull request submitted for these two and adjusting points for all of the bannered GA routes.
https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3669
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: Eth on March 16, 2020, 09:54:08 pm
GA247: fixed. I originally changed this one when I thought I had evidence that GA247 reached I-75 at exit 167 also. At this point, I'm still not 100% convinced that it doesn't, but that (very) short piece between I-75 and US23 doesn't appear to be signed.

On one hand, GIS data (from 2017) identifies Pierce Avenue north of US23 as having Route_ID 1000100024700 (i.e. SR 247) with mileposts continuing GA247's sequence. On the other hand, well, there's an END sign clearly posted at the intersection with US23. When in doubt, stick with the signage.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 16, 2020, 10:43:10 pm
GA247: fixed. I originally changed this one when I thought I had evidence that GA247 reached I-75 at exit 167 also. At this point, I'm still not 100% convinced that it doesn't, but that (very) short piece between I-75 and US23 doesn't appear to be signed.

On one hand, GIS data (from 2017) identifies Pierce Avenue north of US23 as having Route_ID 1000100024700 (i.e. SR 247) with mileposts continuing GA247's sequence. On the other hand, well, there's an END sign clearly posted at the intersection with US23. When in doubt, stick with the signage.

Of course, the end sign is there because north of US23 is essentially just ramps (yes, there is one minor road connection to one of the ramps). Not that I'm arguing, just presenting all the possibilities.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 19, 2020, 08:37:43 pm
I decided to go through the U.S. Routes to find disagreements with the underlying state route files.

US 1/US 221: LFBriAPRd -> CamRd
US 1/540: SteMatRd -> WooAcaRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.2647778,-82.3064693,3a,15y,3.47h,88.4t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s54UrGfawSYUuyhgIdCzxvw!2e0!7i16384!8i8192)
US 17: GA25SprDar -> FortGeoDr
US 17: GA57/99 -> GA99 (or GA99_Eul?)
US 19: move GA208 to match point on 3 and 208
US 19/3: GA20Con -> LowWooRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.3702006,-84.2965233,3a,29.6y,298.55h,83.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sRRrRtM3Vkuk4owXI0VV_aw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
US 19/US 29/US 41: starting at CleAveSW and ending at MackDobRdNW, remove directional suffixes; also McDStSW -> McDanSt (or on 3, McDanSt -> McDSt)
US 19: GA141 -> GA141_S
US 19: GleDrNE -> GleDr, and many other suffixes here that are in both the US 19 and 9 files
US 19: add missing points (from 400's file) between GA136 and GA60_S
US 23/US 341: LivRarmRd -> OweRd
US 23: GA13/155 -> GA13_S
US 23: replace +X007(US23) with GA87ConEas to match the EasByp point on 87
US 23/US 129altmac: WillHenRd -> AlbJenRd? neither is posted
US 23/US 129altmac/87: GA87Con -> GA87ConMac
US 23: I-75(167A) -> *I-75(167A), move I-75(167) to match 87
US 23: I-675(2) -> I-675
US 23: EllRd -> ForPkwy
US 23: I-20(60) -> I-20
US 23: I-85(91) -> I-85
US 23: replace +X021(US23) with MudCreRd to match 365
US 23/US 441: LevGroRd -> GA15Con
US 25: move GA121_S to match 67
US 25: move GA88 to match 121
US 27: PhiRd -> CouLineRd
US 27: WestRomeByp -> GA1Lp_S, GA1Lp -> GA1Lp_N
US 27: RivPkwyNE -> RivPkwy
US 27: McFAve -> McFarAve_S, DodAve -> McFarAve_N
US 29/139: NavAve -> HarShePkwy (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.6899755,-84.4368911,3a,15y,360.72h,89.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sAsfKyh5MU17wArDGwyfONA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192)
US 29: starting at RocRdNW and ending at GloRdNW, remove directional suffixes
US 29: GA20/124_N -> GA20/124
US 29: replace +X011(US29) with DroCreRd to match 316
US 29/US 129/US 441: PetSt -> GA10Lp(9)
US 41: MainSt -> MainSt_Lak
US 41: OldUS41 -> FoxAve
US 41: KinBrgRd -> CenAve
US 41: 11thStS -> JoeWriDr
US 41: 6thSt -> 7thSt??
US 41: W11thSt -> 11thSt
US 41: US341 -> US341_Per
US 41: RicPetBlvd -> LowWooRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.3702006,-84.2965233,3a,29.6y,298.55h,83.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sRRrRtM3Vkuk4owXI0VV_aw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
US 41: WWesRdNW -> WesRd
US 41: GA176 -> MarsHillRd
US 41: RedTopMRdSE -> RedTopConn (https://www.google.com/maps/@34.1403154,-84.7458096,3a,24.5y,241.78h,94.72t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sqT8jO1AqHaESHmtRWgq9Kg!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
US 41: RivRd -> OldRivRd
US 41/US 76: HosCon -> ChaRd
US 76: SMainSt -> MainSt_Eli
US 76/515: OrvLaneDr -> OrvLanCon
US 76: US19_N -> US19/129_N, US19_S -> US19/129_S
US 76: GA17/515_N -> GA17/515
US 78: MirBlvd -> GA8Con
US 78/US 278: CopLakeRd  -> CooLakeRd
US 78: GA22_N -> GA22_E
US 78: GA77_W -> GA77_S, GA77_E -> GA77_N
US 78/10: GA22_S -> GA22_W (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.852549,-83.0944735,3a,25y,168.64h,86.01t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s6nThYhD5TKVxKoDL__OIiA!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
US 78: WillWinRd -> WillWynRd
US 80: I-16 -> I-16(2)
US 82: InnSt -> InmSt
US 82: I-95(29) -> I-95
US 129: MackHEnRd -> MackHenRd
US 129: HouRd_N -> HouRd
US 129/11/49: I-16 (1A) -> I-16
US 129: AppPkwy -> US129BypCle_S, HulRd -> US129BypCle_S
US 278: GA260 -> GleRd
US 280: I-185(1) -> I-185
US 280: WallSt -> WallSt_W
US 280: GA215_W -> GA215_N, GA215_E -> GA215_S
US 301: LakRd -> ParSt_W
US 319: US84BusTho_W -> US84Bus
US 319: US441BypDub_S -> US441Byp
US 319: RubyDr -> NewChuRd
US 341: US341Bus_N -> US341BusEas_N
US 341: replace +X013(US341) with MorDr to match 11busper
US 341: US41 -> US41_Bar
US 441/29: FallLineFwy -> GA540

