Spain Carretera Nacionales (espn) + Regional Routes (tier 5)

[si404]

Active systems: AN, CT

Reviews processed for: AR, AS, CB, CM, CN, EX, MC, NC, PV, RI, VC

Reviews given for: CL, IB, MD

Reviews still to be given: (GA when ready)

System to be checked and made preview: GA

[michih]

Reviews still to be given: AS, CB, CL, CM, EX

I'll review them soon. When fraidfd will be done or even earlier 

[michih]

Concurrencies:    FINE
NMPs:             FPs
Add eursf routes: DONE
wikipedia:        https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anexo:Red_de_Carreteras_del_Principado_de_Asturias
wikipedia check:  FINE


AI82:
Should be added as eursf route from A8 exit 417 to the airport. It's only indicated on km posts. GM and wikipedia indicate it being A81 but that's wrong.


AS11:
+X938257 is off
+X690964 is off
AS13/27 -> AS13 since A27 is a green Red Comarcal only?


AS12:
AS22 is off
AS14/28 -> AS14 since A28 is a green Red Comarcal only?


AS13:
AS11/27 -> AS11 since A27 is a green Red Comarcal only?


AS14:
GS1 is off
AS219 is off (it's at AS217 junction)
AS11/28 -> AS11 since A28 is a green Red Comarcal only?


AS15:
AS348 is off


AS19:
GI19 -> GJ19
N633 needs to be renamed since this N633 segment (only indicated on OSM) is not in HB; Maybe ToN632?


AS117:
CalLaMina -> AS387


espas review done!

[michih]

Concurrencies:    FINE
NMPs:             FPs
Add eursf routes: NONE
wikipedia:        https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anexo:Red_primaria_de_carreteras_de_Cantabria
wikipedia check:  CA-137 is not listed but 2018 GSV and an official 2017 map confirms that it's an orange CA route


CA130:
N611_N -> N611_E
N623 wp should be at the other roundabout
N611_S -> N611_W


CA135:
+X175395 is off


CA140:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=43.401078&lon=-3.826421 for S10 exit 6
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=43.417555&lon=-3.845496 for S10 exit 4


CA141:
BarMue -> BarMue_N
CA434/440 -> CA434 ?
CA4448 -> CA448
CA907_E is off


CA142:
CA619 is off
CA262/264 -> CA262 ?


CA146:
CA146a -> CA428, see CA146a
CA432 is off


CA146a:
Is yellow CA428 according to the official 2017 map but still signed CA146(a) according to 2018 GSV. OSM does not indicate any numbering. I guess that the route was downgraded but signs are still there. I would remove the route.



CA151:
CA512 -> CA511/512 ?
CB/PV is off


CA160:
CA162/260 -> CA162 (CA260 is a different system)


CA161:
CA162/261 -> CA162 (CA261 is a different system)


CA162:
CA160/260 -> CA160 (CA260 is a different system)
CA161/261 -> CA161 (CA261 is a different system)


CA170:
CA704 is off


CA171:
CA725 is off


CA180:
CA182/280 -> CA182 (CA280 is a different system)


CA181:
CA842 is off
+X620841 is off
CA850 is off
+X293035 is off
CA182/282 -> CA182 (CA282 is a different system)


CA182:
CA180/280 -> CA180 (CA280 is a different system)
+X804155 is off
Car is off
CA181/281 -> CA181 (CA281 is a different system)


CA183:
PasJimDIaz -> PasJimDiaz or PasDJD


CA184:
CA875 is off
+X973435 is off


espcb review done!

[michih]

Concurrencies:    FINE
NMPs:             FPs
Add eursf routes: NONE
wikipedia:        ? ? ? https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anexo:Red_de_Carreteras_de_Castilla-La_Mancha
wikipedia check:  No complete list, not sure what's your source! Not checked whether complete or not!


A4/E5/N4a:
wp 243 should be synced. It was drafted off by 0.000001° to break the concurrency but since we've split Spain into regions, the routes are split anyway.


CM10x:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=40.647263&lon=-3.141768 ?


