Poland Drogi Krajowa - poldk

[si404]

This system is ready for review

[michih]

I'll make a review this fall like I've done for norrv and svng

[michih]

DK1psz:
S69 waypoint is S1/S52 now

DK3:
Exceeds limits b/n UliLeg and DK94

DK3swi:
UliKarSwi_S waypoint should be DW111 and location should be moved to the underpass (concurrent E road too)

DK5byd:
DK80 waypoint missing
Exceeds limits b/n DW248 and DW245

DK7kie:
DK55/502 wp should be DK55 only

DK7rad:
New wp: JanaJisLip http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=51.352313&lon=21.046178

DK7zuk:
DW20 wp should be DK20

DK8:
Exceeds limits b/n DW655 and +X619542 (concurrent S61 and E road too)
PloOsi should be DW662
Location of Lithunian border wp seems to be far away from the border

DK8mar:
AleJanaPaw should be DW635

DK10sie:
Exceeds limits b/n UliSie and DW539

DK11:
Exceeds limits b/n Dob and DW172
Dw167 wp label should be DW167

DK12:
DK1/8 wp label should be changed (S8 or DK91?)
Generally, S8 seems to have numbered exit labels
S8(326) should be 326(S8)
S8(330) should be 330(S8)
New wp: DW742 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=51.375742&lon=19.821095 (concurrent DK74 too)
DW726 wp is no exit
DK12 b/n Pulawy and Jastkow seems to be still signed DK12 (OSM, GSV)

DK14:
New wp: DW713 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=51.761552&lon=19.485090 (road to A1)
DW70 wp should be DW708

DK15:
Exceeds limits b/n DW538 and BrzLub

DK20:
Exceeds limits b/n Gin and Tonic
DW20 wp should be DK7

DK22:
Exceeds limits b/n Uni and DW201
DW22 wp should be DK91

DK23:
Psc wp label should be Psz

DK28:
Dw957 wp label should be DW957
Exceeds limits b/n Krz and Kra

DK32:
Dw431 wp label should be DW431
Dw280 wp label should be DW280

DK40:
Dw411_N wp label should be DW411_N

DK43:
DK1 wp label should be DK1/46


I've not yet reviewed DK50 to DK98 except:


DK73:
Dw764 wp label should be DW764

[michih]

Why have you not done this modification?

DK20:
DW20 wp should be DK7

DK10sie:
DW50_S wp should be DK50_S

DK36:
I think DW292 wp should get a suffix because there's already DW292_N and DW292_S

DK46:
DW91 wp should be DK91

DK50:
DW10_W should be DK10_W

DK52cie:
It's concurrent with S52. Dunno if it's right  but if it isn't, DK52 "Jab" wp should be called S52 because it's the only wp. No problem with a potential future S52 extension because DK52Cie would not exist anymore

DK53:
Move +X238217 a little bit to the north and call it "Pod" (Podgorze)
Move +X245122 a little bit to the north and call it "Zal" (Zalesie)

DK61:
I think DW633 wp be DW801

DK62:
Move +X789251 a little bit to the west and call it "Zuz" (Zuzalka)

DK62:
I think there should be a wp at the old DK8 junction in Wyszkow, Bialostoaka
Move +X294703 a little bit to the west and unhide it
Move +X983179 a little bit to the west and call it "SloAnn" (Slochy Annopolskie)

DK72:
Exceeds limits b/n AleKlo and DW707

DK74:
Exceeds limits b/n UliPio and DW484_S

DK74zam:
Move +X801392 a little bit to the south and unhide it

DK75:
There should be a wp at the junction to A4 Brzesko interchange
Exceeds limits b/n DW980 and LosDol

DK85:
DK575 wp should be DW575

DK91:
DW12/74_E wp should be DK12/74
DW46 wp should be DK46

DK94tar:
DK835 wp should be DW835


Some routes are not yet checked because the maps are currently loaded damn slow but I'll complete my review in the coming days or weeks.

[michih]

DK7/DK79/DK94:
DK79/94 wp should be S7 or S52
Is the western Krakau access road (s007wkr) still signed S7 or already S52 like it's indicated on OSM? Should be clearified before activation to avoid that the DK7, DK79 and DK94 wps must be renamed again.

DK78:
Exceeds limits b/n Sud and DW742
Exceeds limits b/n DW791_N and DW793
New wp: DW913 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=50.450256&lon=19.067931
New wp: DW973_S http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=50.294107&lon=20.799479 (shaping point or additional wp (StaKor) needed west of the junction)
DW973 should be renamed to DW973_N
Exceeds limits b/n KroGora and Uli11Lis
NEW wp: DW873 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=52.043190&lon=21.081331

DK80:
DK10_E should be A1 like S10 wp label

DK81:
S1 wp should be S52

DK82:
S12/17 wp should be S12/S17

DK84:
Move +X293191 a little bit to the east and call it "Jan" (Jankowce) or "Gli" (Glinne)
Move +X988700 a little bit to the west and call it "Rud" (Rudenka) or "Pod" (Podmagura)

DK86:
DK94_E wp should be S86 (like DK94's wp), maybe DK94 wp of S86 should be renamed to DK86/94

DK86kat:
S1_S wp should be S1 only

DK91:
S5/91 wp should be S5 only
New wp: DW301 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=52.746918&lon=18.886099
S8(326) should be 326(S8)
S8(330) should be 330(S8)
DK12/74_E should be DK12/74 only
DK1_Cze should be DK1 only

DK91gda:
New wp: DroZie http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=54.388011&lon=18.650333
S6 should be ToS6 or ToA1

DK94tar:
DK19_S wp should be DK19 only

DK97:
New wp: Rze http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=50.055458&lon=22.036922 + shaping point required


I've not checked that all routes are mapped neither that all mapped routes are really signed. Nevertheless, my review is completed now. Please fix all data check errors and other checks (e.g. concurrencies) before activation.