All of these changes made locally unless noted otherwise. Still need to do the state routes.
US17: GA57/99 -> GA99. Selected as it is a crossing with GA99, as opposed to the concurrency in the Darien area (GA99_N and I-95BL_S).
US19/29/41: Directional suffixes removed (kept as alt-labels where necessary) except WinPkwy (would cause duplicate label).
US23/129Alt/GA87: There's only one GA87Con, so I didn't change it.
US76: Did not change US19_S to US19/129_S, as it is a point previously in use before the Blairsville bypass was built. I made the US19_N label primary for consistency. US19/129_N is an alt-label for US19_N.
US80: I-16(2) is already an alt-label for I-16. US80 only crosses I-16 at that one interchange.
US280: There is only 1 WallSt point. I know the route crosses it between the next points, but unless we add that second point, I don't think we need the _W tag.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 20, 2020, 06:11:27 pm
3: RedTopRd -> RedTopConn (https://www.google.com/maps/@34.1403154,-84.7458096,3a,24.5y,241.78h,94.72t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sqT8jO1AqHaESHmtRWgq9Kg!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
4: GA4BusWad_* -> US1BusWad_*
4: WooDr -> WooAcaRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.2647778,-82.3064693,3a,15y,3.47h,88.4t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s54UrGfawSYUuyhgIdCzxvw!2e0!7i16384!8i8192)
5/515: OldUS76 -> BalRd
10: GA44_W -> GA44_S (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.7445309,-82.7463222,3a,38.8y,201.24h,86.83t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sQFfDXIYvZzZ-qpQrsWh0iQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
11: GA11Byp_S -> GA11/135Byp
11: US129BusCle_* -> US129BypCle_*
11: US341/341Byp -> US341_N
12: WireRd_W -> WireRd
14: NabAve -> HarShePkwy (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.6899755,-84.4368911,3a,15y,360.72h,89.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sAsfKyh5MU17wArDGwyfONA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192)
15: OldUS441Cen_N -> OldUS441_Cen
15: OldUS441Com_N -> OldUS441_Com
20: RicPetBlvd -> LowWooRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.3702006,-84.2965233,3a,29.6y,298.55h,83.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sRRrRtM3Vkuk4owXI0VV_aw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
22: move US129_N to match US 129 and 44
23: US301_N -> US1/23_N
25: GA57 -> GA99 (or GA99_Eul?)
27: US129_S -> US129/129Bus
30: US80/280 -> US80_W
35: US84Bus_W -> US84Bus
47: US78/378 -> US78
75altcle: GA75Con -> US129Byp
87: EasByp -> GA87ConEas
87ConEas: create a file and add a point on US 341/27
87: OldGA361 -> BassRd
115: AppPkwy -> US129Byp and move to match
282: OldGA5 -> MainSt
282: GA2 -> GA2_W
520: WallSt_N -> WallSt_W, WallSt_S -> WallSt_E