CM41x:
2 is off
+X668132 is off


CM42x:
24 is off


CM45x:
5 is off
+X513917 is off
26 is off


CM101:
+X173366 is off
GU150_S is off
GU150_N is off
CM110_W is off


CM110:
CM1101 is off
GU127 is off
GU170 is off
CM101_N is off, see CM101
CM1006 is off


CM200:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=40.551211&lon=-2.857432
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=40.352805&lon=-2.899752
CM2003/2006 -> CM2003 ?
GU226 is off
CM2050 is off
CM3000 is off


CM210:
CM2111 is off
CM2023 is off
CUV9116 is off
Excceds limits b/n CUV9116 and +X379705
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=40.573943&lon=-2.078696


CM211:
CM220 is off


CM215:
CM2250 is off


CM220:
+X470300 can and should be removed
SolCha -> CalMota (Calle Solana is parallel to CM220)
Gab -> CalFue
+X261303 is off
+X873045 is off
QuiRey_N is off
CUV8111 is off


CM310:
CM2108 is off
+X734780 is off
CM2002 is off
CM2025 is off
CamDis source? There is nothing with this name, only east of CM3011 - 4mi away
VilSan is off
Move CM3013 to the center of the roundabout
N301 -> N301_S
CM3105 is off
Move CM3012 to the center of the roundabout
New Wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=39.917700&lon=-2.796029 heading to A3 exit 100
Remove +X446832 then
CM42 -> CM42/420


CM311:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=39.440454&lon=-1.744621
CM3137 is off
CUV8211 is off


CM313:
+X615039 is off
+X745489 is off
+X899325 is off
CM3152 is off
Poz_W -> CarHel_W ?
Poz_E -> CarHel_E ?
Add a hidden wp to show that the route is via the bypass
Does it extend into Hellin?
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=39.044401&lon=-2.572960 (also for concurrent N430)


CM316:
+X163432 is off
CalMar -> AveJRR


CM320:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=38.775683&lon=-2.450691


CM401:
TO3956 is off
CM4157 is off


CM403:
+X253707 is off
+X783760 is off
+X364258 is off


CM410:
CalCamCem -> AveLib
ToA4 -> AveAnd_S
+X821576 is off
TO2031 is just an underpass
CM42 is off, see CM42x
Move TO3221 to the center of the roundabout
TO3045 -> TO3425


CM412:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=38.700838&lon=-1.422448
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=38.681728&lon=-1.452159
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=38.475262&lon=-1.776052
CM3529 is off
CM3529 -> CM3259
+X388078 is off
AB304 is off
CarElCen is off
CarElCen -> CarCen
+X385477 is off
+X419281 is off
+X535765 is off
+X522887 is off
AB5026 is off
CM3119 -> CM3129
+X984452 is off
CR5221 is off
CR5222 is off


CM413:
CarEMCal -> CalAnc
CR5225 is just an underpass
Exceeds limits b/n CM45 and CR5122


CM415:
N430 is off
+X919696 is off


CM420:
New wp http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=39.405494&lon=-2.957243
N430 -> N420/N430

espcm review completed!

[michih]

Concurrencies:    DONE
NMPs:             FPs
Add eursf routes: NONE
wikipedia:        https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anexo:Red_de_Carreteras_de_Castilla_y_Le%C3%B3n
wikipedia check:  CL-625 from the list is not in HB but it's confirmed by OSM, GM and Nov 2018 GSV that it's green BU-525.


N621/N625:
Concurrency broken north of junction with CL626


CL101:
SO132_E is off
SOP4156 is off
+X884935 is off
SOP3162 is off
SO350 is off
+X132172 is off
SO380_N is off


CL116:
SOP4171 is off
A15(39A) should be moved to the roundabout east of the exit
SOP3151 is off
+X870307 is off
new wp @  http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=41.457877&lon=-2.491193 for A15(36)
new wp @  http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=41.443531&lon=-2.469456 for A15(32)


CL117:
BUV8229 is off
+X548923 is off
CarAmo is off
CalMad is off
SO820 is off


CL127:
BU742 is off
BUV7414 is off
BUV7418 is off


CL501adr:
AV901 is off
Remove +X937236


CL505:
AV501/502 -> AV501 ?
N110a -> N110/N403


CL507:
CalCal is off
AV804 is off


CL510:
+X471899 is off
+X905329 is off
SA114_E is off


CL512:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=40.942475&lon=-5.680007
DSA210 is off
SA205/211 -> SA205 ?


