Author Topic: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger  (Read 5600 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline si404

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1536
  • Last Login:September 02, 2021, 01:19:56 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #30 on: November 22, 2020, 07:13:10 am »
Fv34 - KjoVeg is off

Fv35
 - GraVei is off
 - Fv34_W -> Fv32_W
 - Fv34_E -> Fv32_E
 - Fv810 -> Fv3218 (or add Fv810)

Fv37
 - Ski -> MosVei?
 - Tin -> TinVeg?

Fv38
 - Fro is slightly off (also -> Mod?)
 - Rv41_S is off

Fv40
 - Fv2804 is off
 - Fv2800 is off
 - FV2792_N is off (also FV -> Fv)
 - Fv2782 is off
 - Fv101 -> Fv2788 (or add Fv101 if it now is)
 - E18 -> Rv400 as that's what the graph connection is (perhaps extend to E18?)

Fv42
 - Fv4188 is off (probably in an old location)
 - Tve -> TveVeg?
 - Fv3772 is off
 - Hel -> AskVei?

Fv42Kje - Rv9 is slightly off

Fv42Sto - fine

Fv43
 - Fv4045 is slightly off (checked via imagery, though it's hard to tell as the junction is in shadow, but it's slightly west of the actual location)
 - Fv461_W is slightly off
 - FibVei -> FiboVei

Fv44
 - Fv428_N -> rename or add route
 - move E39(28) to overbridge
 - Fv4144 is slightly off
 - move E39_S to overbridge

Fv44Sta
 - is this not part of Fv440, per OSM? Certainly the route confirmation cartouche at the E39 end has [44] with broken (ie 'to') border (and E39 likewise the other end)
 - Fv44San -> Fv44

Fv46 - Fv520 -> Fv46Rop/520 or Fv46/520 ?

Fv46Rop - fine

Fv47 - Fv4942 is slightly off

Fv48, Fv48Ars - fine

Fv49 - Fv136_Sam -> Fv5132

Fv49Odd - fine

Offline michih

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3231
  • Last Login:September 16, 2021, 12:11:48 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #31 on: November 22, 2020, 02:43:40 pm »
https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/4337

Fv44Sta
 - is this not part of Fv440, per OSM? Certainly the route confirmation cartouche at the E39 end has [44] with broken (ie 'to') border (and E39 likewise the other end)

Yep, some changes happened due to the tunnel opening, e.g. Rv509 was partially downgraded to Fv441 now. Fv44Sta is Fv440 up to the northern end of the new tunnel now.

Offline si404

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1536
  • Last Login:September 02, 2021, 01:19:56 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #32 on: November 29, 2020, 07:00:29 am »
Fv50 - FjeVeg is very slightly off

Fv50Bel
 - Fv50 is off
 - check location of Bel (it seems odd, but that suggests you got the exact location of the end of the designation)

Fv51
 - Bri -> TesVeg?
 - Lag -> MoeVeg?
 - GolVeg is slightly off
 - Fv2912 is very slightly off

Fv51Gje - fine

Fv53
 - shaping point near Kolnostunnelen is off by some distance
 - Fv2515 is slightly off

Fv55 - OlnVeg is off

Fv55Bal, Fv55Hoy - fine

Fv57
 - Yrt -> YtreBoVeg?
 - Fv607_S -> Fv607_E as paired with _W
 - Fv5654 is off
 - Fv5597 is slightly off
 - shaping point 3 south of Fv607_N is off
 - shaping point 1 south of Fv607_N is off
 - shaping point 1 north of Fv607_N is off (and replace with a point at Hauglandsvegen)
 - Dale -> DalsVeg
 - Fv5678 is off
 - Fv5676 is off
 - Fv423 is slightly off
 - E39 is slightly off

Fv57Dal, Fv57Lin, Fv59, Fv59Gim - fine

Fv60
 - GerVeg -> GreVeg
 - ToFv77 -> To Fv5918
 - add point at the other end of HevVeg (or replace HevVeg with point at LanVeg)
 - E39_W is slightly off (and rename E39/15? should be E39_S if you don't mention Rv15, with E39_S renamed E39_Byr, as paired with E39_N)
 - Fv5725 is off
 - Fv5736 is slightly off
 - Fv5738 is off

Fv60Bli - NegVei is off

Fv60Hel, Fv60Str - fine

Fv61
 - Syl is off
 - Ska is off
 - Hat is off
 - Fv620 is slightly off
 - Rv15 is off