All changes made locally except
GA27: US129_S. Kept as-is, as it is the end of a concurrency.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 20, 2020, 06:17:14 pm
US 19/3: GA20Con -> LowWooRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.3702006,-84.2965233,3a,29.6y,298.55h,83.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sRRrRtM3Vkuk4owXI0VV_aw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)
...
US 41: RicPetBlvd -> LowWooRd (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.3702006,-84.2965233,3a,29.6y,298.55h,83.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sRRrRtM3Vkuk4owXI0VV_aw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656)

Tangentially related: would it make sense to add a point on US19/US41/GA3 at Woolsey Rd/Richard Petty Blvd (the actual one, not the mislabeled one)? Woolsey Rd is the former routing of GA 20, moved in about the mid-2000s.

Done locally.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 21, 2020, 11:36:19 am
Now the bannered routes:

US 19busalb/US 82busalb: W3rdAve -> 3rdAve
US 19busdah: replace AndDr and +X000(US19B) with CampWahRd to match 60busdah
US 27altnew: I-85(41) -> I-85
US 27busbai: EColSt -> ColSt
US 27busbre: BucStS -> BucSt
US 27busced: replace PieAve with JohnHandRd to match 1busced
US 29buswin: GA11/53_N -> GA11/53
US 41busmac: I-75(164) -> I-75
US 78busath: OldGA8 -> AtlHwy_W, GA422 -> GA10Lp(18)
US 78buswas: replace LinCir with 3rdSt to match 10buswas
US 129busgai: OldUS129_S -> MarKingBlvd, OldUS129_N -> DowBlvd
US 221trkdou: GA158_W -> GA158
US 221trkdou: US441 -> US441_N
US 278busroc: EuhSt -> MLKingSt
US 301bussyl: GA21Bus_W -> GA21Bus_N, GA21Bus_E -> GA21Bus_S
US 341bypper: I-75(138) -> I-75
US 441busmil: AllMemDrSW -> AllMemDr, VinHwySE -> VinHwy, MLKingJrDr -> MarKingDr (?!)
US 441bypdub: replace lines 2-4 with the FirRd and GA257 lines from 117
US 441trkdou: GA158 -> GA158_E
US 441trkdou: fix the coordinates at US441_SE to match US441_SW - but see below!