CL517:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=41.012811&lon=-6.434960
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=41.010807&lon=-6.440263
+X203301 is off
Move N620 to A62 wp (or extend N620 to the north)


CL526:
DSA391 is off
DSA365 source? GSV shows no sign, GM indicates no road number and OSM suggests CM208
+X903298 is off
N620a -> N620


CL527:
ZA311 is off
ZA316 is off
+X974014 is off
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=41.366940&lon=-6.106711


CL600:
VA200 is off


CL601:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=40.936129&lon=-4.099209
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=40.942775&lon=-4.108608
+X607130 is off
Why CalSol? Should it be GSJ? I'd prefer having wps at the roundabouts


CL602:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=41.323813&lon=-5.147519 (heading to motorway exit)
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=41.311739&lon=-4.920271
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=41.314414&lon=-4.908593
ZA633 is off
ZA605 is off
Replace CalSal by CalCal @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=41.317480&lon=-4.836849
VA405 is off
VA410 is off
VP1104 is off
CalCog -> CalPil
+X371616 is off


CL603:
SGV2223 is off
Replace +X975131 by nearby SGV2412


CL605:
SGP3211 is off
+X970903 is off
+X170934 is off
AV413/804 -> AV413 ?
AV800 is off
SA800/810 -> SA800 ?
+X315838 is off
ZA623 is off


CL610:
Does it extend into Valladolid as OSM and GM suggest?
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=41.314706&lon=-4.913364
ZorFroPar source? CalAlfPar?
VA801_W is off
CarMad is off
CarMad source? AveCIC?
VA405 is off


CL612:
ZAP2314 is off
ZA713 -> ZA714_E
ZA714 -> ZA714_W
Remove +X228078


CL613:
P905_S -> P905/P972?
CalConAns source? CarPal_N?


CL615:
P961 -> P961/P963 ?
PP2414 is off
PP2415 is off


CL619:
BU130 is off
BUP1131 is off
BU113 is off
P113 is off
P114 is off
P130 is off


CL620:
CL/PV -> PV/CL
PV/CL -> CL/PV


CL621:
LE7612 is off
LE411 is off
LE6515 is off
LE6508 is off
LE6501 is off


CL622:
LE6508 is off
Move LE413_N to the center of the roundabout
LE6515 is off
LE6515 -> LE6531
LE6532 is off
LE6506 is off
LE5533 is off


CL623:
LE5507 is off
LE460 is off
Remove +X244020


CL624:
N601 -> N120/N601
LE5613 is off
LE5610 is off
LE3260 -> LE3620


CL626:
N621_N -> N621/N625
N625 -> N625_S
+X880131 is off
Exceeds limits b/n +X880131 and LE497
LE497 is off
LE493_W is off
LE3404 is off
LE3405 is off
LE3407 is off
LE481 is off
LE3416 is off
+X848216 is off
LE473 is off
LE493_E is off
LE311 is off
+X389237 is off
LE321 is off
LE3610 is off
+X350614 is off
LE234 is off
+X150052 is off
PP2299 is off
P215 is off
PP2247 is off
PP2243 is off
PP2248 is off
P227 is off
+X279804 is off
PP2128 is off
PP2121 is off
+X855356 is off


CL627:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=43.055213&lon=-4.459033
PP2173 is off
PP2112 is off
+X806634 is off


CL628:
BUV5609 is off
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=42.936061&lon=-3.566300


CL629:
N627 -> N623/N627
+X395307 is off
+X309692 is off
+X124779 is off
+X749525 is off
CL/PV is off
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=42.954870&lon=-3.558111
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=42.931063&lon=-3.575607


CL631:
13 is off
15 is off
LE463 is off
LE4309 is off
LE711 is off
LE3307 is off


CL632:
BUV5102 is off


CL633:
BU502 is off
BU502 -> BUV5021
+X163131 is off
+X872411 is off
+X908285 is off
+X209664 is off



espcl review complete!

[michih]

Reviews processed for: AR, AS, CB, CN, NC, PV, RI, VC

AR has a SELFREF issue: http://travelmapping.net/devel/datacheck.php?sys=null&rg=ESP-AR

btw: CT in another system too: http://travelmapping.net/devel/datacheck.php?sys=null&rg=ESP-CT (B40_U is quite odd for this roundabout!)