Fv61Har
 - StoVin -> Hol
 - Fv61Uls is off
 - Fv654 is slightly off
 - Fv5870 is off
 - shaping point s of Fv5852 is off

Fv61Mau
 - Fv657 is off
 - EikVeg_E is slightly off
 - EikVeg_W is slightly off

Fv61Uls - Fv61 is off (as previously mentioned)

Fv62
 - Fos is off (also rename StorGusVeg?)
 - Fv666 is off
 - Eid is off (also rename EidVeg)
 - SveVeg is off
 - Fv6138 is slightly off
 - move Rv70 to middle of roundabout

Fv63, Fv63Gei - already dealt with in norntv

Fv63GeF - GeiHelFry is off!

Fv64
 - Fv6072_N is slightly off
 - Fv6074_E is slightly off
 - Fv6074_W is slightly off
 - Fv663_N is off
 - Fv6104_N is off
 - Fv6108 is slightly off
 - Fv6068 is slightly off
 - Fv6054 is slightly off
 - Fv6052_S is slightly off
 - Fv529 is off
 - Bol_W -> TroVeg_W?
 - Bol_E -> TroVeg_E?

Fv64And - fine

Fv64Isf
 - Fv660 is slightly off
 - GamVeg -> GamAfaVeg

Fv65
 - Fle -> SneVeg
 - Fv6158 is slightly off
 - Fv6150_S -> Fv6150_Hon?
 - Fv6150_N -> Fv6150_Rov?
 - Fv6170 is slightly off
 - Ris is slightly off
 - Fv6469_S is slightly off
 - Fv6498 is off

Offline michih

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3231
  • Last Login:September 16, 2021, 12:11:48 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #33 on: December 01, 2020, 02:35:59 pm »
Fv50Bel
 - check location of Bel (it seems odd, but that suggests you got the exact location of the end of the designation)

No, location was wrong according to vegvesen.no

Fv60
 - E39_W is slightly off (and rename E39/15? should be E39_S if you don't mention Rv15, with E39_S renamed E39_Byr, as paired with E39_N)

I've renamed E39_N to E39_E instead because E39_S is a point in use.

https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/4359

Offline si404

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1536
  • Last Login:September 02, 2021, 01:19:56 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #34 on: June 03, 2021, 09:30:03 am »
Fv72 - fine

Fv72San - marked on OSM (and GM) as Fv756. Presume that's the former number. Signed as Fv322 on GMSV, but that's the number of the Swedish continuation.

Fv72Ver - fine

Fv74
 - Fv7010 is off
 - Heg is slightly off (and check road name isn't signed)
 - Fv7012 is slightly off
 - Fv765 is slightly off
 - Hol is slightly off (and check road name isn't signed)
 - NOR/SWE is off (also SWE L342). Or OSM hasn't got the border in the right place.

Fv76
 - Fv76Hom is slightly off
 - Don, shaping point, Sau and Nor are off
 - shaping point is off (and perhaps move to road junction and make visible)
 - Hon, and all shaping points between there and Tos, are off

Fv76Hom - Fv76 is slightly off

Fv78 - fine

Fv78Omm - E6 is off (looks like an offline rebuild of E6)

Fv79 - fine

Fv81 - pretty much every point is off

Fv81Svo - both points could do with slight adjusting

Fv82
 - Fv7694 is slightly off
 - Kva is off
 - Gje is slightly off
 - OmVei is off (also check name)
 - shaping point slightly off.

Fv82And, Fv82Fis - fine

Fv84
 - BakVei is slightly off
 - Nat is slightly off
 - Gro is slightly off
 - Fv84Med is off
 - StrVei is off
 - Fv851 is slightly off

Fv84Med - both points off

Fv86
 - rename Tor per roads?
 - Fv855 is off
 - RabVei is slighly off

Fv86Gry - fine

Fv87 - E6/E8 is slightly off

Fv91 - fine

Fv91Lyn - Fv868 is slightly off

Fv91Old - E6 is off

Fv98
 - shaping point is off
 - LakVei and Ada are slightly off
 - Tor is off
 - Fv98Sma is off
 - Fv8080 is slightly off
 - Mas is slightly off

Fv98Sma - Fv98 is off

Offline si404

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1536
  • Last Login:September 02, 2021, 01:19:56 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #35 on: June 03, 2021, 12:39:41 pm »
Fv102 - NOR/SWE slightly off

Fv103 - fine

Fv104 - Fv1344 slightly off

Fv106 - NOR/SWE slightly off (OSM has the border where there's a straight line through the trees - seems correct)

Fv107 - fine

Fv108
 - Fv1116 -> Fv1116_N
 - Skj is off (looks a recent reroute of the road)

Fv108Fre - is this part of the mainline as the other branch of Fv108 in Fredrikstad is a third of the length?