1busbla: add a shaping point to match +X002(US27B) on US 27busbla
8: US29/29Bus_S -> US29/316?, US29/29Bus_N -> US29/53
11: US129BusGai -> US129/369
14altatl: GA14_S -> GA14_W, GA14_N -> GA14_E
16: US27/27Alt -> US27
19: US41/41Bus -> US41/247
85: US27/27Alt -> US27

All done locally except as noted below.
US221TrkDou: Kept US441 as is. It is not the end of a concurrency. Yes, it is the northern intersection with US441, but the southern intersection is not marked as such, as it is the beginning of the route (so US221_S).
GA8: US29/29Bus_S changed to US29_N.
GA14AltAtl: GA14 is a north-south route, so the _S and _N tags are correct.
GA16: US27/27Alt changed to US27_S.
GA19: US41/41Bus renamed to US41_S.
GA85: Can't do that, as US27 is the label of the southern endpoint. Leaving as-is.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 21, 2020, 11:37:45 am
The Douglas truck routes don't make sense. If trucks traveling US 221 are routed along US 221trkdou, why is the entire segment of US 221 that gets bypassed part of US 441trkdou? I looked at GSV on the south approach; the newest images have nothing, but older imagery (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.4871717,-82.8513129,3a,20.7y,63.27h,90.88t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sjHbFkzF4uiyCvgzX3Et_uw!2e0!5s20160101T000000!7i13312!8i6656) has only signs for 32 and 158. Similarly, traffic approaching from the north on US 441 sees only signs for US 221 and 135 (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5397132,-82.8511762,3a,40.5y,191.04h,88.28t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sUSs-P9E4NMWu5N3xsx915g!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) (older signage (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5395068,-82.851019,3a,15y,217.91h,89.55t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sEL6SrR01QudkB7hGHGOpTw!2e0!5s20130301T000000!7i13312!8i6656), which included 32 and 158, even pointed Truck US 441/31 straight through downtown!), and traffic approaching from the northeast on US 221 sees signs for US 441, 31, 32, and 158 (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5395326,-82.8092566,3a,22y,217.83h,89.09t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s6ifzegF_U39uSKJwJXF-NA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192), but not US 221. (Interestingly, the latter would imply trucks on US 221 south, which overlaps US 441 south of town, should turn right and go through downtown on US 441!) This means that these truck routes do not exist as actual routes, but as signs on intersecting routes pointing trucks around 32 and 158 through downtown, which trucks are banned from. On the other hand, 158trkdou does exist and is simple, as does a 32trkdou that goes around the north side westbound (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5090116,-82.8309833,3a,19.1y,317.99h,88.87t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1ssSs1rCrxYpKtMJHXwZhWOg!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) and around the south side eastbound (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5136579,-82.8736383,3a,15y,142.33h,89.3t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sBnFt-QNsBNShVcap2ikzSg!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) (ugh!)

Yes, this one has always been ugly. As I couldn't figure out what was really going on (even when driving through the area!), I've pretty much left these alone.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 21, 2020, 11:51:41 am
For Hawkinsville, Commerce St is GA 26 throughout.
Ooh, so the 26 file needs to be fixed.

Fixed locally. Added/renamed these points:
US129/341 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=32.285173&lon=-83.480054
{
US129Bus_N http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=32.283930&lon=-83.472650
US129Bus_S http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=32.283500&lon=-83.467016
US341_N http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=32.282950&lon=-83.464300
}
US341_S http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=32.282157&lon=-83.451703
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 21, 2020, 12:08:02 pm
US 129/247: missing GSJ at SarChuRd north of Warner Robins
US 41/11/49: ditto
SarChuRd added to all routes.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 21, 2020, 12:38:45 pm
Re the Fall Line Fwy (GA 540), I see that waypoint 74, the intersection with the now-former GA 243 (Gordon Hwy) in Wilkinson Co, is actually labeled "FallLineFwy", a vestige of the old GA 243 routing (waypoint 6). That waypoint name would be valid for 243 (if it still exists), but not for 540, where I would suggest GorHwy as that old routing of 243 is no more.
FallLineFwy renamed to PenHwy on both GA540 and GA243.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 21, 2020, 12:49:24 pm
I also confirmed that it's not signed south of there, and mileposts 1 and 2 have been moved to reflect the truncation.

Also, the US 129/11/22 junction at Gray needs to be moved west.

GA11BusPer truncated to US341_N (now labeledUS341).

Move the junction west to the access road? Will do, since there's no "through route" on Monticello Highway any more.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 21, 2020, 12:53:44 pm
On 11, US129BusCle_* -> US129BypCle_*
Done
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 21, 2020, 02:03:03 pm
10 (and US 78) has two waypoints in a row named ParkPlaBlvd and ParkPlBlvd.

