Ireland Regional Roads (irlr)

[michih]

I wanna start a peer-review but I already have a problem with the first route...

http://tm.teresco.org/hb/index.php?r=irl.r101

How are the exit numbers signed? I couldn't find any on GM, OSM nor GSV!?

[si404]

They are only not on OSM as an eejit hid them.

Not sure how you didn't find them on GSV as they are well signed.

[michih]

I think it was because of the J prefix. J like... Exit?

[si404]

J is for Junction (and at-grade things like these would have it even in US-English) - though, unlike the UK, the RoI do use Amach / EXIT for offslips.

Perhaps I should put J in front of the inner Dublin exit numbers?

[michih]

Perhaps I should put J in front of the inner Dublin exit numbers?

Good idea!

[michih]

Ok, tier 4 is done, tier 5 is next

R101-R149 are fine except:

R109:
wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=53.351044&lon=-6.352721


R118:
N31_E: N31 doesn't intersect, should be renamed to R119_W
See R137/R138


R119:
N31_E: N31 doesn't intersect, should be renamed to R118_W, R118 --> R118_E


R127/R132:
Are you sure about the location of the junction? It's different on GM and OSM


R131:
J prefix for wps 79, 80 and 81


R132:
N1(19) --> 19(N1)
N1(20) --> 20(N1)
M1(18) should be removed
R173 --> M1(18)
Exceeds limits b/n R172_S and R166_N


R135:
N2_N --> M2_N
R125 --> M2(3)


R137:
R138 should be replaced by R138 wp R118


R138:
R137 should be removed
R118 should be renamed to R118/R138
R110/R840 wp is like R137 wp


R147:
Should be routed via one branch south of Facebook only. The 2nd route should be an own route
N3(4)..N3(1) --> 4(N3)..1(N3)
NavRdPkwySta --> NavRdPkwy
R109/R122 --> R109/R112
N4(1)..M4(5) --> 1(N4)..5(M4)
R158_S --> Are you sure that it's R158?

[michih]

R150-R199 fine except...

R164:
move N51 wp to the junction


R171:
Exceeds limits b/n N2/N33 and R166

[michih]

N14/N56:
Concurrency broken east of Letterkenny


R149:
R1247 --> R147


All R2xx routes fine except:

R206:
N4 --> N16
R206 --> R206Bla


R206bla:
N4 --> N16


R212:
N3 --> N3_N


R238/R239:
Question: Is it correct to call the three R239 wps R239_W, R239_E and R239 w/o suffix? I would call them R239_S, R239_N and R239_E. Same for R238 wps of R239...


R245:
R247 wp has incorrect coordinates


R247:
New L1132 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=55.230742&lon=-7.698557


R253:
New +X999999 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=54.813546&lon=-7.889219 or move +X383426 of R252


R267:
It is signed on concurrency to N15? If not, split the route


R288/R289:
Are incomplete coordinates fine to the code? http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=54.226055&lon=-8.3


R294:
New L4503 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=54.052492&lon=-8.759601

[michih]

All R3xx routes fine except:


R312:
Remove +X593623


R314:
Move +X109214 to L1202_E
Move +X998134 to L1202_W


R327:
wp @ L1513


R335:
Remove +X192447


R338:
N6_W --> N59


R339:
Exceeds limits b/n L3107 and R347


R340:
Remove +X356874


R345:
Move +X265951 to L1613 or remove it


R347:
I think N63 is already realigned
Exceeds limits b/n L3109 and R339
Exceeds limits b/n N18 and N67


R348:
Remove +X371399


R350:
N66 --> N66_S


R353:
Remove +X756559


R357:
Remove +X785432


R362:
N6 --> M6


R393:
Remove +X901584


R396:
Remove +X332412

[si404]

N14/N56:
Concurrency broken east of Letterkenny

There should be no concurrency there. OSM is wrong, but if it was right, then the N14 would end on the N13 and not meet the N56. However the two meet end-on on the edge of Letterkenny town centre.

Are incomplete coordinates fine to the code? http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=54.226055&lon=-8.3

I believe so. I deleted it as frivilous, but I used to have a point on the A21 in England that was on the Prime Meridian, so it ended &lon=-0 (I put the minus in for additional strangeness) and it worked fine.

[michih]

All R4xx routes fine except:

R403:
N4 --> M4
Exceeds limits west of R414


R413:
New wp for R445 at roundabout


R420:
R443 --> R443_N


R430:
Exceeds limits b/n R445 and L5677


R445:
M7(12) wp should be moved to the roundabout and renamed to R413
M7(16) wp should be moved to the roundabout
Are you sure about N77 northern end at M7, not N80?
OSM indicates a different route through Nenagh
Concurrency with N52 broken west of Nenagh


R463:
Exceeds limits b/n R458 and OldEnnRd


R483:
Exceeds limits b/n R484 and N67_S


R484:
Exceeds limits 3x b/n R483 and N68


R493:
Exceeds limits b/n L1094 and L6105

[michih]

All R5xx routes fine except:

R573:
N571_E --> N571_N
N571_W --> N571_S


R577:
N21/N22 --> N21/N23

[michih]

All R6xx routes fine except:

R600:
R613 is off and it might be split into two wps


R639:
Move M8(7) to the roundabout
Move M8(18) to the roundabout


R651:
N40 --> N40_E


R426/R694:
Move N78 wp to the junction

[michih]

All R7xx routes fine except:

R733:
Exceeds limits b/n R770 and R737
R734_S --> R734


R747:
Exceeds limits b/n R748 and R753


R751/R772:
New wp R772_S / R751_E @ roundabout
Move M11(22) to the western roundabout
I think N11_S instead of M11 is fine because I guess that N11 will be dedicated R772 once the M11 bypass will be completed and the wp at the end of the bypass should be called M11, not N11

[michih]

All R8xx and R9xx routes fine except:

R802:
R101 --> R132


R806:
N50 --> M50


R809:
R106/R139 --> R106_N


R824:
R815 --> R815_N


R825:
R112/R133 --> R112


R133:
R112/R825 --> R112


R846:
Does it not extend to N20? It's such a small gap even if there are no signs on N20...


R888:
R488 --> R448


R920:
A46 --> N3


R927:
R180 wp is @ BalRd according to GM and OSM


R941:
R147_W --> R147/R164

Mission complete