Fv109 - fine

Fv109Sar - should this be two routes?

Fv112 - fine

Fv113 - Fv130 off (rerouted to the south around cemetery)

Fv114 - fine

Fv115
 - Fv1454_N -> Fv1454
 - Fv1266 -> Fv1256

Fv116
 - SaltBak -> SalBak
 - Fc1098 is slightly off

Fv117 - fine

Fv118
 - add shaping point between E6(8 ) and Fv1170 to draw road correct side of E6?
 - Fv1170 is slightly off
 - Rv204_E is slightly off
 - NOR/SWE is off

Fv118Ekh, Fv118Hal, Fv118Ing, Fv118Lan - fine

Fv119
 - Fv118_N -> Fv118Ekh (matches concurrent Fv118)
 - Rv355 -> StoVei
 - Fv118_S -> Fv118_Rek?

Fv120 - Fv1022_S is slightly off

Fv120Gar - fine

Fv120Lil - Fv120Lil -> Fv120

Fv120Tei
 - Fv180 is slightly off
 - road cut in two between Fv1542 and Fv1484 by a landslide. Don't know how you want to deal with that.

Fv121, Fv122 - fine

Fv123
 - Fv1294 is slightly off
 - Fv125 is slightly off

Fv124, Fv124Rak, Fv125, Fv126, Fv128 - fine

Fv129
 - E18 is off (also AskMot and Rv22)
 - Rv22 -> Rv22_S?

Fv130 - Fv113 is off

Offline michih

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3231
  • Last Login:September 16, 2021, 12:11:48 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #36 on: June 03, 2021, 02:41:58 pm »
Fv72San - marked on OSM (and GM) as Fv756. Presume that's the former number. Signed as Fv322 on GMSV, but that's the number of the Swedish continuation.

GSV from 2010 shows a 756 sign after the junction towards Sweden. 2019 GSV shows new signs at the junction but no change in numbering, still the Swedish number. You can also see the sign after the junction but it is impossible identifing the number.... And still, the regional reform got in force in 2020. 2019 GSV shows the "old situation".
72 is indicated on the official map. Keep as-is.


Fv74
  - Heg is slightly off (and check road name isn't signed)

The "road name" for the courtyard is just the road name of Fv74

- Hol is slightly off (and check road name isn't signed)

Same here. However, OSM indicates "Holand" (with 1x "l" only) but a sign indicates Gjestegard:
Hol -> Gje

Tot and KVe have specific names on OSM (but not signed on GSV), changed.


- NOR/SWE is off (also SWE L342). Or OSM hasn't got the border in the right place.

OSM and GM show the same location and there is a pavement change. The Swedish sign is there, the Norwegian to the west. The current wp location - to the east - is definitely off. Changed.


Fv81Svo - both points could do with slight adjusting

The Fry wp is fine according to OSM + Esri WorldImagery satellite view.

Offline michih

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3231
  • Last Login:September 16, 2021, 12:11:48 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #37 on: June 03, 2021, 03:49:46 pm »
Fv109Sar - should this be two routes?

A 0.13mi route is also odd. And how should I name them, Sarpsborg-West and Sarpsborg-East? Keep as-is.

Fv118
 - NOR/SWE is off

yep, I moved northwards based on GSV / Esri, OSM is off to the west


Fv120Tei
 - road cut in two between Fv1542 and Fv1484 by a landslide. Don't know how you want to deal with that.

The road seems to be renewed according to latest satellite images (direct link doesn't work, cloud filter must be manually moved from 53% to ~20%).
There was still a gap on 2021-04-15.
I suspect that it will be opened soon. Keep as-is.


https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/4850
« Last Edit: June 03, 2021, 04:08:10 pm by michih »

Offline si404

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1536
  • Last Login:September 02, 2021, 01:19:56 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #38 on: June 23, 2021, 11:36:47 am »
Fv151, Fv152, Fv152Dro, Fv154 - fine

Fv155 - does it end there, at the border of Oslo, or E18?

Fv156 - should it, as the main route, extend to E6 rather than end at a T-junction with a shorter Fv156 route?

Fv156Tog - move E6/E18 per 1ppi?