[michih]

Concurrencies:    FINE
NMPs:             NONE
Add eursf routes: NONE
wikipedia:        https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anexo:Red_de_Carreteras_de_Extremadura
wikipedia check:  FINE, see EX-100


EX100 (N523):
Existed from 1997 to 2019 but is now N523 again, see wikipedia. OSM confirms it.
+X142631 is off
EX214_W is off
BA029 is off
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=38.885425&lon=-6.979886


EX101:
EX365 -> EX364
CerRacFer -> CerRecFer
BA032/146 -> BA032 ?
BA144 is off


EX102:
CC22.5 is off
CC21.3 source? OSM indicates CC21.4, GM CC21.1, GSV nothing
+X764901 is off
+X544585 is off
NVa -> NV


EX103:
+X660713 is off
+X866549 is off
BA062 is off
EX103R is off
EX104_W is off
EX306 source? There is nothing like that... GSV has (to?) EX200


EX104:
EX352 source? OSM has no number, GM extends EX104 to the west and has a junction with EX351 here, GSV shows EX208/EX347 heading south and EX351/N430 heading north
EX349: OSM suggests it being EX115, GM does not indicate any numbering here and EX115 ends at EX351 further east. GSV indicates EX115 which can be considered as "To EX351" or as "OSM is right"
CalCal is off
AveSie is off
BA037 is off


EX105:
BA142 is off


EX105alm:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=38.617449&lon=-6.822523
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=38.622897&lon=-6.823607


EX105A3:
EX105_E -> EX105_W
EX105_W -> EX105_E


EX107:
+X351502 is off
Remove +X803750
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=38.865258&lon=-6.982895


EX108:
Concurrency broken with EX109
EXA1(1) -> A5/EXA1
AlaRio -> CalGua?
ToEX108? -> VarCor?
EX109_S is off
AveLus is off


EX108mal:
CC164 -> EXA1(16), CC is not a potential future system
CC18.2 is off
CC18.3 -> EXA1(42), CC is not a potential future system


EX109:
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=39.961497&lon=-6.514957
ToEX108 --> CC59 or VarCor?
AveLus is off


EX110:
+X231374 is off


EX112:
BA032 is off
+X401986 is off
CalVal source? I have no other label and to be honest, do we really need this wp? It's a gravel road...


EX115:
Are you sure about the start point? OSM suggests EX114 extending to EX346
Check route through Campanario, see EX104
EX348 is off


EX117:
CC174 is off
+X243791 is off
+X269061 is off


EX118:
+X818895 is off
CC20.2 is off
New wp @ http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=39.783984&lon=-5.477760
CC54 is off
CC120 is off


EX119:
N5 -> NV
Tal_S is off
Tal_S -> CarTay?
Tal_N -> CarJar?
+X912826 is off
CC135 -> CC76


espex review complete!

[michih]

Note: The last reviews were so quick because I had already checked them partially a few weeks ago

When can I start reviewing espga system?

[si404]

btw: CT in another system too: http://travelmapping.net/devel/datacheck.php?sys=null&rg=ESP-CT (B40_U is quite odd for this roundabout!)

It literally has no exits that aren't B40 - it's only there to mark the end of the autovia status, and to provide U-turns.

When can I start reviewing espga system?

No idea 

Any other business on the systems with reviews dealt with? I'm doing NMPs and datacheck stuff today.

[michih]

Any other business on the systems with reviews dealt with? I'm doing NMPs and datacheck stuff today.

I don't plan working on TM today.

[si404]

I meant beyond the datacheck, is there any more to do?

[michih]

I've only checked espex so far and have some comments:

Code: [Select]

N523 +EX100 http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=38.923660&lon=-6.942329
No alt labels for preview systems, please!

EX108:
ValCor -> VarCor

EX109:
ToEX108 --> CC59 or VarCor?

Have you missed the last one or is there any reason to keep just "ToEX108"?

Do I need to go through all systems for checking that everything is addressed?

[si404]

What about the other systems that I did earlier? Aragon, Basque Country, La Rioja, Navarre, etc? I think they are the priorities for activation, rather than the systems I dealt with last night. And I'm going to need to activate some systems, given I plan on raising espga to preview and don't want to upset Jim!

EX109:
ToEX108 --> CC59 or VarCor?

Have you missed the last one or is there any reason to keep just "ToEX108"?

Neither - I did it, and then didn't save 

[michih]

What about the other systems that I did earlier? Aragon, Basque Country, La Rioja, Navarre, etc?

That's my question. Did you revise everything or do I need to go through every single change on Github and check that all of my suggestions are addressed? That's what I did for espex today.

And I'm going to need to activate some systems, given I plan on raising espga to preview and don't want to upset Jim!

Activate imnb, jeyb and nirb first. I won't go through it again.

EX109:
ToEX108 --> CC59 or VarCor?

Have you missed the last one or is there any reason to keep just "ToEX108"?

Neither - I did it, and then didn't save 

The very same did recently happen to me with deurpl. It seems that I sometimes forget copying the changed lines from wpt editor to the wpt file