Croatia Državna Cesta (hrvd)

[michih]

System is ready for review.

http://tm.teresco.org/hb/index.php?sys=hrvd

Sources and notes: https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/blob/master/hwy_data/HRV/hrvd/README.md

Any feedback is welcomed

[si404]

D1 - GSJ north of L59064
D2 - fine
D3 - fine
D5 - fine
D6 - shaping pt that's wp 39 is off-highway
D7 - fine
D8 - has new bypass between D59/D121 and Z6087_E
D8Dub - fine
D9 - fine
D10 - ToD22 -> D22
D14 - fine
D20 - fine
D22 - ToD10 -> D10
D23 - fine
D24 - fine
D25 - fine
D26 - fine
D27 - fine
D28 - fine
D29 - fine

[si404]

D30 - point for the new airport terminal; does this not extend to the border?
D31 - fine
D32 - fine
D33 - fine
D34 - fine
D35 - fine
D36 - fine
D37 - Z3196_E -> Z3198; Z3196_W -> Z3196
D38 - Pak -> Paka
D39 - fine
D40 - fine
D41 - fine
D42 - fine
D43 - fine
D44 - fine
D45 - fine
D46 - fine
D47 - ToBIH -> D232_S
D48 - fine
D49 - fine
D50 - fine
D51 - fine
D52 - fine
D53 - fine
D54 - fine
D55 - fine
D56 - fine
D57 - fine
D58 - fine
D59 - fine
D60 - fine
D62 - fine
D64 - fine
D66 - fine
D69 - Nov -> NoveZve
D70 - fine
D72 - fine
D74 - fine
D75 - fine
D76 - fine
D77 - fine

[michih]

D30 - point for the new airport terminal

Done. GSV is not available there and OSM/GM/Bing have no name. Is "Air" ok?

does this not extend to the border?

No evidence. Should I extend it anyway? Minimum "border" is mentioned here: http://narodne-novine.nn.hr/clanci/sluzbeni/2016_10_96_2071.html

D47 - ToBIH -> D232_S

Similar to D30 but it's NOT mentioned here: http://narodne-novine.nn.hr/clanci/sluzbeni/2016_10_96_2071.html

[si404]

D30 - point for the new airport terminal

Done. GSV is not available there and OSM/GM/Bing have no name. Is "Air" ok?

Yes

does this not extend to the border?

No evidence. Should I extend it anyway? Minimum "border" is mentioned here: http://narodne-novine.nn.hr/clanci/sluzbeni/2016_10_96_2071.html

D47 - ToBIH -> D232_S

Similar to D30 but it's NOT mentioned here: http://narodne-novine.nn.hr/clanci/sluzbeni/2016_10_96_2071.html

The thing with these is that you have 'useless' concurrencies, where this D road extends along another D road to where the road to the border turns off with really not far on that. It's odd that that would be the routing and more likely would be
1) the road reaches the border
2) the road terminates on the the other road without a concurrency

[michih]

Ok, but should I add border wps for D30 and/or D232?

My point is that I hate ugly gaps...

[si404]

Either add border points, or truncate them. I prefer adding them.

[michih]

Either add border points, or truncate them. I prefer adding them.

Added. I've included a short segment in Bosnia to D30 and have labeled the wp "M14".

[si404]

D100 - fine
D101 - fine
D102 - D8 -> A7?
D103 - fine
D104 - fine
D105 - fine
D106 - Rit -> Rti
D109 - Sal -> Sali
D110 - fine
D111 - fine
D112 - fine
D113 - fine
D114 - fine
D115 - fine
D116 - fine
D117 - fine
D118 - fine
D119 - fine
D120 - fine
D121 - fine
D123 - fine
D124 - fine
D126 - fine
D128 - fine

[si404]

D200 - fine
D201 - fine
D203 - fine
D204 - fine
D205 - fine
D206 - fine
D207 - fine
D208 - fine
D209 - fine
D210 - shaping point -> L26037?
D211 - fine
D212 - fine
D213 - fine
D214 - fine
D216 - fine
D217 - fine
D218 - fine
D219 - fine
D220 - fine
D222 - fine
D223 - fine
D224 - fine
D225 - fine
D227 - fine
D228 - fine
D229 - fine
D231 - fine
D232 - fine

[si404]

D300 - fine
D301 - fine
D302 - Z5198 -> D75? Also check D75 route
D303 - fine
D305 - fine
D306 - fine
D307 - fine
D310 - fine
D312 - fine
D313 - fine
D314 - fine
D315 - fine
D316 - fine

D400 - fine
D401 - fine
D402 - fine
D404 - fine
D405 - fine
D406 - fine
D407 - point for the ferry terminal
D408 - fine
D409 - fine
D410 - fine
D411 - fine
D412 - fine
D413 - fine
D414 - fine
D415 - fine
D416 - fine
D417 - fine
D418 - fine
D420 - fine
D421 - fine
D422 - fine
D423 - move D72 point to middle of roundabout (also D72)
D424 - fine
D425 - fine
D427 - fine
D429 - fine

[si404]

Added. I've included a short segment in Bosnia to D30 and have labeled the wp "M14".

Can you take it back to the border please? Also, that Bosnian road number will change in March (and I ought to start on getting the post-2018 system drafted)


D500 - fine
D501 - fine
D502 - fine
D503 - fine
D507 - fine
D510 - fine
D512 - fine
D514 - fine
D515 - fine
D516 - fine
D517 - fine
D518 - fine
D519 - fine
D520 - fine
D522 - fine
D525 - fine
D526 - fine
D528 - fine
D530 - fine
D531 - fine
D534 - fine
D535 - fine
D536 - fine
D537 - fine
D538 - fine

review done

[michih]

D302 - Z5198 -> D75? Also check D75 route

It appears that the bypass is completed now and dedicated D75.

I've added the D304 route which is visible on OSM and (partially) on GM now.

D423 - move D72 point to middle of roundabout (also D72)

Moved. The roundabout seems to be new. Not yet visible on GM/GS.

Added. I've included a short segment in Bosnia to D30 and have labeled the wp "M14".

Can you take it back to the border please?

Done!

review done

Thank you very much! Activating: https://github.com/TravelMapping/HighwayData/pull/1481

[yakra]

Re "Air": is the airport name known?

[michih]

Re "Air": is the airport name known?

OSM doesn't indicate anything, GM indicates "Zračna luka Zagreb" --> "Airport Zagreb" (name of the capital), GSV is not available.

Wikipedia:

Franjo Tuđman Airport, also known as Zagreb Airport (IATA: ZAG, ICAO: LDZA), is the largest and busiest international airport in Croatia, commonly referred to as Pleso. In 2016 it handled around 2,8 million passengers and some 10,000 tons of cargo.