Fv157, Fv158, Fv160, Fv161 - fine

Fv164/Fv164San - shouldn't the main route be the longest possible?

Fv165, Fv166, Fv167, Fv168 - fine

Fv169 - new bypass built at Rv22 end

Fv170
 - Fv13468 -> Fv1468
 - Fv1564 -> Fv1464
 - Fv1565 -> Fv1465

Fv171 - Fv173 is off

Fv172 - SkiVeg -> SkrVeg

Fv173 - Fv171 is off

Fv174 - Fv458_N -> Fv1554_N

Fv175 - Fv1954 is off

Fv176 - fine

Fv177 - Fv1594 is off

Fv178 - Fv1553 is off

Fv179, Fv180 - fine

Fv181 - add point for what OSM shows as a spur in Eidsvoll

Fv183, Fv184 - fine

Fv186
 - point for the roundabout at the airport? (replacing shaping point)
 - Fv1734 points should have the concurrency pair as _N/_S or _E/_W (perhaps _Hol for the northern end?)

Fv187, Fv196, Fv196Mid, Fv198 - fine

Offline michih

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3231
  • Last Login:September 16, 2021, 12:11:48 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #39 on: June 23, 2021, 02:34:15 pm »
https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/4922


Fv155 - does it end there, at the border of Oslo, or E18?

No, no and no!


Fv181 - add point for what OSM shows as a spur in Eidsvoll

Spur added as it is also indicated on vegkart


Fv186
 - Fv1734 points should have the concurrency pair as _N/_S or _E/_W (perhaps _Hol for the northern end?)

_Rin for Ringsaker municipality

Offline si404

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1536
  • Last Login:September 02, 2021, 01:19:56 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #40 on: June 24, 2021, 07:10:36 am »
https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/4922


Fv155 - does it end there, at the border of Oslo, or E18?

No, no and no!
So no to all three? Why no change then?

But looking at your links, you've messed up. The first one is a yes for at the border (if I go and move it to the relevant location), the second for no to E18, and the third a yes for 'there'.

So your post should read "Yes, yes, and no!"

No change is a valid option, or move that end to the bridge.

Offline michih

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3231
  • Last Login:September 16, 2021, 12:11:48 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #41 on: June 24, 2021, 12:20:23 pm »
But looking at your links, you've messed up.

Sorry, your question was "Does it end there .... or E18". I asked myself "Does it extend to E18"? The answer to your question is yes, yes and yes. The answer to my question is no, no and no.

Signs at the current end only indicate 156 eastbound, not westbound (GSV 2019).
The official map confirms that 156 only heads to the east from the current end point.
Signs at E18 only indicates "To 156" (with dotted line).

Leave as-is.

Offline si404

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1536
  • Last Login:September 02, 2021, 01:19:56 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #42 on: July 27, 2021, 09:57:28 am »
Fv164Hag, Fv181Eid - fine

Fv201
 - Fv1868, Fv2018 and Fv2038 are slightly off
 - Fv1869 is off

Fv201Kir - fine

Fv202
 - move Fv1992 to centre of roundabout
 - BilVeg is off

Fv205, Fv206, Fv208, Fv209, Fv210, Fv210Val, Fv211 - fine

Fv212
 - Fv184 to centre of roundabout
 - E6 isn't a junction, move to Fv1774 where there is one (exit 73)

Fv213 - fine

Fv215
 - Fv606 -> Fv2188
 - Fv237 is slightly off

Fv216, Fv217, Fv218 - fine

Fv219 - Fv2204 is off

Offline michih

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3231
  • Last Login:September 16, 2021, 12:11:48 pm

Offline si404

  • TM Collaborator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1536
  • Last Login:September 02, 2021, 01:19:56 pm
Re: norfv + norntv: Norway Primære Fylkesveier + Nasjonale Turistveger
« Reply #44 on: August 16, 2021, 11:07:52 am »
Fv220, Fv220Sot - fine

Fv221
 - TyoVei -> TjoVei
 - border is off

Fv222, Fv222Ham, Fv223, Fv224, Fv225, Fv227, Fv228, Fv229, Fv230, Fv231, Fv232, Fv235, Fv236, Fv237, Fv240, Fv241 - fine

Fv243 - End -> HedVeg_W?

Fv244
 - add point for Silogata as links to 33/256 junction
 - Fv2338 is off

Fv245 - Rin is off, other points might be slightly off

Fv246, Fv247 - fine

Fv249 - Ove -> Fv2440?