Kept as alt-labels (in-use). Renamed to WParkPlaBlvd and EParkPlaBlvd (as signed).
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 21, 2020, 02:08:19 pm
Can I get a point on 60 at Cooper Gap Road (south of GA180) please? That's where I turned off for a nice forest drive.

It's less than 1/2 mile to GA180, and the road doesn't appear to be all that useful for regional traffic. Leaving out for now.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 21, 2020, 02:27:16 pm
I noticed this morning that the east terminus of GA120 was recently renamed from ClaSt back to GA20. Did GDOT reverse its changes to the routing of GA20 from a few years back? (Note that the GA20 .wpt file wasn't changed, so this point isn't even at GA20 in the HB.)
Assuming no reversal, it looks like 120 should be extended east to new 20 (Buford Drive) per signage on old 20 westbound (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.9559376,-83.9883099,3a,75y,357.95h,119.8t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sBvpyOHzi9eu7CnXifd8mCQ!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) and eastbound (https://www.google.com/maps/@33.9568816,-83.9896441,3a,75y,176.12h,87.04t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sZuzWeoSu-WP5xczLjKqZSA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192).

I decided to do a field check this afternoon, since I needed to reclinch the new US 29 alignment anyway. It turns out the point is moot, because GA 120 has actually been truncated all the way back to 316, as I suspected it might be. All the 120 shields east of 316 are gone, and this also jives with GDOT's official state map.

EDIT: Also, GA120 will need a new point where US29/GA8 join it (Lawrenceville-Suwanee Rd).

GA120 truncated to GA316. I didn't understand the EDIT until I noticed that US29(GA8) had been rerouted. Fixed those routes, too. Added line to updates.csv as several US29 points are no longer valid.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 21, 2020, 02:31:00 pm
Look for changes in the Perry area, associated with the relocation of US 341 to a bypass north of downtown (http://forum.travelmapping.net/index.php?topic=2455.msg18001#msg18001). This will affect that route, US 41 (at least point relabels), and also at least one state route (ditto).
Appears to be signed as US341 Bypass. That file already exists.

EDIT: I see here http://forum.travelmapping.net/index.php?topic=2455.msg18001#msg18001 that this has changed. Update in process. Will go with my next push.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 21, 2020, 02:42:28 pm
Everything above is pushed (and pull request submitted).

EDIT:
Includes the updates around Perry (including updates.csv). Also removed unused alt-labels on all GA routes.

All that remains is to go through and look for Old* labels that can/should be renamed (both US and GA routes).

https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3683
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on March 21, 2020, 06:12:37 pm
The Douglas truck routes don't make sense. If trucks traveling US 221 are routed along US 221trkdou, why is the entire segment of US 221 that gets bypassed part of US 441trkdou? I looked at GSV on the south approach; the newest images have nothing, but older imagery (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.4871717,-82.8513129,3a,20.7y,63.27h,90.88t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sjHbFkzF4uiyCvgzX3Et_uw!2e0!5s20160101T000000!7i13312!8i6656) has only signs for 32 and 158. Similarly, traffic approaching from the north on US 441 sees only signs for US 221 and 135 (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5397132,-82.8511762,3a,40.5y,191.04h,88.28t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sUSs-P9E4NMWu5N3xsx915g!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) (older signage (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5395068,-82.851019,3a,15y,217.91h,89.55t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sEL6SrR01QudkB7hGHGOpTw!2e0!5s20130301T000000!7i13312!8i6656), which included 32 and 158, even pointed Truck US 441/31 straight through downtown!), and traffic approaching from the northeast on US 221 sees signs for US 441, 31, 32, and 158 (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5395326,-82.8092566,3a,22y,217.83h,89.09t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s6ifzegF_U39uSKJwJXF-NA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192), but not US 221. (Interestingly, the latter would imply trucks on US 221 south, which overlaps US 441 south of town, should turn right and go through downtown on US 441!) This means that these truck routes do not exist as actual routes, but as signs on intersecting routes pointing trucks around 32 and 158 through downtown, which trucks are banned from. On the other hand, 158trkdou does exist and is simple, as does a 32trkdou that goes around the north side westbound (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5090116,-82.8309833,3a,19.1y,317.99h,88.87t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1ssSs1rCrxYpKtMJHXwZhWOg!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) and around the south side eastbound (https://www.google.com/maps/@31.5136579,-82.8736383,3a,15y,142.33h,89.3t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sBnFt-QNsBNShVcap2ikzSg!2e0!7i16384!8i8192) (ugh!)

