fragesdXX: Grand-Est Routes Départementales

[michih]

fragesm54 - Métropole du Grand Nancy Routes Métropolitaines
fragesm57 - Metz Métropole Routes Métropolitaines

First M routes appeared on OSM in the last few days. I could not find M route signs in Metz on October 2020 GSV but in Nancy

I should wait a little bit till the OSM update is (hopefully) complete.

Nancy looks quite advances according to 2021 GSV and OSM. Metz still looks bad.
fragesm54 - Métropole du Grand Nancy Routes Métropolitaines will be in devel state with some routes after the next site update

[michih]

Métropole du Grand Nancy Routes Métropolitaines will be in preview with the next site update. More than 20 routes for some 35mi.

[michih]

fragesm57 - Metz Métropole Routes Métropolitaines

I could not find M route signs in Metz on October 2020 GSV

Metz still looks bad.

OSM indicates some M routes since 2020 but they are not confirmed by October 2022 GSV. I didn't find a single M route sign all over the place in Metz.

[si404]

D300, D303, D304, D304Sau, D309, D310, D311, D314, D315, D319, D320, D321, D322, D323, D324 - fine

D325 - D1006 -> D100

D326, D327, D328, D329, D330, D331, D332, D333 - fine

D334 - guessing the maps we have (mostly using similar data) are wrong on where the border is.

D335, D337, D338, D339 - fine

D340 - move D740 to centre of roundabout

D341, D344, D348, D350, D351, D362, D370, D388, D392, D397, D401 - fine

D403 - border again, this time the river is an obvious border. Guessing Alsace maintains the bridge...

D404, D410, D411Pfe, CHE D411, D411, D414, D415, D415Wol, D416 - fine

D416B - D416 -> D300/D416

D417, D418, D419, D420, D421, D422, D423, D424, D425 - fine

D426 - RuePri -> RuePri_S

D427, D428 - fine

D429 - D430(9) -> D155/D430

D430, D430Wit, D431 - fine

D432
 - D18.9 needs that route added
 - add point for Swiss route 247?

D433, D434, D435, D436, D437, D439, D441, D442, D444, D459 - fine

D463
 - D11B doesn't meet D11B as that route needs adding (that route also meets D473 and D724)
 - add point to correspond with D473 RueFor (marked as D16 on OSM, with good reason)

D466, D468, D468Dru, D468Nee, D469, D473, D481, D483 - fine

[si404]

D500, D501, D502 - fine

D503
 - D3_W -> D3
 - End -> CliLim (for Climbach Limits) or Win/Cli (for Wingen/Climbach) ?

D504 - fine

D505 - RueOrs_S -> RueOrs

D509, D510, D514, D517 - fine

D519 - D1340 -> D176/D1340

D521, D522, D523, D524, D524Tha, D525, D526, D529, D530, D531, D534, D535, D539, D541, D553, D570 - fine

[michih]

https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/6395

D334 - guessing the maps we have (mostly using similar data) are wrong on where the border is.

The wp was where the shp file has the last point. GM has the border there too. OSM is right about the actual border line though, see mapillary.
We might think about a 0.04mi long DEU-RP D334-6ae route but signs in the field are obvious.

Changed.

D403 - border again, this time the river is an obvious border. Guessing Alsace maintains the bridge...

Wp also according to shp file and GM but yes, the river is obviously the border, likely maintained by Alsace. No mapillary pics available. A 0.01mi DEU-RP D403-6ae segment makes no sense.

Moved to river.

[si404]

D11B, D18.9, D600, D601, D602, D603, D604, D605, D606, D607, D608, D609 - fine

D611, D612, D613, D616, D617, D619, D620, D621, D622, D623, D624, D625, D627, D629 - fine

D630, D632, D633, D638, D642, D643, D645 - fine

D648 - D415/D468_X -> D48/D415_X

D650 - fine

D653 - D28 -> D28/D662

D654, D655, D657, D658, D659, D660, D662 - fine

D663 - D rather than M?

D666, D667, D668, D669, D670, D672, D675, D677, D680, D682, D683, D686, D690 - fine

D692 - D1061_S -> D800/D1061

D696, D697, D698, D699, D700, D701, D702, D703, D704, D705, D706, D707, D708, D709 - fine

D710, D711, D712, D713, D715, D716, D717, D718, D719 - fine

D720 - D1004 is off

D721, D722, D722Sch, D723, D724, D725 - fine

D726 - D246 -> D24

D727, D729, D730, D731, D732, D734, D735, D737, D738, D739 - fine

D740, D741, D742, D743, D744, D745, D747, D748, D750, D751 - fine

D752 - D734_W -> D734_N

D753, D754, D755, D756, D757, D758, D759, D766, D768, D769, D772 - fine

D774 - D1 -> D1.6

D777, D782, D783, D788, D790, D790Kir, D791, D793, D796 - fine

[si404]

D800, D801, D802, D803, D804, D805, D806, D807, D808, D809, D810, D813, D815, D816, D817, D818 - fine

D820, D821, D822, D823, D824, D825, D827, D829, D830, D832, D835, D842, D848 - fine

D850, D853, D854, D855, D857, D858, D866, D872, D883, D888, D888Nor, D897 - fine

D901, D903, D904, D906, D913, D917, D918, D919, D922, D924, D925, D927, D929 - fine

D930, D935, D942, D953, D957, D988, D993, D997 - fine

D1004 - D422/D2004 -> D422/D942 ? (numerical order)

D1059 - D424 -> D424_S

D1061, D1062, D1063, D1066, D1083, D1340, D1363, D1404, D1420 - fine

D1422 - D603_N -> D603_S

D2004 - D422/D1004 -> D422/D942 ? (numerical order)

D2029 - fine

D2420 - D392_S -> D315/D392

[michih]

https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/6407

D1422 - D603_N -> D603_S

D603_E

Did you check all 780 routes? If so, I'll check NMPs tomorrow.

[si404]

Did you check all 780 routes?

Any route I've not listed?

[michih]

Did you check all 780 routes?

Any route I've not listed?

Dunno. 780 is a lot. I just want to say "I'm happy that you did it"

You sometimes skip something and I wanted to be sure

[michih]

No datacheck errors, NMPs checked and marked FP. Any further comments to Alsace before activation?

[si404]

I don't have further comment.

[michih]

fragesd6ae - Collectivité européenne d'Alsace Routes Départementales will be activated with the next site update. 780 routes for almost 3,500mi.

[michih]

fragesm57 - Metz Métropole Routes Métropolitaines

I could not find M route signs in Metz on October 2020 GSV

Metz still looks bad.

OSM indicates some M routes since 2020 but they are not confirmed by October 2022 GSV. I didn't find a single M route sign all over the place in Metz.

I finally found a blue M route sign from September 2024 However, most of GSV is still from 2022/23 (or older) showing only yellow D route signs. Most of mapillary pics are from 2017. OSM was mostly updated D -> M over the past months, sometimes refering to this wiki route list . GM does also indicate blue M routes meanwhile. This might be a GO for drafting the system

Edit: wikisara does also have a route list, to be checked.