Canada and USA state/province/territorial highways master thread

[mapcat]

If you need someone else to review Alabama, Georgia, and/or Louisiana, I might be able to help with that. Those have been sitting in preview limbo forever.

Thanks for the offer. I'd welcome help with Louisiana.

[michih]

I've added:

usaga Georgia State Highways reviewer: ntallyn
usala Louisiana State Highways reviewer: cl94

Have I missed adding the reviewer on these preview systems or is there still a lack of reviewer? (list with preview date)

2018-11-12: usaal Alabama State Highways reviewer: t.b.d.
2018-06-15: usaar Arkansas State Highways reviewer: t.b.d.
2019-01-13: usaas American Samoa Territorial Highways reviewer: t.b.d.
2017-05-06: usaca California State Highways reviewer: t.b.d.
2018-06-15: usanyp New York Parkways reviewer: t.b.d.
2017-05-05: usapr Puerto Rico Territorial Highways reviewer: t.b.d.
2017-09-06: usaush United States Historic US Routes reviewer: t.b.d.

[ntallyn]

I've added:

usaga Georgia State Highways reviewer: ntallyn
usala Louisiana State Highways reviewer: cl94

Sorry, I was being confusing. I'm not reviewing the GA highways, I'm doing the update work (I picked it up around Christmastime).

[michih]

I've added:

usaga Georgia State Highways reviewer: ntallyn
usala Louisiana State Highways reviewer: cl94

Sorry, I was being confusing. I'm not reviewing the GA highways, I'm doing the update work (I picked it up around Christmastime).

well, no. I thought that your "update work" is also the peer-review. But if I'm not mistaken, you are quite new, your first "new" system? If so, I think that another more experienced contributor should peer-review it. If you prefer being peer-reviewed, just edit the first post and replace your name by t.b.d.

[michih]

usaga Georgia State Highways reviewer: ntallyn
->
usaga Georgia State Highways reviewer: t.b.d.


usaca California State Highways reviewer: t.b.d.
->
usaca California State Highways reviewer: neroute2

[neroute2]

Did mapmikey review usaga, or was that only a partial go-over? I've finished usaca and usafl, and can move on to either usaar or usaga now.

[mapmikey]

Did mapmikey review usaga, or was that only a partial go-over? I've finished usaca and usafl, and can move on to either usaar or usaga now.

I did go through all the GA state routes looking for labeling errors, missing waypoints, shaping points and stuff like that.  Ntallyn appears to have gone through my list of suggested edits and made changes.  One challenge is that a lot of state route changes require a corresponding US route change and some internal github reviews regarding broken concurrencies is certainly needed.

[neroute2]

Ok, looks like I'll start on usaar after work today.

[mapcat]

Ok, looks like I'll start on usaar after work today.

Thank you!

[michih]

usaar Arkansas State Highways reviewer: t.b.d.
-->
usaar Arkansas State Highways reviewer: neroute2

[neroute2]

I just reviewed usatxre.

[michih]

usala Louisiana State Highways reviewer: cl94
->
usala Louisiana State Highways reviewer: neroute2

[vdeane]

Question: would the Allegany State Park routes in NY be something that we would want to add to the site?  There are three routes in the park signed with shields.  To the best of my knowledge, Allegany State Park is the only state park in New York with signed (or even unsigned) route numbers.  As such, Allegany State Park Routes could be a potential tier 5 system for NY.

I guess the big question would be whether we consider these to be more similar to county routes or to usanp.  Clinching these would require going past the fee booths, but then, the same is true for many usanp routes.

[Duke87]

I'd categorize these with county routes: fails to clear the bar of sufficient significance for inclusion.

Specifically to the point - driving these roads should not be considered a required component of finishing New York.

[michih]

canabs Alberta Primary Provincial Highways 500-986 (tier 5) reviewer: julmac
canmbs Manitoba Provincial Roads (tier 5) reviewer: michih
cannl Newfoundland and Labrador Provincial Highways reviewer: yakra
cannss Nova Scotia Scenic Travelways (tier 5) reviewer: t.b.d.
usaal Alabama State Highways reviewer: t.b.d.
usaar Arkansas State Highways reviewer: neroute2
usaas American Samoa Territorial Highways reviewer: t.b.d.
usaca California State Highways reviewer: neroute2
usala Louisiana State Highways reviewer: neroute2
usams Mississippi State Highways
usanyp New York Parkways reviewer: t.b.d.
usapr Puerto Rico Territorial Highways reviewer: t.b.d.
usaush United States Historic US Routes reviewer: t.b.d.

Is the status still up-to-date?

Can we add who developed the systems as we did for the other regions in the world? (only for systems which are not yet active)
Or say, who will work on bringing it active?

I think canabs, canmbs, usaar, usaca and usala have been reviewed but the developer has not yet completed the rework?
Is any of the preview systems not yet ready for peer-review?
Is any system missing in the list, Texas?