Yes, this one has always been ugly. As I couldn't figure out what was really going on (even when driving through the area!), I've pretty much left these alone.

I very much disagree with keeping US 221trkdou and US 441trkdou. Neither matches the way things are in the real world.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: oscar on March 22, 2020, 08:50:26 am
GA 115 should get another waypoint in Cleveland, matching the GA115 point on US 129 Bypass.

Thanks for all the Perry area changes, which I've just incorporated in my list file.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: neroute2 on March 22, 2020, 09:52:30 am
GA 115 should get another waypoint in Cleveland, matching the GA115 point on US 129 Bypass.
115 also has waypoints in the wrong order in Cleveland.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 22, 2020, 10:56:36 am
Looks like both of these issues are due to a "Duplicate Coordinate" issue. It appears I put the US129 coordinates in for the US129Byp label as well. Fixed locally.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 28, 2020, 03:50:25 pm
Everything has been pushed. I went through all of the route files and updated/removed all of the Old* labels. The ones that remain in the files fall into one of the following categories:

1. Closed intersections
2. Intersections that are actually signed Old*
3. Intersections that I couldn't find any evidence that the label was incorrect.

https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3705

At this point, I've completed all of the comments and suggestions in this thread, as well as all of the updates mentioned in the GA route update forum. Once this is merged, I believe this system is ready for activation.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: Jim on March 28, 2020, 04:39:14 pm
Assuming usaga is next to activate, it will be the one that puts us over 1,000,000 miles in active systems, and will blow past what we need to get there by quite a bit.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: michih on March 28, 2020, 04:41:38 pm
Once this is merged,

with tonight's update

I believe this system is ready for activation.

You just need to edit systems.csv (https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/blob/master/systems.csv) and systemupdates.csv (https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/blob/master/systemupdates.csv).

Code: [Select]
usaga;USA;Georgia State Highways;brown;4;preview
->
usaga;USA;Georgia State Highways;brown;4;active

Code: [Select]
-->
2020-03-28;(USA) Georgia;usaga;Georgia State Highways;active
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 28, 2020, 06:17:14 pm
I'm also moving the 3 NSF routes into the regular GA state highway folder. Do I need to do anything else with those?

Should I edit my current pull request with these files?
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: si404 on March 28, 2020, 06:47:46 pm
I'm also moving the 3 NSF routes into the regular GA state highway folder. Do I need to do anything else with those?
Remove them from the NSF system .csvs
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: Jim on March 28, 2020, 09:16:09 pm
Are we good to go for tonight?  I can wait for the additions to the pull request or a new pull request that does the activation, or that can just happen tomorrow instead.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 29, 2020, 10:59:01 am
Sorry. Was out of pocket most of the evening. Family time. Pull request submitted for activation.

https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/3708
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: Jim on March 29, 2020, 06:18:05 pm
Not a problem at all.  The million mile mark will be eclipsed tonight.
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: kjslaughter on March 30, 2020, 02:12:14 pm
So excited to see Georgia now in production!!  Thanks so much for all of you're work on this!!!!
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: michih on March 30, 2020, 03:24:50 pm
Yes, thanks for working on this, ntallyn :) There are some data errors to be checked: http://travelmapping.net/devel/datacheck.php?rg=GA
Title: Re: usaga: Georgia State Highways
Post by: ntallyn on March 30, 2020, 05:52:55 pm
All are FPs and are now in the datacheck.csv file.

I also noticed that I missed updating US23 when I added exit 14 on I-985.

Both are fixed locally and will be pushed soon.